Georgia Institute of Technology
Epistemic Breakdown and Repair in Civic Data Settings: A Study of Youth Participatory Mapping and Civic Technology Practice
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis dissertation develops a theory of epistemic breakdowns in civic technology. Through this work, I argue that epistemic breakdown is a moment when a sociotechnical arrangement, a data setting, fails to respond to a person in their capacity as a knower. These moments are concrete, observable failures that prevent a person's knowledge from counting in the data setting. As communities are increasingly asked to participate in civic life through digital tools, from participatory mapping to environmental sensing to collaborative data visualization, the question of whose knowledge counts becomes more pertinent. Research in HCI, CSCW, and civic technologies has shown that communities use civic tools to advocate for themselves. What has remained underexamined is the epistemic dimension of participation itself, i.e., who counts as a legitimate knower and whose knowledge matters. This dissertation examines how civic technologies might fail to serve their publics epistemically. I draw from two bodies of data. The first is three years of qualitative fieldwork with Map Spot, a collaborative mapping tool in which participants bring their own experiences together with existing data layers to make claims about the places they live in. In a disaster resilience program in Savannah, Georgia, with middle school participants, we used Map Spot to map their neighborhoods and engage with environmental and community data. The second set of data consists of fourteen interviews with civic technology practitioners in the United States, extending the scope of my research beyond the workshops. I found that civic knowledge-making breaks down in four recurring ways. Sometimes the participants' experiences could not be translated into the data setting, as when a student's account of a neighborhood that “stank” daily from a nearby paper plant could not be captured in a static pollution layer. Sometimes the person speaking would be dismissed due to their social standing, as when participants anticipated their own compromised social standing: “I'm too young to vote,” or they joked that “children make maps to escape a flood” would receive little to no attention. Other times, the material arrangement of the data setting interfered with the process, blocking projections, the cost of a permanent mark, missing legends, and exhausted bodies running behind schedule. And sometimes the knowledge produced did not travel beyond the data setting; when youth participants felt they could not share with adults, officials could not read the finished maps, or a community's priorities got stuck in decades-long consultation loops. Civic technologies compress situated, contested experience into forms institutions can read, and that compression always leaves a remainder. Breakdowns occur in the remainder when an arrangement treats what it cannot absorb as the participant's deficit. Thus, I argue that these epistemic breakdowns are constitutive features of civic technologies rather than usability flaws, and that they are felt most by citizens with limited political power. A breakdown becomes an injustice when an arrangement will not accommodate a knower it could, and, left to recur, breakdowns harden into exactly that. I argue for moving towards epistemic repair as a response to epistemic breakdowns. Epistemic repair occurs when a breakdown is read as evidence about the data setting rather than about the person, and the data setting is modified in response to accommodate the knower. Drawing on design workshops and civic experts' accounts, I showcase three relationships in which epistemic repair occurs, and I put forth commitments that can move us towards it: changing the activity so that knowledge can get in, sharing control over what the activity is for and who decides it, and opening pathways for knowledge to count beyond the immediate setting. Across my research, the repair participants asked for most often, and the one that most often worked, was peer-peer, between participants working with each other, rather than the facilitator or the institution. Through this dissertation, I offer a middle-range account of civic knowledge-making in data settings, how it breaks down, and how we might attempt to repair it. The goal of the dissertation is to encourage a shift from designing for seamless participation to designing for epistemic vulnerability: building data settings that read a hesitation, a silence, or a refusal as evidence about the system itself rather than the person, and that can provide an opportunity for repair when the process runs into friction.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Digital Media, PhD
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Literature, Media, and Communication
- Grantor
- Georgia Institute of Technology
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Yousufi, Mohsin Y. K.
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Loukissas, Yanni
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Wong, Richmond
- Smith, Allegra
- Hyde, Allen
- Meng, Amanda
- ORCID person:identifier.orcid
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/1853/82210