University of Glasgow
The structural transformation of the public sphere in Scotland: print culture, class conflict, and opinion formation, c.1850-1920s
Abstract
dc:description.abstractAs seen from the perspective of antagonistic Scottish print publics, how did the commercialisation of the press after the repeal of the ‘Taxes on Knowledge’ change the dynamics of class conflict, critical democratic deliberation, and opinion formation? The thesis reconsiders Habermas’s narrative of public sphere transformation (examined in Chapter 1) in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries through a series of case studies of periodicals printed in Glasgow, including the daily Glasgow Advertiser (1783-), Thomas Johnston’s ILP-aligned weekly Forward (1906-1959), and the Marxian monthly the Socialist (1902-1924). Through readings of the clashing post-bourgeois commercial and proletarian (earlier plebeian) print public spheres, the thesis contributes to comparative historical studies of distinct cultural formations, to Habermasian theory and public sphere studies, and to the history of education in Scotland. Chapter 2 analyses the Glasgow Herald (as the Advertiser became called) and its publishing company George Outram & Co., arguing that the proprietors resolved the dilemma of maintaining an organic community of readers for the mother-publication while pursuing the financial opportunities of an expanded reading public by segmenting the offering with the evening paper Glasgow Evening Times. I analyse the cultural fragmentation effects of commercial print culture, and the Glasgow Herald’s defensive strategies of containment via public opinion management, policing, and directed educational efforts by focussing on its mediation of the 1919 Battle of George Square and debates on post-war reconstruction. Chapter 3 analyses the Socialist which projected a socialist public sphere model, but actually constituted an intervention-driven proletarian counterpublic directed at the ideological and educational needs of the labour movement. I highlight continuities with plebeian radicalism in its educational praxis, and suggest that this formation became entangled in an ambiguous cultural politics which made it prone to isolation from wider working-class culture and legitimising constitutional discourses. Chapter 4 analyses the Forward’s distinctive cultural practices through advertisements, public notices, discussion- and legal-advice columns, showing a cross-class public approximating a deliberative Kantian public sphere model fusing morality with politics and political representation with enlightenment. Through debates on adult education in Forward, and following Raymond Williams, I argue that the labour movement contributed to cultural democratisation in Britain through hegemonic contestation. In the Conclusion, I propose further research into the emergence of critical populism.
Degree
thesis:*- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- PhD
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Glasgow
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Thoreson, Jonas
Subjects
dc:subject × 4Rights
- Language dc:language
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- DOI dc:identifier.doi
- https://doi.org/10.5525/gla.thesis.84962