Back to search

The University of Edinburgh

Health care seeking practices and barriers to health care seeking for suspected pneumonia in children aged less than five years in tribal and non-tribal rural areas of Pune district, India

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

BACKGROUND: Pneumonia continues to be a major cause of mortality and morbidity in children globally. In 2015 and India, Nigeria, Indonesia, Pakistan, and China contributed to more than 54% of all global pneumonia cases, while 49% of global pneumonia deaths occurred in India, Nigeria, Pakistan, Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Ethiopia collectively. India had the highest number of episodes of clinical pneumonia (32% of all episodes in developing countries). Seeking care from health care providers is a crucial step which can potentially determine the prognosis of the illness. Children who have pneumonia and do not receive adequate and timely treatment have an increased risk of mortality. Few studies conducted in different parts of India that looked at care sought for childhood illnesses reported that proportions of parents seeking care ranged from 65% to more than 90%. Factors that determine care seeking behaviour of parents as well as the exact care seeking pathways are not very well-understood in India, especially in tribal areas, which are not as well developed as non-tribal areas. A contextual understanding of these challenges becomes important to identify potential interventions to improve health care seeking, for which I used two methods in my thesis, a systematic review of relevant literature from low and middle income countries and a study conducted in Pune, India in which I collected data on health care seeking practices for children aged less than five years with suspected pneumonia. AIMS: The aims of my PhD thesis were (i) to systematically review health care seeking practices of and barriers to health care seeking for pneumonia in children aged less than five years in low and middle income countries (ii) locally, in India’s Pune district, to determine common health care seeking practices and identify factors that facilitate and hinder health care seeking for children under the age of five years with pneumonia symptoms, with a comparison between rural tribal and rural non-tribal areas. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW: I conducted a systematic review with an aim to assess health care seeking practices of caregivers, i.e., individuals who are primarily take care of children aged less than five years, in suspected and confirmed cases of pneumonia in low and middle income (LMIC) countries and factors that affected health care seeking practices. The search yielded 10,823 articles, of which, 27 studies met the inclusion criteria. The pooled proportions of care seeking from any provider and from qualified health care provider for children aged under five years with suspected pneumonia in LMICs were 76.7% (95% confidence interval, CI=70.3 to 83.1) and 69% (95% CI=53.5 to 84.5), respectively. Studies conducted in urban settings had a higher proportion of care sought from qualified providers (92.3%, 85% CI = 86.2 to 98.2) compared to studies in rural settings (58.8%, 95% CI = 37.4 to 80.3). Factors associated with care seeking included the child's gender, age, care-givers` socio-economic status and use of traditional medicines. The proportion of care-givers seeking health care for childhood pneumonia in LMICs is still relatively low, particularly in rural areas. A greater understanding is required about factors that drive caregivers to seek care for childhood pneumonia. Design of the study conducted in tribal and non-tribal rural areas in Pune district, India I conducted a population-based cross-sectional survey among households with children aged between two months to 59 months in tribal and non-tribal rural villages in Pune district. Households with at least one child aged between two to 59 months who have had cough and difficulty in breathing at any time and for any length of duration during three months before data collection were eligible for inclusion in the study. SAMPLING STRATEGY: Sample size was calculated to be 350 in each area, thus resulting in total sample size of 700 children. In the study I collected data from 702 eligible children. To select my study participants, I employed a simple random sampling method, as a line-list of all under-five children was available in both study areas. STUDY VARIABLES: Data regarding socio-demographic characteristics, actual illness details about which care seeking was explored, details about care sought from all health care providers sequentially including the details of treatment sought, outcomes and duration of treatment at each provider. If no care was sought at all, the same was recorded. This section also included questions regarding factors determining care-seeking behaviour, including reasons for not seeking care at all. RESULTS: Health care seeking practices: For the complete study population, 88% of the respondents sought care from a health care provider (HCP) for their child`s illness episode. Of the 82 respondents who did not seek care, almost 80% said that they either thought that the illness would improve by itself or that the illness did not need treatment from a health care provider. Almost 80% of those who sought care visited a private health care facility, while only 2% respondents sought care from a non-qualified provider, i.e., an HCP without any approved medical degree. Commonest reasons for visiting an HCP included faith in the provider`s capabilities (51%) and positive previous experience with the provider (27%). Easier accessibility to provider made up around 8% of all responses. Almost 6% respondents visited a second health care provider for the illness episode. For the complete study population, home remedies were given to 26% of all children, irrespective of whether they sought health care or not. Some aspects of care-seeking practices differed among the two study populations. While 91% tribal respondents sough health care, this proportion was around 86% among non-tribal rural study participants. What differed greatly was the choice of health care provider, with around 35% tribal respondents visiting a government health facility compared to 5% non-tribal respondents. The next significant difference was proportion of hospitalizations, with 21% of children in the tribal study population hospitalized compared to 1% in the non-tribal population. Another difference was seen in the proportion of children given home remedies with around 38% children in non-tribal study population given some kind of home remedy compared to 10% children in tribal population. Factors associated with health care seeking: For the complete study population, when included in a multivariable regression analysis, perceived severity of breathing difficulty was statistically associated with greater likelihood of seeking health care. Perceived severity of illness is a major driver of health care seeking as seen from my study, with parents who perceived their child`s symptoms of breathing difficulty as severe statistically more likely to seek health care. When I analyzed association of other factors considering similar severity level of illness using a multivariable regression, it was seen that households belonging to poorer wealth quintile were significantly more likely to seek health care for the complete study population, i.e., when four quintiles, poorest, poorer, middle and richer were compared to the richest quintile as the reference category, only the poorer quintile was statistically more likely to seek care. No other factor was significantly associated with health care seeking. Factors associated with choice of HCP: : Regarding choice of HCP, when adjusting for perceived illness severity in a multivariable regression analysis , it was seen that accessibility to HCP was directly associated with choosing a government health facility compared to a private health facility ; in addition, respondents who had studied up to middle school compared to those who had studied up to higher grades, those who were currently working and those who were sole owners of any land, were significantly more likely to visit a government health facility, while respondents those who were owners of any property were significantly less likely to do so compared to those who did not own any property. Caregivers of children with age between 13 to 24 months were significantly more likely to choose the HCP because of their confidence in the provider`s abilities compared to children aged more than 24 months, but not with children aged less than 12 months. Accessibility as a reason for choice of HCP was more likely to be associated with visiting a government HCP. It was seen that households from the richer wealth quintile were significantly more likely to choose the health provider because of confidence in the provider`s abilities. In conclusion, in the systematic review, it was seen that in low and middle income countries, the pooled estimate of health care seeking for suspected pneumonia in children aged less than five years was 76.7%, however, with a wide heterogeneity across studies. In the Pune study, while the overall proportion of health care seeking was fairly high, differences in choice of health care provider were seen between the tribal and non-tribal rural study populations. Perceived severity of illness determined decision to seek care while tribal communities preferred government health facility, probably due to reduced cost of treatment and accessibility. Previous experience with an HCP was the commonest reason for visiting the HCP again. These findings show that health care seeking for childhood suspected pneumonia is varied and contextual. Any intervention to improve health care seeking should address these contextual factors.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
The University of Edinburgh
Year dc:date.issued
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Roy, Sudipto
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Chan, Kit
  • Nwaru, Bright
  • Rudan, Igor

Subjects

dc:subject × 9

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Handle dc:identifier.uri
https://hdl.handle.net/1842/41127

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Roy, Sudipto. Health care seeking practices and barriers to health care seeking for suspected pneumonia in children aged less than five years in tribal and non-tribal rural areas of Pune district, India. The University of Edinburgh, 2023. https://hdl.handle.net/1842/41127