University of Edinburgh
Development, design and delivery of a pilot human factors science and ergonomics education programme for vascular surgery trainees in the United Kingdom
Abstract
dc:description.abstractBACKGROUND: Interactions between people and the systems and environment within which they work are what influence safety, performance and wellbeing in surgery. Human factors science/ergonomics (HFE) draws on several evidence-based disciplines to describe, identify and optimise these relationships. Existing HFE interventions in surgery are often limited in content and availability, and few are targeted towards a specific specialty or aspect of practice. The majority of in-hospital adverse events relate to surgery, of which two-thirds relate to the intraoperative phase. This thesis therefore aims to design an evidence-based accessible and relevant HFE education programme targeted towards improving operative performance for vascular surgery trainees in the UK and Ireland and thus enhancing patient safety. METHODS: A scoping review of the impact of HFE on operative performance in vascular surgery was conducted to identify themes in extant literature in order that relevant areas for training could be defined and categorised. An analysis of a surgical adverse events database was conducted to establish surgeons’ perceptions of HFE elements implicated, and any correlation with the severity of event or year of report. To ensure that the content and design of an education programme was relevant and accessible, a service evaluation, comprising a survey of junior registrars (needs assessment) and focus groups with senior registrars (needs analysis), was carried out. Data from these components informed the design of an evidence-based hybrid pilot education programme which was delivered as pre-course podcasts and an in-person workshop. Post-course evaluation was conducted to assess participant satisfaction and success in delivering educational learning outcomes. RESULTS: All categories of HFE were found to influence operative performance in vascular surgery. Notable findings included how the use of adjunctive equipment can adversely affect operator wellbeing, and the presence of communication and equipment failures in adverse events. When considering surgeons’ perceptions of HFE in adverse events, it was found that, although a spectrum of elements were identified, individual failings were considered prevalent. In contrast, analysis by a psychologist identified a broader range of causative factors suggesting that an independent observer could offer additional insights relevant to performance and safety. A survey of junior registrars confirmed that there is an unmet need for an HFE education programme: trainees recognise it as critical to performance, however their understanding of the subject is limited. Thematic analysis of focus groups with senior registrars demonstrated trainees’ baseline understanding of HFE concepts and how they present in the operative setting, and revealed what would make an education programme engaging and something which they would be able to and want to attend. This included: clinically relevant content, an expert HFE faculty, and limited demand on money and time. The education programme contained content proven relevant in the literature, answered the results of the service evaluation and received positive participant feedback. There was an improvement in knowledge and understanding of HFE and the educational learning outcomes were achieved. CONCLUSION: To improve performance, wellbeing and patient safety, targeted HFE education should be incorporated into surgical training. This thesis defined the components of HFE most relevant to operative performance in vascular surgery and assessed surgeons’ perceptions of which elements are present most frequently during adverse events. After establishing current understanding of HFE amongst trainees, and what would make training opportunities effective and attractive, a hybrid pilot education programme was successfully designed and delivered. Recommendations are offered regarding how to: (i) translate this model for other surgical specialties; (ii) integrate HFE frameworks into daily practice; and (iii) contextualise the course to promote equity in global surgery.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Kerray , Fiona Margaret
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Yule, Steven
- Tambyraja, Andrew
Subjects
dc:subject × 3Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- https://doi.org/10.7488/era/7412