Back to search

The University of Edinburgh

Use of metaphyseal sleeves to address bone loss in revision total knee arthroplasty

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

The rate of revision total knee arthroplasty is projected to increase by more than 300% between 2005 and 2030. This is due to a combination of ever-increasing number of primary procedures and increasing life expectancy of the population. Whilst survivorship of primary TKA has been well investigated, there has not yet been an ideal method for revision total knee arthroplasty with favourable long-term results. One of the most challenging aspects of revision total knee arthroplasty is managing bone loss, a number of techniques have been investigated with varying success, including augmentation with cement, bone graft and modular augmentation with blocks or wedges. This thesis aims to examine the use of metaphyseal sleeves through a series of retrospective, biomechanical and radiographical investigations. A prospective database of patients undergoing metaphyseal sleeve revision total knee arthroplasty over a ten-year period was developed. This database was used to report on the outcomes of the surgery, the primary long-term outcomes were implant survival and infection rates. To further evaluate the performance of the metaphyseal sleeve, a radiographical analysis was carried out to compare stability of the implant. Osteolysis and Subsidence were examined on 100 sequential radiographs by 3 users. Inter and intra-observer variability was measured. A subgroup analysis was then performed to investigate if there was any difference in outcomes of patients who received a metaphyseal sleeve only versus a sleeve and intramedullary stem. Finally, a cadaveric biomechanical study was performed using nine cadaveric tibias with simulated increasing bone loss to assess this effect on stability. For the retrospective study 120 metaphyseal sleeves were matched to 120 patients from the SAP database and 120 patients who underwent primary TKA in the same institution. Implant survivorship at 5 and 10 years was 98.3% for metaphyseal sleeves and 89.8% and 88.1% for the SAP control (p=0.0016). Metaphyseal sleeves had significantly higher overall implant survivorship across all time periods. There were 4 patients in the metaphyseal sleeve group and 5 in the SAP control group who had prosthetic joint infection (p=0.64). Oxford knee score was 33.4 for the metaphyseal sleeves and 35.7 for primary TKA. ROM was 98.1 degrees for the metaphyseal sleeves and 112.4 for the primary TKA. There was no significant difference in clinical outcomes, radiographic stability or complications when a metaphyseal sleeve is used with or without a stem for AORI type I and II bony defects. Radiographical stability was investigated on 100 patients who received a metaphyseal sleeve revision TKA. The immediate post-operative radiograph was used as a baseline, and subsequent latest follow up radiograph used for analysis of osteolysis and implant subsidence. At final follow-up 3 patients (3.7%) had radiological subsidence of the prosthesis. 6 patients (7.5%) had radiological signs of lucency/osteolysis surrounding the implant. 1 patient required re-revision surgery (survivorship 98%). Metaphyseal sleeves provide excellent implant stability and survivorship up to 10 years. There is minimal subsidence, osteolysis and rates of revision. In a cadaveric setting, increasing levels of bony defect were created in the tibia: small (15mm), medium (25mm) and large (35mm). Metaphyseal sleeves were inserted into the tibia and a standard axial pull-out (0 – 10mm) force and torque (0 - 30°) tests were carried out to determine the effect of increasing bone loss on implant primary stability. For the sawbone experiment the peak pull-out force with no defect was 160N, for small defect was 133N, medium defect 108N and large defect 56N. The peak torque with no defect was 17.8Nm, for small defect was 13.4Nm, medium defect 13.3Nm and large defect 11.1Nm. The only significant reduction of force was for the large defect. For the cadaveric experiment only the no defect, medium and large were tested. The mean peak pull-out force with no defect was 208N, medium defect 150N and large defect 50N. The peak torque with no defect was 13.6Nm, medium defect 9.9Nm and large defect 4.7Nm. The only significant reduction in force was observed in the large group. For the scenarios examined, this experimental study shows that when a metaphyseal sleeve is used for revision TKA, biomechanically up to 25mm radial defect may be acceptable, however between 26-35mm may be the “critical limit” for bone loss making the implant unstable. This is the first study in the literature to attempt to quantify this critical limit in any arthroplasty. The findings of this thesis support the use of the metaphyseal sleeve for the management of bone loss in revision total knee arthroplasty. The failure rate, medium to long term patient reported outcome, radiographic evaluation and biomechanical properties are encouraging.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
The University of Edinburgh
Year dc:date.issued
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Jabbal, Abhimanyu
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Simpson, Hamish
  • Walmsley, Phil
  • Yang, Irene

Subjects

dc:subject × 5

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Jabbal, Abhimanyu. Use of metaphyseal sleeves to address bone loss in revision total knee arthroplasty. The University of Edinburgh, 2025. https://hdl.handle.net/1842/44178