Back to search

The University of Edinburgh

Neck of humerus fractures: epidemiology, predictors of nonunion and classification

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Proximal humerus fractures are common, accounting for 5% of fractures to the appendicular skeleton. Neck of humerus fractures (NHF) account for approximately 80% of all fractures of the proximal humerus – the remainder being isolated fractures of the greater, or lesser tuberosity. NHF should be considered as a separate entity to isolated tuberosity fracture as both injuries have distinct epidemiological characteristics, natural history and treatment principles. Despite this, many of the studies which form the basis for our understanding of NHF are in series which include all proximal humerus fractures. There are important unanswered questions regarding the epidemiology and determinants of outcome of NHF, and no robust evidence base to guide their management. Furthermore, there is no existing fracture classification system that is of proven value in predicting outcome. As a consequence, patients with similar injuries may receive very different opinions about the severity of their fracture, its likely prognosis, and its best treatment, dependent on the unit in which they are treated and the surgeon who treats them. This thesis aims to investigate the epidemiology of NHF, identify the prevalence and risk factors for nonunion and develop and evaluate a novel fracture classification. In CHAPTER 2 the study setting and method of case ascertainment was described. In CHAPTER 3 and CHAPTER 4, a large prospective database of 2,368 fractures collected over 7 years was used to define the epidemiology of NHF. Radiographs for these factures were analysed and the prevalence of nonunion was determined. Multiple logistic regression analysis of the data was performed to identify those radiographic factors that are prognostic of nonunion. The statistical method used provided weighted significance for each of those factors, and thus a mathematical formula predictive of nonunion was constructed. In CHAPTER 5 a novel classification for NHF based on clinically relevant fracture patterns and radiographic predictors of nonunion was described. In CHAPTER 6 and CHAPTER 7 a second database of 419 fractures collected over a one-year period was used to prospectively to evaluate the novel fracture classification as well as the mathematical formula’s ability to predict nonunion. NHF occurred predominantly in the older female patient following a simple fall. The prevalence of nonunion was 7.1%. Worsening social deprivation and cigarette smoking were the patient factors associated with nonunion. The radiographic predictors of nonunion were increasing humeral head-shaft translation, increasing varus angulation of the humeral head, separation at the fracture and absence of an associated tuberosity fracture. A mathematical formula for predicating nonunion was developed based on these risk factors. The formula performed well when evaluated on a second prospectively collected dataset. A novel fracture classification was described based on clinically relevant fracture patterns and the radiographic predictors of nonunion. The majority of fractures had a ‘stable’ configuration according to the novel classification. Fractures with a ‘stable’ configuration had a very low rate of nonunion and fractures with an ‘unstable’ configuration had a higher rate of nonunion. In summary, the prevalence of nonunion after NHF has been established. Risk factors for nonunion have been identified and a predictive formula has been developed which could improve patient counselling and decision making in fracture management. A novel prognostic fracture classification has been introduced which could facilitate better comparison between individual fracture subtypes in future studies.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
The University of Edinburgh
Year dc:date.issued
2020

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Goudie, Ewan Barclay
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Simpson, Hamish
  • White, Tim
  • Robinson, Mike

Subjects

dc:subject × 5

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Goudie, Ewan Barclay. Neck of humerus fractures: epidemiology, predictors of nonunion and classification. The University of Edinburgh, 2020. https://hdl.handle.net/1842/36972