Back to search

University of Edinburgh

Role of antimicrobial photodynamic therapy in the disinfection of the root canal system of human permanent teeth in vivo

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Successful root canal treatment is dependent on the elimination of necrotic pulpal tissue and micro-organisms from the root canal system. Factors such as anatomical complexity, the presence of organised biofilms and the formation of a smear layer during instrumentation makes disinfection of the root canal system challenging. It is known that in cases where a negative microbial culture was obtained, the outcomes of treatment were improved so emphasising the importance of effective decontamination. However, conventional chemo-mechanical debridement is unable to completely eradicate micro-organisms from the root canal system especially in retreatment cases. Sodium hypochlorite solution, the principal conventional irrigation chemical, has some shortcomings. It is ineffective against some micro-organisms found in the root canal system, it needs to be allowed to dwell in the root canal for thirty minutes and regularly refreshed during that time. In addition, its therapeutic and toxic doses are undesirably close together. In order to attempt to overcome these shortcomings, a novel technique termed antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) is available. This may be defined as “light induced inactivation of cells, micro-organisms, or molecules”. In principle, the system involves the use of a nontoxic dye as a photosensitiser which is selectively adsorbed onto, or absorbed into, a target tissue. When exposed to light energy, the photosensitiser is activated which, in the presence of molecular oxygen produces free radicals, oxygen ions and singlet reactive oxygen species by a series of chemical reactions. This leads to disruption of the cellular plasma membrane and / or damage to deoxyribonucleic acid thus causing cell death. It is effective against all micro-organisms found in the root canal system and, in addition, resistant strains of bacteria seen with conventional antibiotic therapy cannot occur. The aim of the present thesis is to investigate whether the incorporation of aPDT into the chemo-mechanical debridement of the root canal system protocol improves the outcomes of endodontic treatment. These include enhanced disinfection, reduced post-operative pain, improved (namely quicker and better) healing of the periradicular tissues, increased survival of the root treated tooth and an improved oral health-related quality of life. METHODS: Following an introductory chapter which explains the system in detail, how it functions and sets out the clinical problem in endodontics, the present thesis includes a systematic review of the literature aiming to identify whether there is evidence to support the use of aPDT to improve the outcomes mentioned above. Three previously published in vivo studies are included, two of which sought to investigate whether aPDT is effective in reducing the bacterial load during chemomechanical debridement by analysing microbiological samples realised at various points in this process. The third paper followed up teeth treated when aPDT was incorporated into the endodontic disinfection protocol to determine their survival over a ten-year period. This latter study was continued and reported in a separate chapter on the survival of a larger number of teeth at risk and over a longer period of time. The present thesis concludes with a narrative review and synthesis of the salient points derived from the body of the work and makes recommendations on how aPDT may be incorporated into a clinical protocol as well as offering suggestions where further research work could be undertaken. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: The systematic review revealed that when aPDT is used adjunctively to chemomechanical debridement, it is effective at reducing the bacterial load, there was no consensus that it had a statistically significant effect with respect to reducing postoperative pain and there were mixed results that it may enhance healing of the periradicular tissues. There were insufficient studies to make any conclusions with respect to survival of the tooth or oral health-related quality of life. However, aPDT can only be used adjunctively in addition to the conventional disinfection agents such as sodium hypochlorite solution and is best employed at the end of the disinfection phase of treatment. The two in vivo studies which analysed microbiological samples at various points in the disinfection process proved the concept that aPDT is effective in reducing bacterial load. As regards survival of the root treated tooth, at ten years, when failure for reasons other than the root treatment failing were excluded, the survival rate was 97.33% for the first attempt at root treatment and 93.67% where the root treatment was being done for a second or more time with the number of teeth at risk being 620 and 167 respectively. These figures compared favourably with previously published survival data where aPDT was not used. aPDT could therefore enhance the disinfection of the root canal system especially in cases when the root canal treatment required to be redone. The follow-on trial included 1097 teeth at risk over a period of 6,794 days (18.60 years). At fifteen years, the survival rate was 96.74% and 99.48% for root canal treatment and repeat root canal treatment respectively when failure for reasons other than the root treatment failing were excluded. This compared highly favourably with previously published work so concluding that there is a place for the incorporation of aPDT into the disinfection protocol as an adjunct as it may enhance the effectiveness of the disinfection of the root canal particularly in secondary cases so potentially increasing the survival of the tooth. Areas identified as requiring further research work would be to determine the most appropriate photosensitiser (together with its optimal properties) and the most efficacious combination with the light source. Studies are required to investigate whether aPDT can reduce post-operative pain and whether more complete and quicker healing of the periradicular tissues can be achieved. More studies would be desirable to determine the survival of teeth treated using this system and how this compares when aPDT is not employed. Lastly, it would be useful to investigate whether aPDT can have a beneficial effect in treating acute exacerbations of endodontic cause.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Bonsor, Stephen James
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Walls, Angus
  • Ibbetson, Richard
  • Philpott, Bob

Subjects

dc:subject × 6

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Bonsor, Stephen James. Role of antimicrobial photodynamic therapy in the disinfection of the root canal system of human permanent teeth in vivo. 2026. https://era.ed.ac.uk/handle/1842/44845