University of Edinburgh
Developing an audio-visually enhanced surgical coaching program in the southeast of Scotland.
Abstract
dc:description.abstractCurrent professional development activities for fully qualified consultant surgeons in the United Kingdom (UK) are broadly limited to attending conferences or courses, and structured around the General Medical Council (GMC) appraisal process. The opportunities for operative performance review are scarce, despite the necessity for surgeons to maintain peak performance. Surgical coaching could be a potential solution to this gap in professional development. While research on surgical coaching has increased over the past decade, most studies originate in the United States (US). Furthermore, advances in digital technologies have made high quality audio-visual (AV) recording more accessible at low cost. The potential impact of their use in surgical training and development is recognised but yet to be fully realised. This thesis aims to develop and evaluate an AV-enhanced surgical coaching program in Southeast Scotland. The Stanford Design Thinking model was used as the overarching framework due to its emphasis on multidisciplinary team work, engagement with users throughout the process, and focus on development of solutions to complex problems. The five stages; empathise, define, ideate, prototype, and test, guided the research which comprised five interconnected studies addressing specific research questions: 1.Systematic Review: A review of the published research on audio-visual technology (AVT) use in coaching programs for acute hospital healthcare professionals was performed. This demonstrated that various modalities of AVT had been used successfully in coaching programs though predominantly in the US. 2.Modified e-Delphi Consensus Study: To gain an understanding of the essential elements required when developing an AV-enhanced coaching program for surgeons in the UK, a modified e-Delphi study gathered input from a wide range of expertise including the end users of the surgical coaching program, consultant general surgeons. Consensus was achieved on 27 statements regarding program design. 3.Qualitative Sub-Analysis: Due to the wealth of data generated from the e-Delphi study, a focused analysis explored the integration of AV technology in surgical coaching. This characterised the perceived benefits of using AVT within surgical coaching research as well as the barriers, but crucially also noted possible solutions to the challenges faced. 4.Collaboration with Ariadne Labs (SCOPE Program): Two studies were performed in collaboration with the Safer Surgery team at Ariadne Labs in Boston, who had created the Surgical Coaching for Operative Performance Enhancement (SCOPE) program, that explored the utility and implementation potential of an existing surgical coaching program: (i)A mixed methods study that characterised the experience of participation in a surgical coaching program from the perspective of the coach. This study demonstrated that surgeons who act as coaches do benefit from participation and noted changes in their practice as well as improved wellbeing. (ii)An implementation assessment framework evaluated the feasibility of implementing SCOPE at a geographically distant hospital that was not part of the Lab’s academic research network. Although in a small cohort, the program was successfully implemented and completed by the majority of participants. Due to participant feedback on the largest barriers to participation; time and scheduling logistics, several changes were made to the SCOPE implementation guide based on the results. 5.Trial of Methods Study: Before implementing AV-enhanced coaching in real surgical settings, and capturing real patient data, a simulation-based trial was conducted with consultant and trainee general surgeons. They used both direct observation and video-based coaching and were asked to complete surveys and interviews for evaluation. This trial of methods also allowed the video recording and data management pathways to be tested. Overall, this study was successfully implemented with participants reporting high levels of satisfaction and acceptability. Potential challenges and action points were identified. This research has systematically defined the challenges in developing an AV-enhanced surgical coaching program, refining key research questions and addressing overarching issues such as ethico-legal concerns in clinical video use. The next steps would involve conducting an audio-visually enhanced coaching feasibility study within the real surgical environment to test the use of AVT, and the acceptability of the SCOPE coaching program amongst surgeons in the South East of Scotland. More broadly the knowledge gained from this work could be applied to the use of digital technologies within surgical training or surgeon performance enhancement research, offering insights applicable to future innovations in surgeon development.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Gunn, Eilidh G. M.
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Yule, Steven
- Tambyraja, Andrew
Subjects
dc:subject × 5Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- https://doi.org/10.7488/era/7024