Georgia Institute of Technology
Understanding the Socio-Technical Factors that Drive Organizational Sustainability of Makerspaces
Abstract
dc:description.abstractMakerspaces are community-operated innovation centers that promote creativity, learning, and entrepreneurship. Despite their growing role in local innovation ecosystems, many struggle to survive, and closures can disrupt communities, deplete volunteer capacity, and halt public programs. Understanding what makes these organizations viable over time is, therefore, both a practical and a scholarly concern. This dissertation addresses that concern through four years of ethnographic fieldwork, in-depth interviews, and analysis of digitally mediated interaction across multiple makerspaces in the United States, presenting three interconnected studies that together offer an empirically grounded and theoretically informed account of how socio-technical factors shape makerspace sustainability. The first study defines sustainability in this context and develops a multidimensional framework that conceptualizes it as a dynamic system of interacting elements: people, community, culture, management, finance, and processes. The framework yields a central insight — that people come for the tools but stay for the community, and that culture is what holds the community together. The second study examines the people dimension of this framework, identifying how inclusive organizational practices — diverse leadership, equitable policies, gender-focused programming, and physically and psychologically safe environments — broaden participation beyond a self-selecting few and strengthen the membership base on which sustainability depends. The third study turns to culture, the factor that emerged as most critical. Through interviews and analysis of digital interaction data using Swidler's cultural toolkit framework as a sensitizing lens, this study identifies four domains of cultural practice — help and mutual support, psychological safety and accountability, learning and mentorship, and stewardship and material care — and examines how members describe and enact these practices through everyday interaction. Findings from the cross-study analysis also reveal that these cultural practices operate with limited structural support from the communication platform — a condition this dissertation terms platform-culture misalignment. The final contribution responds to this misalignment by proposing design guidelines for a makerspace-focused communication platform that uses AI-assisted scaffolding to support the cultural practices identified empirically, reduce friction in participation, and increase the visibility of community work — while preserving member agency over what gets posted, who gets contacted, and how contributions are recognized. This dissertation makes four primary contributions: a theoretical contribution in the form of a socio-technical framework for organizational sustainability of makerspaces, an empirical contribution grounded in multi-sited fieldwork, interviews, participant observation, and platform traces, a methodological contribution offering an analytic approach for studying culture as observable interactional work across field and platform data, and an artifact contribution proposing a design artifact that scaffolds cultural practice through communication infrastructure. Collectively, these contributions reposition makerspace sustainability as an ongoing socio-technical achievement: makers maintain spaces through several interconnected socio-technical factors based on cultural practices and social relationships that unfold in interaction, while communication infrastructure may assist or hinder this work.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Human-Centered Computing, PhD
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Interactive Computing
- Grantor
- Georgia Institute of Technology
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Rahman, Mizan
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Arriaga, Rosa I.
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Edwards, Keith
- Henneman, Richard
- Uchidiuno, Judith
- Lakshmi, Udaya
Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/1853/81727