Back to search

Dublin City University

Remedial Judicial Discretion in Constitutional Review of Legislation: A Comparative Analysis

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

This PhD is about “remedies” in “constitutional review.” Constitutional review is where litigants bring a case to the superior courts (i.e., the High Court, Court of Appeal or Supreme Court) challenging the constitutionality of some exercise of state power – generally legislation. Think, for example, of legal challenges to the constitutionality of legislation prohibiting public worship during pandemics, or of constitutional challenges to legislation criminalising assisted suicide. Remedies are the practical parts of a court’s judgment which concretise a litigant’s rights. From the litigant’s perspective, they are the most important part of a court’s judgment. After all, there would be little point in claiming constitutional rights without effective remedies for their violation. The most basic remedy is a declaration of invalidity, i.e., when courts invalidate laws because they infringe constitutional rights. In recent years, however, courts have become more innovative in the remedies they use. This thesis thus explores the nature and scope of the “remedial discretion” that judges ought to enjoy where they find legislation is inconsistent with the constitution. That is, it assesses whether judges ought to enjoy greater flexibility in respect of the practical solutions available to them in cases where they find a law is unconstitutional than has traditionally been the case in constitutional democracies. The thesis is concerned with describing, analysing, and comparing existing arrangements and practice in this area of constitutional law in selected jurisdictions around the world – namely Canada, Ireland, and the United Kingdom. And it aims to inform judicial practice, institutional design, and constitutional reform. It also draws on works of constitutional and political theory in developing a series of “remedial touchstones” which serve to both ground and constrain the remedial powers available to judges in constitutional review of legislation.

Degree

thesis:*
Name dc:type.qualificationname
phd
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
doctoral
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
Dublin City University
Year dc:date.issued
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Lalor, David

Rights

Language dc:language
en

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Dublin City University
Base URL
doras.dcu.ie/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Lalor, David. Remedial Judicial Discretion in Constitutional Review of Legislation: A Comparative Analysis. doctoral thesis, Dublin City University, 2026.