Back to search

The University of Edinburgh

Magnetic resonance elastography: a novel imaging technique to assess knee joint function using a bespoke loading device in patients undergoing total knee replacement

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

The knee joint is a complex synovial joint that relies on surrounding musculature for optimal functioning. The stability of the knee joint during its range of movement is dependent on static and dynamic stabilisers. The static stabilisers of the knee are made up of passive structures such as the menisci, ligaments (cruciate and collateral) and the bony anatomy of the knee. The dynamic stability of the knee is influenced by the neuromuscular performance characteristics of the overlying muscles. The overall strength (magnitude of force produced) of the knee joint musculature is important. However, contemporary research describes that the speed of muscle activation and the rate of force production is equally important for dynamic joint stabilisation. The viscoelasticity of the dynamic stabilisers of the knee can influence neuromuscular performance characteristics such as electromechanical delay (EMD) and the rate of force development (RFD). Electromyography has been able to offer some insights of neuromuscular performance, however it is unable to quantify viscoelastic properties of muscle. To date, there is no ‘gold standard' method of measuring the mechanical properties of tissues in vivo. Total knee replacements (TKR) are a well-established treatment for patients with end stage osteoarthritis who have failed conservative treatment. The outcome following TKR is generally very good in the vast majority of patients and is dependent on many factors including patient factors, surgeon factors and prosthesis design. Patient engagement with muscle rehabilitation programmes play a crucial role in achieving a good outcome. Muscle balance refers to the relationship between muscle force produced by antagonistic muscle groups around an articulation. In the lower limb the most frequently used parameter to describe muscle balance around the knee is the hamstring to quadriceps (H:Q) ratio. The H:Q ratio has been extensively studied in athletes to detect muscle imbalance and to act as a screening tool for injury prevention and rehabilitation. Understanding the intricate relationship between antagonistic muscle pairs could offer important insights into muscle recovery following surgery. Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is a novel imaging technique for quantitatively assessing the mechanical properties of tissue. The elasticity of tissue is quantified using a combination of MRI and assessing the propagation of shear waves through the tissues. MRE allows non-invasive quantification of the shear stiffness of tissues and is highly sensitive to changes in the mechanical properties. Skeletal muscle has anisotropic properties and its stiffness changes depending on its contractile state. The stress-strain relationship of muscles and the interaction with surrounding connective tissues is integral to knee joint function. The aim of this thesis was to investigate the sensitivity, reproducibility and utility of MRE to detect change in muscle mechanical properties around the knee through a series of clinically relevant experiments. The validity and utility of MRE as an assessment tool for muscle stiffness and as a proxy marker of knee joint muscle function has been explored. The measurement characteristics of MRE and the relationship with objective indices of neuromuscular function have been systematically evaluated in both a healthy asymptomatic population, and an OA population prior to and following TKR surgery. Initial work focussed on protocol development of MRE data acquisition and analysis protocols at the Clinical Research Imaging Centre (CRIC) in Edinburgh. This was to ensure a repeatable and robust protocol could then be applied to healthy volunteers, patients with end stage osteoarthritis and patients post total knee replacement (TKR). The development of a muscle loading device allowed investigation into the intricate relationship between antagonistic muscle groups to further our understanding of muscle co-activation and recruitment patterns during loading. The MRE data acquisition protocol and analysis technique has offered reliable and repeatable results. The complex shear modulus |G*| MRE output measure gave the most repeatable results (Intraclass correlation coefficient, ICC=0.956, P<0.001). The average coefficient of variation in measurement values between scans for different raters ranged between 4.7% to 7.5%. The ‘region of interest’ (ROI) analysis method has also shown very high inter-rater reliability as measured by the ICC (0.977, P<0.001). A strong significant correlation between muscle stiffness |G*| and muscle loading was observed for both quadriceps (R2=0.781 (p<0.001)) and hamstrings (R2=0.680 (p=0.004)). The MRE Hecc:Qcon ratio decreased as the knee extensor resistance loads increased during knee extension. Conversely during knee flexion, the MRE Hcon:Qecc ratio increased as the knee flexor resistance loads increased. These results confirm that the muscle MRE can be used as a sensitive tool for measuring muscle engagement. The MRE loading device has allowed investigation into the hamstring to quadriceps ratio as marker of muscle balance around the knee. Following TKR, significant muscle atrophy was observed post operatively with reduction in muscle size affecting the quadriceps (-13%; p=.044), hamstrings (-18%; p=.012), and adductors (-23%; p=.013). The overall resting muscle stiffness was significantly higher post TKR surgery in all muscle groups; quadriceps (+31%; p=.003), hamstrings (+32%; p=.050) and most notably in the adductors (+62%; p=.040) and medials (+63%; p=0.007). This thesis has demonstrated that muscle MRE is a reproducible and sensitive diagnostic tool to obtain information on muscle mechanical properties in vivo, in healthy volunteers and patients with TKR in situ. MRE can offer insight into muscle function with great potential for it to be used in various clinical settings. Objective measurement of muscle stiffness could aid our understanding of muscle physiology and recovery in the peri-operative period. Monitoring muscle stiffness in patients with neuromuscular conditions such as cerebral palsy or stroke could lead to targeted muscle rehabilitation programs. MRE is a completely novel means to investigate muscle physiology allowing clinicians to monitor response to treatment and could facilitate clinical decision-making concerning the need for early and targeted pre- and rehabilitation. This personalisation of therapy could lead to improved dynamic stability around the knee and ultimately improve outcomes following TKR.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
The University of Edinburgh
Year dc:date.issued
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Simons, Michiel Robert
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Biant, Leela
  • Roberts, Neil

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Simons, Michiel Robert. Magnetic resonance elastography: a novel imaging technique to assess knee joint function using a bespoke loading device in patients undergoing total knee replacement. The University of Edinburgh, 2023. https://hdl.handle.net/1842/41224