Back to search

University of Glasgow

Persuasion : a historical-comparative study of the role of persuasion within the judicial decision-making process

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Legal theory has failed to fully explore the rhetorical in the judicial decision and, in doing so, has misunderstood the key role played by reasons that seek to legitimate and justify while expressing emotion and commitment. This thesis sets out to understand why legal theory has failed to do so and what role rhetoric plays in the judicial decision. Three legal theorists, Chaim Perelman, Bernard Jackson and Neil MacCormick are used to show that it is seeking to be philosophically acceptable that has led legal theorists to avoid the emotional and character-based aspects of the judicial decision. Two historical studies, of the Talmud and Aristotle's Ars Rhetorica, demonstrate that rhetoric can be seen as closely related to the limits of authority in the system and the character and identity of the decision-maker. These insights are then applied to the common law, exemplified by six cases from the law of negligence. This highlights the importance of the commitment of judges to their own sense of role and the way limitations on reasoning help to create this sense. The thesis concludes by considering the relationship between philosophy and judgement and argues that they can be seen as different forms of understanding and that there are strong ethical reasons for rejecting attempts to see either as a paradigm for all understanding.

Degree

thesis:*
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
PhD
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
University of Glasgow
Year dc:date.issued
2002

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Malloch, Valerie Ann

Subjects

dc:subject × 1

Rights

Language dc:language
en

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Glasgow
Base URL
theses.gla.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Malloch, Valerie Ann. Persuasion : a historical-comparative study of the role of persuasion within the judicial decision-making process. PhD thesis, University of Glasgow, 2002.