University of Edinburgh
Sociotheological exploration of what freedom means to carers in the context of dementia caring: the liberating impact of common humanity and community solidarity
Abstract
dc:description.abstractWe as humans value freedom and control to live our lives the way we choose (Fujiwara et al, 2013) and restrictions of freedom have been linked with distress (Mohiyeddini, 2025). In the context of dementia care, the importance of staff training in person-centred care (Kitwood, 1997) that supports the freedoms of people living with dementia is understood, although distressing failures of implementation remain (e.g., Gwernan-Jones et al., 2020; Mackay et al., 2022). The Alzheimer Society (2018) notes that ‘nine in 10 carers for people with dementia experience feelings of stress or anxiety several times a week’. The freedoms of carers of people with dementia may also be affected as they struggle to uphold the freedoms of the person they are supporting. Studies have found that carer distress is linked to loss of autonomy (e.g., Dombestein, 2021; Lin, Macmillan and Brown, 2011). Similarly, studies of staff working in dementia care settings find that increased moral distress, which arises when systems prevent staff from delivering compassionate care, is related to lower job satisfaction and increased staff turnover (e.g., Spenceley et al., 2015; Pijl-Zieber, 2018). Meanings of freedom have been discussed by scholars and applied to policies for centuries including, since 1948, within international and national human rights frameworks (e.g., Mertens, 2020). Given this, a question arises about whether freedom may have different meanings for different carers. Some meanings may be individual (such as autonomy) and other meanings may be collective (e.g., Díaz, 2024; Gutiérrez, 1973) or spiritual (e.g., Baumgardner, 2018). This thesis takes an interdisciplinary approach that considers freedom in relation to sociotheological frameworks such as liberation theology, along with secular frameworks such as human rights. This new empirical qualitative study explores with unpaid carers and care staff what freedom means to them in the context of dementia caring, including the impact of the global pandemic of COVID-19 and national lockdowns and restrictions in Scotland. One-to-one interviews were conducted remotely with 22 participants, of whom 13 were family carers (6 men and 7 women) and 9 were care staff (all women). The analysis was guided by the phronetic iterative analysis method developed by Tracy (2020). The analytic process was also informed by the ‘sacred reading’ approach of Lectio Divina, as described by Sexton (2019, p. 44). The predominant experience of both family carers and care staff was that of systemic invisibility or ‘system-based inequalities’ (Giebel et al., 2024, p. 559). When experiencing systemic invisibility, carers felt less free. When experiencing support, whether practical, emotional or spiritual, carers felt more free. Two meta-themes linked all types of support, and these were experiences of (1) common humanity (e.g., Neff, 2023); and (2) community solidarity (e.g., Sheid and Smith, 2021). Experiences of common humanity (being treated in a way that indicates that everyone has equal value) and community solidarity (being treated in a way that indicates others understand and respond to one’s feelings and needs) were experienced as liberating. In addition, courage had a bridging role between common humanity and community solidarity. This aligns with Gilbert’s (2024) discussion of his evolutionary psychological emotion regulation model that illustrates that when people are treated with compassion, they feel socially safe (common humanity). Then, when people feel socially safe, this also gives them courage, and a further sense of connection with others (community solidarity). Findings are critically discussed in relation to foundational concepts in dementia care, including personhood (Kitwood, 1997); humanness, the divine embrace and Christian communities of belonging (Swinton, 2017); and other sociotheological and secular frameworks. Recommendations are made for research and practice that increase freedom for family carers, care staff, and people living with dementia. These include actions at three levels: •Individual level: providing training for staff in dementia care that focuses on compassion, self-compassion and courage. This cultivates common humanity and community solidarity that increases well-being for people living with dementia, family carers and staff carers. Family carers also need self-compassion learning opportunities for reducing distress. •Community level: creating hyper-local spaces where carers and people living with dementia can find social safeness through listening, resting, learning and connecting. These community hubs should also co-ordinate bespoke, long-term, community-based practical support in the home through ‘circles of support’ or ‘small supports’ models (e.g., NDTi, 2014). •National level: initiating collaborations that open and adapt spaces where carers and people living with dementia can find what they need in one hub. Mobilising innovative structural funding and partnerships that enable suitable building adaptations and secular support to happen in places like churches, temples and mosques could help establish accessible hubs of support in local communities throughout Scotland. Similar sacred-secular partnerships could be replicated internationally. Findings from my research highlight especially how, for carers, having access to humanising networks of support enables freedom. The insights that carers of people living with dementia have shared for this thesis reveal the fundamental importance of common humanity and community solidarity for human freedom and well-being.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Pollard, Martha C.
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Russ, Tom
- Wilkinson, Heather
- Harris, Harriet
- Starr, John
Subjects
dc:subject × 7Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- https://doi.org/10.7488/era/7861