University of Edinburgh
Exploring how information infrastructures integrating health and social care evolve: case study of the key information summary in Scotland
Abstract
dc:description.abstractINTRODUCTION: In many countries, health and care providers are seeking to deliver integrated care to improve coordination. However, efforts to enable interorganizational data exchange are constrained by the heterogeneity and limited interoperability of existing information systems. Health Information Exchange (HIE) technologies, such as Summary Care Records (SCR) and Shared Care Records (ShCRs), are increasingly deployed to address these challenges by facilitating data sharing across fragmented health and care settings. These technologies seek to standardize subsets of data for exchange but are implemented within an existing information infrastructure, understood as the installed base of information systems, user practices, and organizational structures. Existing work has shown that HIE developers may struggle to standardize data exchange and align user requirements, which are diverse and extensive, difficult to identify and agree across professional and organizational boundaries, leading to non-adoption or alternative uses that diverge from their intended purpose. In addition, most studies have focused on healthcare integration and relatively short timeframes, a limitation that partly reflects the practical demands of ethnographic research and restricts understanding of how information infrastructures evolve over time to support integration across health and care providers. This thesis explores how regional information infrastructures integrating health and care providers evolve through an in-depth longitudinal and contemporary ethnographic case study of the Key Information Summary (KIS) in Scotland, an ambitious national initiative enabling the sharing of information held in General Practice (GP) records across other health and social care settings. Complementary insights are offered from a smaller-scale study of ShCR development and implementation in England, which exemplifies newer, regionally implemented technologies integrating information from multiple providers. METHOD: I conducted a qualitative, multi-sited ethnographic study examining the development, implementation, adoption, and use of the KIS in Lothian, Scotland, across diverse settings, tracing its development, implementation, and adoption spanning more than 13 years. I explored how social, organizational, cultural, and political factors shaped the development and implementation of the KIS over time within the broader trajectory of integrating health and care providers. Data were collected through online interviews with users like GPs, hospital specialists, social workers, social care workers, out-of-hours clinicians, ambulance personnel, academics, vendors, and implementers to capture perspectives on the development, implementation, and adoption of the KIS. I conducted online observations of national-level strategic meetings and regional multidisciplinary team meetings supporting the strategic use of the KIS, as well as online observation sessions of practitioners using the system. Finally, archived websites, user guides, policies, and internal reports were analyzed to trace the planned and actual evolution of the KIS. Data were collected from April 2024 to March 2025 and subsequently coded using NVivo 14 and NVivo 15. A hybrid analytical approach combined deductive and inductive methods: the Technology-People-Organization-Macroenvironment framework guided initial coding, while concepts from Science, Technology, and Innovation Studies - including information infrastructure theory, the sociology of expectations, the social shaping of technology, and workarounds - were applied abductively to explore evolving visions, long-term infrastructure development, and sociotechnical factors shaping implementation and adoption. Building on insights from the Scottish case study, I conducted targeted interviews and documentary analysis of ShCR implementation and adoption in the English context in order to explore contextual transferability and validate findings. RESULTS: Data included 73 interviews (59 Scotland, 14 England), 20 hours of observation, two archived websites, and 108 documents (69 Scotland, 39 England). Findings illustrate that the evolution of information infrastructures integrating health and care providers occurred gradually in successive stages, conceptualized here as a "wave model of infrastructural evolution." Following each stage, expectations of integration and information sharing continued to evolve, prompting further concerted efforts at national and regional levels to integrate providers. National initiatives mobilized health boards, vendors, and users to establish common rules, guidance, and networks for information sharing, delivering significant, though inherently partial progress. At the regional level, local adoption strategies and formal workarounds, agreed and led by health boards, vendors, and organizations, extended the healthcare-centric infrastructure to social care settings, enabling new users, including social care staff, to access the KIS. Adoption and use of the KIS varied across settings, influenced by users' roles, access to the KIS, digital skills, information needs, and organizational practices. Adoption and use varied over time, particularly during COVID-19, when national directives repurposed the KIS to flag vulnerable patients. Many records were marked with a COVID label, which obscured existing care planning information and required users to take additional steps to update the KIS. Users across clinical and non-clinical settings engaged in informal context-specific adoption strategies, including repair work, which involved checking alternative information sources and datasets to correct, supplement, and share information, maintaining the KIS's usability and accuracy. Applying insights from Scotland, infrastructural evolution in England showed a homologous wave pattern, though the number, timing, and focus of waves varied across contexts, reflecting differences in governance structures, national integration agendas, local autonomy, and regionally driven practices. Centralized coordination of health and social care in Scotland reduced variability in the development and implementation of the KIS across regions and organizations, whereas England's oscillation between top-down directives and local initiatives had generated greater heterogeneity in ShCR development and implementation across regions. In both contexts, national-level initiatives achieved meaningful but incomplete progress, with local and regional strategies addressing persistent differences in technology adoption, information sharing, standardization across organizations and regions, shaped by the existing installed base. CONCLUSION: Regional information infrastructures evolve through successive waves, oscillating between top-down system-level changes, such as major infrastructure revisions, and bottom-up, user-driven adoption strategies and workarounds that leverage novel infrastructures to establish new practices, ways of working, thereby identifying opportunities and providing resources for further transformation. Effective integration requires a long-term strategic vision that recognizes how the existing installed base constrains what changes are seen to be achievable. Achievable outcomes are shaped by existing data structures and standards, organizational routines, diverse information requirements, and locally emergent practices, all of which are continuously negotiated as infrastructures develop. However, these outcomes remain constrained, as even expanded data sharing does not fully meet diverse informational needs across complex circumstances, conditions, and decision pathways. Evolution proceeds through inherently incomplete transformations, making periodic updates and renewals essential yet necessarily partial. These processes are guided by enduring, though gradually evolving, visions of integration that persist over the long term. Policy and implementation must therefore operate across multiple temporal frames, addressing immediate operational priorities while remaining aligned with longer-term objectives, ensuring that short-term solutions are compatible with and supportive of broader strategic trajectories.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Sai, Varun
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Cresswell, Kathrin
- Williams, Robin
Subjects
dc:subject × 7Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier URI
- https://doi.org/10.7488/era/7966