The University of Edinburgh
Some observations on the uses of tuberculin reactions in diseases
Abstract
dc:description.abstractCALMETTE'S METHOD. In carrying out the series of tests by Calmette's method it does not appear that the different forms of Tuberculous diseases shew any appreciable variation in the intensity of the reaction. Some patients suffering from the disease in a very advanced and serious stage would react very intensely to the test while others equally ill would give very mild reactions. Again patients suffering from chronic Tuberculosis would generally give very intense reactions, but this was not always the case. I think it is now generally accepted that patients affected with acute forms of Tuberculosis such as Acute Miliary Tuberculosis frequently fail entirely to react with Calmette's test. In these cases, it is probable that the toxaemia is so overwhelming that the antibodies are not produced at ail, or, if produced, are so rapidly united with the toxins produced by the Tubercle Bacilli that sufficient are not present in the circulation to react with the weak Tuberculin (Antigen) used in this test. In my cases I had no experience with such severe types of the disease. Many of my patients were very seriously ill, yet all of them reacted to Calmette's test, and the reactions varied considerably in degree. My chief object in these experiments was not however to determine the presence or absence of reaction in any test but to find, out by a series of tests on each patient whether the intensity of the reactions lessened as the disease became less active and as the patient's health improved. I had to contend with one disadvantage in carrying out these tests, namely, the difficulty experienced in keeping these patients under observation for a sufficient length of time. Some of the patients who had benefited considerably under the treatment adopted would cease to attend the Hospital, and take up some regular work. This was even more noticeable in those unfortunate cases where the disease had steadily progressed in spite of all treatment. Such patients would tend to drift from one Hospital to another with the faint hope that some improvement might be obtained at one of these institutions. In a few cases, these patients could not be traced. In cases where the disease was advancing the re- actions produced at the second and final inoculations did not shew any noticeable increase of intensity from the reaction produced when the test was first tried. Usually the advance of the disease in these patients was very gradual, and it must be noted that I did not see the patients until the disease had been present for a considerable period, and load progressed to a very advanced stage. In patients where the disease had remained in status quo the reactions resulting from primary and subsequent inoculations were of equal intensity. In patients where improvement in the Tuberculous conditions had been effected, the reactions were somewhat uncertain in their variations of intensity, but in most instances they lessened as the Improvement progressed. This was very noticeable in cases where the improvement had taken place rapidly. Again in patients where a rapid improvement was maintained throughout, and cures finally established the Calmette test would give reactions which gradually decreased in intensity, and finally, after the patients had been cured, the Calmette test would fail to give any reaction provided a certain time had elapsed between the cure of the disease and the retesting. In my cases, the reactions were tested every six or twelve months, and I could not determine the length of time required after the disease had been cured, for a test to give a negative result. Judging from the results I obtained by this method, I believe that a series of tests by Calmette's method, if carefully carried out, would give satisfactory indications of the progress of the disease, since changes in the Tuberculous conditions are followed by corresponding variations in the intensity of the Calmette reaction. But Tuberculosis in any form is a disease which, if left untreated, tenets to progress to a fatal issue very gradually, though, occasionally an acute general invasion terminates the life very rapidly in the end. Similarly when the patient is success fully resisting the disease, the improvement is also slow, and gradual as a rule. If this does occur in any particular case, then we would expect to get only very slight changes in two successive Caimette reactions which have been tested at intervals of six months, hut if a series of tests are made, and the observations of the resulting reactions carefully recorded, then, though there may he only very slight differences between the first and second tests, the difference between the first and third tests may be quite appreciable. Owing to these very slight gradations in the reactions, I think that a series of tests greatly increases the "value of Calmette's method, and I would suggest that better results would be obtained if the tests and subsequent observations are made by the investigator who carried out the test primarily. I would like again to draw attention to the patients who were finally cured after prolonged treatment in most cases. In them, the reactions shew appreciable diminution, and finally, when the disease ended, the test by Calmette's method failed to give any reaction. I believe that-when such a result is produced with Calmette's test, it may he safely assumed that the patient's resistance has been sufficiently increased and that the disease has been cured. Finally, with Calmette's test as with Von Pirque t's, I think i t is very necessary that the solution of Tuberculin should be freshly prepared. VON. PIRQUET'S METHOD :- This test is probably more frequently used than any other by both physicians ana surgeons for the diagnosis of Tuberculous diseases. The reason for this, I believe, is due to the fact that its use is not followed by any ill effects such as occasionally follow the use of Calmette's test or the subcutaneous injection of Old Tuberculin. In my hands, this method used as a test, for estimating the progress of the disease gave very disappointing results. Changes in the patient's condition even though very pronounced, usually failed entirely to be followed by any variation in the intensity of the reaction obtained by Von Pirquet's method. In fact, the one outstanding feature of this test was the constancy of the intensity of the reaction. In all my patients the reaction always appeared though the time which elapsed between the inoculation and the first appearance of reaction did shew some variation. If a patient exhibited a mild reaction when first tested, then mild reactions were the rule in subsequent tests, and similarly, if the primary test gave a severe reaction, then severe reactions would appear in later tests even though marked improvement had taken place in the disease during the interval. Again, in cases where all evidence of active disease had disappeared, the Von Pirquet reaction could be readily produced even many months after the cure had been established. This feature has been constantly noticed by man}’- observers, and it is now generally considered that a positive reaction obtained by Von. Pirquet1 s method merely indicates that the patient undergoing the tests has been affected with Tuberculosis but it does not necessarily shew whether the disease is still present in an active form. In very young children, the Von. Pirquet's test as a diagnostic aid, is considered to be more reliable, but in children over three years of age and in adults a positive reaction is really of very little value. If, however, a negative is obtained with this test, then, I believe, it indicates that the patient is not now suffering from and has not in the past suffered from Tuberculosis in any form. In using this method in my patients, I frequently noticed, as I have stated above, that the time which elapsed between the inoculation and the first appearance of reaction varied considerably in different patients, and I endeavoured to find out if this feature had any bearing on the progress of the case. In the first cases which I investigated the results would appear to indicate that the reaction tends to be delayed in patients who are improving, but with other patients this feature was by no means constant, and I do not think that any value can be attached to this observation. Though delayed, the reactions always became very well marked in a few days time, and always remained for a longer period than reactions whi ch were present at the end cf 24 hours from the time of inoculation. Judging from the results of my experiments I do not believe that Von. Pirquet'6 test gives any indication as to the severity of the disease and as to the ultimate result likely to be obtained from the treatment MORRO'S TEST ;- This method, which was not introduced until after the Caimetce and Von. Pirquet^has not been used very extensively in this country. The results which I obtained with it were extremely poor and after trying it in many patients I gave up using it altogether. Most of the patients failed entirely to react, and even in those cases where reactions aid appear, the reactions were very slight,and. transient, and almost invariably subsequent tests on these patients failed to produce any reaction. In my opinion the test is of very little value. If a patient has suffered from any form of Tuberculosis, but more particularly, Tuberculosis of the Lungs, and has finally recovered, it is, I think very advisable to retest the reactions in this patient some months later. It frequently happens that the immunity which has been established in the patient is not sufficiently stable and readily breaks down under any increased strain. I have seen this occur in several patients who have been treated for early phthisis in sanatoria, and have been discharged as cured from these institutions. For the purpose of retesting either the Calmecte Method or the Subcutaneous injection of Ola Tuberculin ¡pay be used. Von Pirquet's method for reasons given above is quite useless. The Ophthalmic test by Calmette's method has many advantages. It is simple ana can be rapidly carried put, and it gives reliable results without causing the patient any serious inconvenience. Some observers believe that the injection of Ole Tuberculin in gradually increasing amounts and given at intervals of three or four days for a fortnight gives better indications. Local reaction at the seat of injection or noticeable increase in the temperature following an injection is considered to indicate a reinfection or a breaking down of the immunity. If local reaction or marked rise of temperature are produced with the first injection then it is not necessary to proceed with the larger doses. I have not tried this method myself, hut I have seen it used very considerably. It is certainly very thorough, but it requires longer time than Calmeóte's method, and if there has been any break-down in the immunity, the test with Old Tuberculin; will almost certainly cause the patient considerable discomfort, and in such a case I do not think that it is quite free from danger. For ordinary purposes I believe that the Calmeóte Test is quite sufficient.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- The University of Edinburgh
- Year dc:date.issued
- 1912
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Pearson, Arthur Bushby
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- http://hdl.handle.net/1842/33498