The University of Edinburgh
Exploring clinical decision-making processes in dentistry
Abstract
dc:description.abstractINTRODUCTION: Dental education today is charged with the important responsibility of helping dental students gain effective clinical decision-making skills. To date, there appears to be limited understanding of how dental students and dentists make clinical decisions in relation to actual clinical situations. It is crucial to understand clinical decision-making processes in dentistry to enhance the development of clinical decision-making skills of dental students. This study aimed to explore the clinical decision-making processes of dental students and dentists, possible factors influencing their clinical decision-making, and develop the models to explain the processes in dentistry. METHODOLOGY AND METHODS: Critical realism was used as the philosophical and methodological frameworks of the study to look at the nature of reality in dental practice in complex situations, with social interactions between dentists and environment. The frameworks were also employed to identify factors influencing clinical decision-making processes that acted as underlying mechanisms to generate outcomes as clinical decisions. There were two main phases in this study. In Phase 1, video recording and video-elicitation interviews were used to explore the clinical decision-making processes of 40 participants from different levels of dental expertise while making oral diagnoses and treatment plans for real dental patients. Then, semi-structured interviews were conducted to identify various influencing factors that could affect their clinical decisions. In Phase 2, the findings from Phase 1 were used to develop models of the clinical decision-making processes. The models were subsequently validated through 31 participants from 6 focus groups. Thematic analysis was employed to analyse the data and explain the relationships and interconnections between codes and themes. RESULTS: The dual-process theory was useful to explain the clinical decision-making processes in dentistry. All participants used pattern recognition, heuristics, analytical thinking and metacognition in different ways to formulate and confirm oral diagnoses and treatment plans. The diagnostic and treatment planning processes in different participant groups were compared in terms of similarities and differences of the processes. Various factors from dentists, patients and the environment, including complex interactions among those factors were identified. Additionally, some cognitive biases and errors were found during the study. The models of clinical decision-making developed in this study could reflect dentists’ daily dental practice and could be used to improve dentists’ and dental students’ clinical decision-making skills. CONCLUSION: The clinical decision-making processes in dentistry are complex, interactive and iterative. It is important to understand these processes to develop the conceptual models to explain the processes. This research can be the first step in providing strategies for improving the clinical decision-making skills of dental students and dentists through the models, which can enhance the quality of oral care and patient safety.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- The University of Edinburgh
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Nakhapaksirat, Dechsak
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Foley, Jennifer
- Lent, Neil
Subjects
dc:subject × 5Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- http://dx.doi.org/10.7488/era/1804