Back to search

University of Glasgow

The paradox of care and control: experiences of community based compulsory treatment orders in Scotland

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

The use of community based compulsory treatment orders for individuals experiencing mental distress is contentious. This is because they are fraught with tensions between care and control. They restrict liberty by mandating compliance with a range of conditions, including medication administration, attending specified services, and allowing professionals into the home space. Despite this, they were introduced in Scotland as part of a wider modernisation agenda, which has earned Scotland a worldwide reputation for leading the way in progressive mental health legislation. The unique Scottish approach is underpinned by rights and principles, which are designed to strengthen voice and choice and benefit ‘revolving door’ patients through access to treatment, and has been framed as a less restrictive option than hospitalisation. This thesis draws upon qualitative, semi-structured interviews with individuals, their relatives, and mental health advocates to explore whether experiences reflect the rights based intentions of the legislation. It specifically focuses on the named person provision, experiences of care and treatment, control and surveillance, and the mental health tribunal. A relational approach was adopted to examine how CCTOs are negotiated within the context of inter-personal and professional relationships. Furthermore, it uses the ethics of care as a normative model to assess the quality of care being provided, specifically drawing upon Tronto’s (1993, 2013) integrity of care framework to assess this. This thesis contends that the rights based intentions of the legislation are not being realised in practice and that paradoxically, a lack of control, hierarchies of power, and distrust overwhelmingly define experiences of compulsion. It argues that rights based frameworks can only go so far to benefit individuals and that an ethics of care is required to improve practice.

Degree

thesis:*
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
PhD
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
University of Glasgow
Year dc:date.issued
2019

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Macgregor, Aisha

Subjects

dc:subject × 1

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Glasgow
Base URL
theses.gla.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Macgregor, Aisha. The paradox of care and control: experiences of community based compulsory treatment orders in Scotland. PhD thesis, University of Glasgow, 2019. https://doi.org/10.5525/gla.thesis.75119