Back to search

The University of Edinburgh

What we teach medical students about ‘difficult’ patients in the context of clinical reasoning. an emergency department case study

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Introduction: Clinical reasoning describes the thinking and decision-making that occurs in medical practice. When the process goes awry, it can lead to diagnostic errors, potentially resulting in patient harm. It is understood from the broader decision-making literature that emotion and decision making are intertwined. Thus, clinicians’ emotions are likely to moderate their clinical reasoning. In clinical practice, patients are a key source of emotion. This work considers a cohort of patients, often termed ‘difficult,’ describing those who engender negative emotional responses in the clinicians providing their care. It is recognised that such patients may be more likely to be misdiagnosed and are therefore at risk of harm. Despite acknowledgement of the role that emotion can have in clinical reasoning and its patient safety implications, the topic is not well attended to in undergraduate medical curricula. To help address this, this thesis looks to ascertain what we currently teach medical students regarding the role of emotion in clinical reasoning using difficult patients as a stimulus. It further explores if and how it could be done better and makes suggestions about how this important topic could be approached in the future. The following research questions were posed: 1.What non-clinical factors contribute towards clinician perception of ‘difficulty’? 2.Do clinicians who perceive a patient as ‘difficult' believe that their clinical reasoning is subsequently altered? 3.What do medical students in the ED learn about ‘difficult’ patients specifically regarding how such a perception impacts on clinician clinical reasoning? 4.How might we better teach around the subject of emotion in the context of clinical reasoning? Methods: The overarching approach was that of a case study based in a university-affiliated Emergency Department (ED) in Scotland. Four distinct studies were undertaken to address the research questions. The first study looked to answer the first research question and ascertain what the literature said about non-clinical factors rendering patients difficult for their healthcare provider. It took the form of a rapid literature review. The second study aimed to gain a contemporary understanding of ‘difficult patients’ in a local context. It also addressed the second research question exploring if clinicians felt that their clinical reasoning was altered because of a perception of difficulty. It used focus groups of Emergency Medicine clinicians to do this. The third study used focus groups to consider the perspectives of final-year medical students attached to the ED. It aimed to answer the third research question by appreciating what medical students learned about difficult patients and emotion as it pertains to clinical reasoning. The fourth and final study explored clinicians’ perspectives regarding the teaching of emotion as it relates to clinical reasoning, answering the fourth research question. It used semi-structured interviews. All focus group and interview data were analysed via Reflexive Thematic Analysis. Ethical approval was granted by the University of Edinburgh Medical Ethics Committee. Results and Discussion: Question 1: What non-clinical factors contribute towards clinician perception of ‘difficulty’? Twenty-four studies were identified from the literature that considered non-clinical factors rendering patients challenging in the eyes of their care provider. Only eight of those were conducted in the last two decades, two by the same author. Amongst others, patients perceived as demanding, manipulative, angry, or non-compliant and those who frequently used healthcare services were found to be difficult. Five focus groups, involving 25 ED clinicians echoed some of these findings and illustrated that frequent attenders to the ED, patients whose expectations differed from that of their care provider and patients who altered the care provider–patient power dynamic were among the non-clinical factors perceived as challenging. However, these factors were found to be moderated by clinician-specific elements such as experience, personality and the situation in which the healthcare encounter occurred. This supports more recent conceptualisations of ‘difficult’ patients recognising that these patients do not exist in isolation. Question 2: Do clinicians who perceive a patient as ‘difficult' believe that their clinical reasoning is subsequently altered? The focus group study of ED clinicians found that the participants felt that their clinical reasoning was at times adversely impacted by their perception of certain patients as difficult. This is in line with prior work in healthcare and the wider psychology literature and although was self-reported, has important patient safety implications. Question 3: What do medical students in the ED learn about ‘difficult’ patients specifically regarding how such a perception impacts on clinician clinical reasoning? Across four focus groups, 20 medical students reported no explicit teaching regarding the role of emotion in clinical reasoning. Despite this, through their experiences they learned a lot. They observed times they believed negative emotion towards a patient was detrimental to a clinician’s reasoning. They further learned that emotion is most commonly managed through suppression or compartmentalisation. The concept of emotional detachment and distancing is not uncommon in clinical practice and this thesis supports this. The implicit learning described by the students is known in healthcare as the hidden curriculum. The hidden curriculum has been shown to have a powerful influence in other domains including career choice and professionalism. Although this work acknowledged the power of the hidden curriculum, it found that students are not passive participants in it but are active learners - they can choose to accept or reject the messages implied from their observations. Social cognitive theories are a group of theories that, amongst other things, recognise that students are not passive receivers of information but are able to exert choice in accepting or rejecting what is observed. They provide a useful lens to consider how students learn about the impact of emotion in clinical reasoning. Question 4: How might we better teach around the subject of emotion in the context of clinical reasoning? Greater transparency and normalisation regarding clinician emotion were highlighted as ways that learning in this area could be advanced by the medical students in the third study. Interviews with 12 senior ED clinicians in the fourth study showed that although the clinicians comprehended that being emotionally candid had possible benefits to learners, their fear of the consequences such as peer judgement prevented them being so. However, teaching students about the normality of frustration and its theoretically deleterious consequences was felt to be imperative. The clinicians considered greater self-insight as well as formalising teaching around emotion as promising strategies through which to do so. Conclusion: This work suggests learning about emotion in clinical reasoning is largely through the hidden curriculum. Students are taught emotion is something that is ‘seen but not heard.’ Within the clinical reasoning domain, they can see that it impacts decision making but that it is generally not acknowledged nor explicitly taught. Normalising emotion, formalising teaching around its moderating impact on clinical reasoning and having more candid clinical role models are ways in which this work suggests we could better teach around the subject.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
The University of Edinburgh
Year dc:date.issued
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Roy, Susie
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Jaap, Alan
  • Skinner, Janet

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Roy, Susie. What we teach medical students about ‘difficult’ patients in the context of clinical reasoning. an emergency department case study. The University of Edinburgh, 2024. https://hdl.handle.net/1842/42709