Georgia Institute of Technology
Knowledge Transferred Between Subject Matter Experts and Makerspace Users Within Makerspaces
Abstract
dc:description.abstractWithin academic and community settings, makerspaces are well-documented as innovative environments that support hands-on learning, interdisciplinary collaboration, and rapid iteration. In contrast, United States (US) military makerspaces remain comparatively understudied, despite their growing presence reflecting a broader shift towards innovation. The US Army Engineer Research and Development Center (ERDC) and publicly available military documents have confirmed that makerspace initiatives exist within the US armed forces. However, due to security constraints and sensitivity of operational information, military makerspaces have not been comprehensively researched. Research indicates that stationary and mobile military makerspaces support problem-solving through rapid prototyping and on-site fabrication, yet little empirical research has examined what soldiers need to effectively utilize these spaces – from foundational knowledge required to operate equipment through to the higher-order skills needed to innovate within them. This study therefore seeks to characterize the knowledge transfer occurring between makerspace subject matter experts (SMEs)and soldier-users, as well as to identify the equipment, materials, and instructional supports that best enable effective makerspace engagement. This study investigates knowledge transfer between makerspace leaders and soldiers, with particular attention to what knowledge is transferred and how that knowledge is transmitted. Understanding both the content of information exchanged and the modalities through which information is exchanged is necessary to inform decisions about the personnel required for effective makerspace operations and to identify opportunities for reducing reliance on experts. Semi-structured interviews with seven military makerspace leaders across three installations were conducted and analyzed using qualitative inductive coding, with inter-rater agreement calculated to assess reliability of the findings. Analysis of the interview data revealed that knowledge transfer in military makerspaces is characterized by both formal and informal content and modalities. All seven participants emphasized the centrality of project-specific information, and informal content and modalities were discussed more frequently than formal content and modalities. These findings suggest that while formal modalities – such as structured makerspace course – are important for introducing soldiers to the space, informal modalities – including in-person conversations, visual demonstrations, and working alongside the soldier – are essential for developing iterative, project-specific solutions. Because these informal, in-person modalities may be unavailable in mobile or forward-deployed makerspace environments where expert personnel are limited, this study also explored whether structured, project-specific design guidelines could partially offset the reliance on SMEs. To this end, standardized instructional resources were developed for a drone as a representative project commonly discussed within military makerspaces. These guidelines, modeled after instructional resources commonly used in academic makerspaces and drawn from publicly available technical documentation, took the form of a poster and an accompanying manual intended to guide users through the construction process with minimal expert intervention. Prior to use in the case study, the guidelines were submitted to drone experts who reviewed the documents for feasibility and suggested improvements, and then the lead researcher independently constructed the drone to verify that the documented build process could be followed end-to-end. A subsequent case study evaluated these materials with two participants – a civilian student with prior makerspace experience who completed the full drone build and a military member whose construction was limited to the 3D printing phase – who followed markedly different trajectories in both their progress and their help-seeking behaviors. The civilian participant relied primarily on in-person SME consultation and instructional videos to resolve challenges, while the military participant leveraged an artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot as an intermediary, citing prior 3D printing experience as the basis for critically evaluating the tool’s output. Despite these differences in approach, both participants ultimately required SME involvement to resolve unforeseen challenges not adequately addressed in the guidelines. This finding reinforces the conclusion from the interview analysis: makerspace SMEs remain critical to effective makerspace operation, due to the prevalence of bilateral, in-person knowledge exchange that is deeply responsive to the specific and evolving needs of each soldier’s project. This study contributes empirical characterization of knowledge transfer within military makerspaces and offers preliminary instructional resources to support users of varied technical backgrounds in engaging with these spaces more independently.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Mechanical Engineering, MS
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Mechanical Engineering
- Grantor
- Georgia Institute of Technology
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Huff, Lily
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Linsey, Julie
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Seepersad, Carolyn
- Jariwala, Amit
Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/1853/82121