Back to search

University of Edinburgh

Objective risk stratification of patients with suspected acute and chronic coronary syndromes

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

INTRODUCTION: Cardiovascular disease remains the leading cause of morbidity and mortality resulting in substantial loss of economic productivity and accounting for 1 in 7 deaths. The value of high-sensitivity cardiac troponin assays to provide objective risk stratification has been demonstrated in large scale randomised clinical trials in patients with suspected acute coronary syndrome. In those with chronic coronary syndromes, however, objective markers of risk are lacking which makes identifying those at greatest risk challenging. The aims of this thesis are to evaluate how strategies that use diagnostic testing as part of objective assessment can be implemented to improve the identification of those at greatest risk and allow for targeted and timely interventions to reduce risk of future myocardial infarction or cardiovascular death. METHODS: Study 1 was a sub-study of the SCOT-HEART2 trial. In this study, asymptomatic individuals with at least one cardiovascular risk factor, were randomised to coronary CT angiography or the current clinical standard, cardiovascular risk scoring, to identify those at risk of future myocardial infarction or coronary heart disease death. The composite primary outcome was compliance with the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence recommendations for diet, body-mass index, smoking, and physical exercise at six months. Study 2 was a retrospective cohort study where the short- and long-term outcomes for all patients referred to rapid access services with suspected angina were evaluated using linked routine healthcare data. The primary outcome was fatal or non-fatal myocardial infarction at one year. Study 3 was a prospective observational cohort study to assess feasibility. This involved evaluating the feasibility of implementing diagnostic testing in an out-patient setting to allow rapid, objective risk stratification in patients with suspected exertional angina referred to a specialist cardiac out-patient clinic was evaluated. Objective testing included measurement of cardiac troponin with a high-sensitivity assay at the point of care, a personal electrocardiogram and an on-line questionnaire to record patient reported symptoms. The primary outcome was the proportion of patients with suspected angina who completed risk assessment within one working day of referral from primary care Study 4 was a retrospective cohort study conducted across 13 hospital sites. Outcomes for patients presenting acutely to the Emergency Department with possible myocardial infarction were evaluated using routinely collected healthcare data. Cardiac troponin was used to risk stratify these patients into low, intermediate and high-risk groups. The primary effectiveness and safety outcomes were the proportion of patients discharged from the Emergency Department, and the proportion dead or with a subsequent myocardial infarction at 30 days, respectively. RESULTS: In study 1, 400 asymptomatic individuals were enrolled (50% female, median age 62 years, median 10-year cardiovascular risk score of 14%) with 195 randomised to cardiovascular risk scoring and 205 to coronary CT angiography. At 6 months, those who underwent CT angiography were more likely to meet the primary composite endpoint (17% [33/194] versus 6% [10/177]; odds ratio 3.42 [95% confidence interval 1.63 to 6.94], p <0.001). Compared to cardiovascular risk scoring, fewer participants were recommended preventative therapy following CT angiography (51% (105/205) versus 75% (147/195), p<0.001) but acceptance of recommendations was higher (79% (83/105) versus 47% (69/147), p<0.001). This resulted in similar number of patients taking lipid lowering therapy (44% (90/205) versus 35% (69/195), p=0.09) and greater use of antiplatelet therapy in those randomised to CT angiography (40% (83/205) versus 0.5% (1/195), p<0.001). Participants randomised to coronary CT angiography had modest incremental improvements in lifestyle behaviours and risk factors at six months, largely driven by those with coronary atheroma on CT angiography. In study 2, 13,552 patients (61 [53-69] years, 46% female) with possible angina were referred with 11,512 (84.9%), 1,443 (10.6%) and 597 (4.4%) reviewed in the rapid access clinic (4 [2-7] days), general cardiology clinic (16 [3-47] days) or referred but not seen, respectively. Patients referred but not seen were more likely to have fatal or non-fatal myocardial infarction compared to those seen at the rapid access clinic after adjusting for age, sex, hypertension, diabetes and previous myocardial infarction (17.0% [99/597]) versus 2.9% [329/11,512], (adjusted odds ratio 6.78 [95% confidence interval 5.28 to 8.71; P<0.001]). Patients referred but not seen were also more likely to attend the Emergency Department (52% [308/597] versus 29% [3,396/11,512]) or undergo unscheduled revascularisation (14.0% [85/597] versus 5.3% [612/11,512]) at one year, or to have a cardiac death (5.2% [31/597] versus 3.0% [340/11,512]) during follow up (P<0.01 for all). In study 3, 246 patients (median age 63 [57 to 70] years, 50% women, 94% white ethnicity) with suspected exertional angina completed objective risk assessment following referral to specialist services. Of these patients, 52.4% (129/246), 39.8% (98/246) and 7.7% (19/246) were stratified as low, intermediate and high risk, respectively. The primary outcome of completing objective risk assessment within one working day of referral to rapid access services was achieved in 40.2% (99/246) of patients. A clinical diagnosis of anginal chest pain was made in 25.6% (63/246) of patients. Those stratified as low or intermediate risk were less likely to receive a clinical diagnosis of angina relative to those stratified as high risk (21.9% versus 28.7% versus 57.9%, respectively; P=0.0013). Ten (4%) patients were found to have an acute coronary syndrome on completion of objective risk stratification, and all were stratified as high risk. In study 4, a total of 137,881 patients (49% female) were included of whom 60,707 (44%), 42,727 (31%), and 34,447 (25%) were stratified as low, intermediate and high-risk, respectively. Overall, 65.8% (39,918/60,707) of low-risk patients were discharged from the Emergency Department, but this varied from 26.8% to 93.5% by site. The safety outcome occurred in 277 (0.5%) and 3,917 (11.4%) patients classified as low- or high-risk, of whom 18 (0.03%) and 304 (1%) had a subsequent myocardial infarction at 30 days, respectively. CONCLUSION: Coronary CT angiography and high-sensitivity cardiac troponin testing allow objective risk stratification of patients with acute and chronic coronary syndrome. Combining these tests could allow the highest risk patients to be identified and subsequently enable targeted interventions and more efficient allocation of healthcare resources to those most in need. Whether these strategies alone or together can improve clinical outcomes will be evaluated in future clinical trials.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • McDermott, Michael P. J.
Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
  • Mills, Nicholas
  • Anand, Atul
  • Newby, David
  • Kimenai, Dorien

Subjects

dc:subject × 5

Rights

Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Edinburgh
Base URL
era.ed.ac.uk/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

McDermott, Michael P. J.. Objective risk stratification of patients with suspected acute and chronic coronary syndromes. 2026. https://hdl.handle.net/1842/45324