Back to search

The University of Edinburgh

Construction of publics: an examination of how visions of digital health technologies shape publics' potential roles in governance practices of such technologies

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Digital health technologies (DHTs) and their associated uses of data play an increasing role in health settings, ranging from the provision of healthcare to the management of health services. DHTs can, thus, have a considerable impact on individuals, communities, and societies. These impacts can be both positive (e.g., improving treatment and diagnosis methods) and negative (e.g., raising ethical concerns relating to the uses of data such as privacy infringements). Despite the impact of DHTs on publics and their reliance on publics’ data and use, the extent to which publics have a say in shaping these DHTs is limited and often restricted by factors beyond their control, such as governments’ agendas or organisations’ time and monetary constraints. Using different methodologies – namely, social network analysis, documentary analysis, and semi-structured interviews – this thesis provides a novel study of discourses of DHTs in global, national, and local policy contexts. The aim of this research is not to analyse the ways in which publics may use DHTs for the provision of their own healthcare. Instead, it is concerned with examining and enrichening our understanding of how future-oriented and prospective framings of DHTs (referred in this thesis as ‘visions’), identified in policy discourses, may influence how publics can be involved, and the roles they can play in the governance of these technologies. Based on results from my analysis, visions of DHTs identified in policy discourses centre notions of public participation around the engagement of publics with their own health through DHT and increased data access. This approach enrols publics in visions of DHTs by giving them a role as users of these technologies and enablers of healthcare transformation (thus achieving their support and acceptance for DHTs). This takes place whilst distracting publics away from their involvement in governance debates, such as how, when and for what purposes DHTs and data are being used. Those unwilling or unable to use DHTs or to agree to their data being used are framed as threatening the realisation of visions of DHTs and perceived as lacking the sufficient knowledge to understand the technologies. Participatory activities are, therefore, aimed at gaining their support. I argue that dominant visions of DHTs limit the sites for reflective and meaningful dialogues relating to the governance of DHTs by regulating the types of publics that can be involved in governance processes, and the nature of that involvement. This thesis contributes to debates on the implications of DHTs (and their associated uses of data) for citizens by problematising the extent to which promises of patient empowerment and personalisation associated with visions of DHTs may lead to improved public involvement in the governance of these technologies. Moreover, it enriches our knowledge of the ways in which such visions can shape the roles that publics are expected (or allowed) to play in the governance of these technologies. In doing so, this thesis highlights the importance of understanding the intersection between DHTs, publics and practices of participatory governance for the achievement of meaningful participatory activities for the governance of DHTs.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
The University of Edinburgh
Year dc:date.issued
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • González Hernando, Esther
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Sethi, Nayha
  • Engelmann, Lukas
  • Pickersgill, Martyn

Subjects

dc:subject × 3

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

González Hernando, Esther. Construction of publics: an examination of how visions of digital health technologies shape publics' potential roles in governance practices of such technologies. The University of Edinburgh, 2024. https://hdl.handle.net/1842/42155