Abstract
dc:description.abstractIt might "be said that no treatise on cataract extraction is complete unless the vexed question of iridectomy is thoroughly discussed. I have, however, only discussed the operation from the standpoint of the average surgeon operating on patients who cannot "be kept quiet during the after treatment. Under such conditions the routine performance of iridectomy is unquestionably indicated. The cases I have quoted are for the most part unsuccessful cases because it from such examples that certain conclusions can be drawn. As I have already remarked we learn more from our failures than from our successes. The operation, by whatever method, is on the whole highly successful - so that, in judging of the frequency of an accident, such as prolapse,we may have several hundred cases free from prolapse and then several cases of prolapse in quick succession. Therefore before drawing conclusions from our successes we must have a very large number of cases to go upon. The cases I have included have been taken verbatim from notes made "by myself at the time of operation. In the different hospitals I have had charge of the eye cases have always been my chief interest and I nave never had too much work to allow me to treat and report all my cataract cases personally from first to last. From this I exclude a few cases operated on at outlying dispensaries. In this connection I may say something of the remarkable series published by Smith. Vide table 1. I know Jullundur district very well having visited most of the villages when I was district plague medical officer. I have seen scores of Smith results and I have often watched him operating. There is no doubt that he is a highly successful operator but there are the following flaws in his argument. (1). Before his claims regarding extraction in the capsule are proved, he must show that eyes with vitreous loss remain sound - he must disprove the logical inference that detachment of the retina is a frequent result of vitreous loss. (2). In his discussion on the figures quoted in Table 1 Smith forestalls criticism thus "I have been told that it is impossible to do such an amount of work and do it scientifically I see the cases, almost all, when leaving hospital. At both ends of our throng season, I have ample time to examine the cases leaving hospital as regards refraction, but in the "throngest" (sic) times spectacles are fitted by one of the dressers who can do it well." The admission that, from pressure of work, he has to leave even a small part of the examining and testing of operated cases to native ^subordinates detracts from the value of the figures; without casting any reflection on the soundness of the practice. From a large experience of native medical subordinates I can emphatically say, that when the reputation of their official superior is at stake their judgment and reporting of results is apt to be inaccurate. The scientific mind is rare among them.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- The University of Edinburgh
- Date dc:date.issued
- 1893
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Scott-Moncrieff, W. E.
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- http://hdl.handle.net/1842/33868