Georgia Institute of Technology
Developing meta'omic methods for forensic analysis of wastewater infrastructure performance
Abstract
dc:description.abstractWastewater infrastructure represents the components of the bult environment which capture, convey, and treat wastewater. The type of wastewater infrastructure employed can vary globally, based on social and economic conditions. Yet, all wastewater infrastructure is replete with a diverse array of microbial life. The communities formed by these microbes play key roles in biological wastewater treatment. However, microorganisms can present substantial hazards when released into the environment since they often harbor human pathogens, antimicrobial resistance genes, and other pollutants. Yet, global estimates for the percentage of wastewater escaping proper treatment exceed 80%. Knowledge of when and why failure occurs among wastewater infrastructure systems is essential for improving such statistics. Expanding forensic tools available to environmental engineers for interrogating the performance of wastewater infrastructure, from conveyance in collection systems to biological treatment at WWTPs, will be essential to meet sanitation and sustainable development goals now and in the future. The application of shotgun-based nucleic acid sequencing, i.e., meta’omic methodologies, to examine the root cause of failure in these systems remains rare, in part because of several limitations ranging from uncertain analytical limits, lack of population proportioning benchmarking, and uncharted microbial genetic and functional diversity. Yet these data streams promise to assist environmental engineering forensics and this dissertation explores the development of meta’omic approaches for forensic analysis of wastewater infrastructure. This dissertation begins with the development of a theoretical basis in support of using metagenomic sequencing to track microbial populations in food and environmental samples (Chapter 2). This framework proposed multiple avenues for estimating a key parameter for microbial tracking: the detection limit. The framework was based on a target feature’s sequence characteristics and methods for calculating abundance a priori and a posteriori based on metagenome read mapping. Utilizing this theoretical framework, a metagenomic theoretical limit of detection (thLOD) was tested using simulated sewage spills in laboratory mesocosms combining sequencing, culture-based, and qPCR-based data (Chapter 3). Sewage-associated populations were tractable and quantifiable across 4-7 days of monitoring and in silico experiments validated the proposed thLOD. Chapter 3 also explored the use of shotgun metagenomic data to perform source apportionment – this is, to describe the fraction of fecal contamination belonging to a particular source. A major limitation uncovered by these efforts was the need to understand which microbial populations were specific or cross-reactive. Accordingly, a whole genome database was curated for fecally shed prokaryotes across multiple common contaminating sources to overcome this issue (Chapter 4). Comparative genomics revealed that the species level performed well as a cutoff for grouping populations into source-specific categories though substantial sequencing efforts are still needed for many hosts, especially ruminants. To combine these source curated databases with a population proportioning pipeline, a new bioinformatic tool was developed as part of this thesis called “SourceApp” (Chapter 5). The tool was then tested in a double-blind study using mesocosms of known composition to benchmark its source attribution, apportionment, and cell fractioning capabilities. Extensive parameter tuning was investigated to identify parameters of best choice for these efforts. The findings of this portion of the thesis position metagenomic based fecal source tracking (FST) as a powerful technique for source apportionment – which remains difficult with existing techniques. Additionally, the development of SourceApp should accelerate application of metagenomic FST more broadly and aid with reproducibility across future work. Lastly, this thesis applied the methodologies developed for FST to tracking functional microbial populations in a continuous mixed culture environmental bioprocess for enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR) (Chapter 6). Key functional populations were identified based on taxonomic classification and gene annotations. Changes in the relative abundances of these populations corresponded with periods of decreased EBPR performance. Statistical modeling of process performance was then used to implicate the importance of flanking populations which were not identified as putative functional populations but may play important roles in process performance. Follow up efforts combining metagenomic and metatranscriptomic sequencing identified specific genes carried by functional and flanking populations which were up and down regulated during process upsets. These genomes and the genes identified through metatranscriptomic inquiry can serve as biomarkers for ongoing efforts to probe the performance of full-scale EBPR with more rapid, real-time quantitative methods (e.g., RT-ddPCR).
Degree
thesis:*- Level thesis:degree_level
- Doctoral
- Department dc:contributor.department
- Civil and Environmental Engineering
- Grantor dc:publisher
- Georgia Institute of Technology
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Lindner, Blake G.
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Konstantinidis, Kostas T.
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Huang, Ching-Hua
- Pinto, Ameet J.
- Graham, Katherine E.
- Layton, Blythe A.
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/1853/78575