Back to search

The University of Edinburgh

Urinary infection and oral penicillin G

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

1. A review of the literature on the absorption of oral penicillin and its excretion, the relative importance of serum and urine levels of antibiotics in the treatment of pyelonephritis, and on the penicillin sensitivity of Gram -negative urinary pathogens is given, and it includes a comment on the published cases of Gram- negative urinary infection treated with oral penicillin. There are also assessments of the laboratory diagnosis of urinary infection in patients consulting general practitioners, and of the importance of this disease in general practice. Penicillin resistance is discussed with particular reference to the development of penicillinase- producing resistant mutants, and an account of some recent experiments with an in-vitro model bladder is given. 2. Studies with six volunteers demonstrated that the oral administration of a single dose of 500 mg of penicillin G produced mean urine levels of 500 }ig of penicillin per ml in the first 2 hours, and that in the urine secreted between the 4th and 6th hours after the dose the mean concentrations were 40 1g per ml. Serum concentrations were approximately 1000 times less. Three different preparations of oral penicillin were examined in a cross over trial, and the cheapest, which was "Crystapen G" (potassium penicillin G) was found to be the best. 3. The penicillin sensitivity of 969 strains was measured. These included 502 consecutive strains isolated from patients with urinary infections who were attending their general practitioners, 48 strains from antenatal patients with bacteriuria , 243 strains from patients with urinary infections in hospital, and 176 strains from the faeces of healthy adults. There were in all 608 strains of Escherichia coli, 106 strains of Proteus, 12 of Ps. aeruginosa and 35 strains of Gram -positive cocci. Eighty three per cent. were sensitive either to a specially developed filter paper disk, containing 100 pg of penicillin, in a disk - diffusion test, or to 50 }ag per ml in a tube -dilution test. The results of these two tests were found to be equivalent. 4. All the penicillin -resistant strains produced free penicillinase, whereas none of the penicillin -sensitive strains did so under normal conditions. A sensitive strain was found to produce small quantities of bound penicillinase under normal conditions, and small amounts of free penicillinase when incubated for seven days. Sensitive strains grown in sub- lethal concentrations of penicillin were found to become penicillin- resistant, and two out of three such strains became free penicillinase producers. The mean inhibitory concentration of one of these strains increased from 25 to 5000 )Zg of penicillin per ml. The changes in penicillin sensitivity were stable on culture in penicillin -free media and on storage. 5. A computer was used to test the relationship between penicillin resistance and ampicillin resistance, and also to investigate possible links between the resistance of other pairs of antibiotics. There was among the urinary strains of E. coli evidence of an association of resistance between streptomycin and sulphonamide and between streptomycin and tetracycline, and to a lesser extent between tetracycline and sulphonamide. 6. An in-vitro model bladder was set up and the rapid elimination of penicillin sensitive Gram- negative urinary pathogens was observed when they were exposed to concentrations of penicillin similar to those shown to occur in the volunteers and patients. A strain of E. coli resistant to the concentrations of penicillin achieved in the bladder was also shown to suffer bacteriolysis. When the residual infected volume is being diluted the bacilli appear to be peculiarly sensitive to penicillin. 7. The method of testing the urine of patients attending general practitioners was examined. The dip-inoculum method was exhaustively tested in the laboratory and clinically. The difference in the relationship between the viable count as performed by a surface counting technique and the spoon count for strains of Gram-negative bacilli and Staph. aureus was shown to be due to clumping of the staphylococci. 8. The inoculation of the spoon by passing it through the uninterrupted stream of urine during micturition was tested, and though marginally less accurate in theory, it did not prove to be so in practice, and the method was considered to have considerable advantages. These were the ease with which the mid- stream specimen of even a small stream of urine could be sampled, the absence of discomfort or difficulty for the patient, and the lack of a need for a container in which to collect the urine. 9. The use of oral penicillin G was tested in four patients who developed bacteriuria while recovering from gynecological operations. The immediate response to treatment was encouraging, but unfortunately these patients could not be followed up adequately. 10. A single patient with acute urinary infection caused by a pure strain of Escherichia coli sensitive to 25 pg of penicillin per ml was given a single dose of 500 mg of penicillin by mouth, and her clinical and bacteriological response was followed for two days. The viable count of bacilli per ml of urine was reduced from 2.72 x 107 to 32 bacilli per ml over 5 hours, but after 12 hours it had returned almost to pre -treatment levels. The clinical improvement was considerable and maintained for nearly two days and then relapsed quickly. A course of penicillin G 500 mg 6 hourly by mouth was started and continued for four weeks. The clinical and bacteriological response, though slower than after the first dose was nevertheless steady and complete. No alteration in the sensitivity of the infecting organism to penicillin was noted. 11. A second patient, a child, with an acute Gram -negative urinary infection was treated with a five day course of oral penicillin G, 500 mg per day in divided doses. Clinical and bacteriological improvement was dramatic and complete. 12. A clinical trial of the use of oral penicillin G was established with the aid of 15 general practitioners. Five hundred and thirty patients were involved, of whom 242 were shown to be infected and were treated and followed up. Ninety four were treated with penicillin and 57 with sulphonamides, thirty of the former and 29 of the latter being treated 'double- blind' with specially formulated tablets. The remaining 91 patients were treated with other drugs. Follow -up analyses of the urine were performed in the third and seventh week after diagnosis. Therapy with penicillin was compared with sulphonamide and was found to be marginally better when the results were compared immediately after treatment stopped, and marginally worse after 7 weeks. The differences were not significant. The results were also compared with the smaller number of cases treated with other drugs, and were analysed according to age and a history of previous infection. 13. Clinical and bacteriological cures were compared, and it was found that there was no correlation between the subjective opinion that treatment had been successful and the bacteriological record of elimination of bacteriuria. Continuing symptoms were however, a reliable indication of the failure of treatment. 14. The general conclusion is that penicillin is the cheapest, and in many ways the best 'broad -spectrum' antibiotic for the treatment of Gram-negative urinary tract infection.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
The University of Edinburgh
Year dc:date.issued
1971

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Hulbert, John

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Handle dc:identifier.uri
http://hdl.handle.net/1842/34701

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Hulbert, John. Urinary infection and oral penicillin G. The University of Edinburgh, 1971. http://hdl.handle.net/1842/34701