Georgia Institute of Technology
ON THE SUITABILITY OF PRINTED CIRCUIT HEAT EXCHANGERS FOR HIGH TEMPERATURE NUCLEAR SERVICE
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThe goal of this dissertation is to investigate the suitability of printed circuit heat exchangers (PCHEs) for high-temperature, high-pressure transient service. This investigation is performed with the double toolbox of experimental thermohydraulic tests and structural analyses. Thermohydraulic experiments were performed on two different lab-scale (small but complete units that include core and headers) PCHEs using a new test facility constructed specifically for this project. The first set of thermohydraulic tests utilized sCO2 at 20 MPa and up to 350C as the cold fluid and supercritical helium at up to 4 MPa and up to 550C as the hot fluid. The goal of the first set of experiments was to derive non-dimensional thermohydraulic correlations to predict the heat transfer, pumping power requirements, and metal temperature distribution of PCHEs over a broad range of operating conditions. The fluids used for these tests as well as the range of operating conditions were selected to be representative for applications of Next Generation Nuclear Power (NGNP). For relevance to industry, the PCHEs used in this study were constructed according to American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) design rules for conventional pressure vessels. the stainless steel PCHEs used for this study were uniquely designed to include distributed instrumentation ports that directly intercept the fluid channels within the core. These ports allowed a detailed and distinct analysis of the performance of the exchanger’s core and header performance with minimal assumptions. The second set of thermohydraulic tests were performed on a PCHE made of Incoloy 800H with similar internal architecture to the first. This material is one of six ASME approved alloys for the construction of pressure vessels operating at elevated temperatures and is classified as critical for the safety of a nuclear reactor. However, there are still outstanding questions about the integrity of PCHEs fashioned out of 800H since there is a scant experience in their manufacture. Consequently, this exchanger was tested for structural integrity in addition to thermohydraulic performance. Therefore, the goals of the second set of tests were twofold: 1. Test the validity of the thermohydraulic correlations already produced in the first set of thermohydraulic tests, 2. Challenge the exchanger structurally to investigate the suitability of the ASME design rules for sizing exchangers made of this particular grade of nickel alloy. The first set of friction factor performance data showed deviations of up to 15% with the friction factor correlations derived on the 316L PCHE for the sCO2 and 8% for the helium. The heat transfer performance was compared with the formulation provided by counterflow heat exchanger theory and showed excellent agreement to within 5% with the theory. The second set of tests applied 150 aggressive cold and hot thermal shocks to the exchanger. The particular set of transients used to challenge the pressure vessel were selected because the adverse temperature gradients caused by such operating conditions are a known cause of damage in exchangers in the field. These shocks were applied by modulating the cold fluid flow, a room temperature 20 MPa CO2 while keeping the helium inlet conditions fixed at approximately 4 MPa and up to 575 C. After every 50 cycles of hot and cold shocks, the exchanger was extracted from the loop for inspection. This included dimensional measurements at key locations, leak tests, and hydro tests with room temperature water at up to 37 MPa while measuring strains at key locations. Once these tests were completed, the exchanger was milled to tensile and microscopic inspection specimens for further analyses and to be used in subsequent studies. In parallel with the physical tests, this dissertation sought a method to accurately model or bound the stress and strain experienced by PCHE when subjected to thermohydraulic loads. The need for this task is rooted in the complex, multi-length-scale internal features of such components. These features were then addressed and simplified in five steps. In each step, the stress and strain forming as a result of a geometrical feature, such as the corrugated flow path, the large number of channels, or the three-dimensionality of the stress and strain, were analyzed. Simplified models are proposed by this dissertation to accurately model or bound the stress and strain of the complex PCHE geometry using finite element (FE) software. The output of this work is a simplified model that can be used for structural analysis of PCHEs operating as reactor safety-critical components in accordance with ASME design rules. Detailed code verification and validation were performed and are included in this manuscript to increase confidence in the models and the results. Finally, the insight into the temperature distribution during operation gained by the first set of thermohydraulic tests, as well as the simplified FE models developed, were used to analyze the damage caused by the thermal shocks to the 800H unit. The damage analysis focused on the locations of the exchanger that were subjected to the highest stresses due to the transients. The results of the analyses were then compared with the damage observed experimentally and by optically inspecting specimens milled from the tested exchanger. The model of the lab-scale PCHE that agreed with (validated by) the experimental observation was then increased in size to 1 m3 to simulate the utility-scale PCHE. This model was then analyzed under normal and severe operating conditions to investigate the suitability of such geometry for high-temperature high-pressure transient service. This analysis demonstrates that if the utility-scale PCHE is operated under well-balanced cold and hot streams heat capacitances, with temperatures ranges found in a Sodium Fast Reactor, then the stresses developing in such a unit will remain well within the allowed stress bounds specified by the ASME code rules.
Degree
thesis:*- Level thesis:degree_level
- Doctoral
- Department dc:contributor.department
- Mechanical Engineering
- Grantor dc:publisher
- Georgia Institute of Technology
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Katz, Alon
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Ranjan, Devesh
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Messner, Mark C
- Kalidindi, Surya
- Kumar, Satish
- Sun, Wenting
- Loutzenhiser, Peter
Subjects
dc:subject × 1Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- http://hdl.handle.net/1853/67148