Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Διερεύνηση ασφάλειας και λειτουργικότητας οδού δυό λωρίδων κυκλοφορίας ως προς την κίνηση διαξονικών οχημάτων σε αυξημένες κατά μήκος κλίσεις

Abstract

dc:description

The existing highway design concept accepts that the safe curve negotiation of a vehicle is not depended on its mass value and its technical characteristics, as well as the longitudinal profile of the road. Contrary to these assumptions, the present study examines the motion of dual-axle vehicles in a 3-D surface concluding that relationships must govern the above mentioned road and vehicle parameters. Studying the vehicle motion, which is safe when no slip occurs in both the lateral and the longitudinal direction of travel, it is necessary to introduce into its description all interacting parameters, namely the road - the vehicle - the driver. This study confined to the interaction of the two former ones, develops relationships that involve elements of design (specifically horizontal radii and grade values) with values related to the vehicle technical characteristics. The behavior of the driver is considered outstanding, thus it is ignored, since a thorough examination towards this direction requires the contribution of other fields (ex. psychology) and escapes the aim of the present research. This thesis is composed of ten chapters that are briefly delineated by the following paragraphs. In the first chapter a review regarding the state of the art is presented where the evaluation of safety is addressed according to road geometry, the vehicle operating speed, and the expected accident rate. In the second chapter the forces acting on a moving vehicle are examined. These forces include aerodynamic forces; forces derived from the interaction between tire and road surface; and the vehicle mass. The tire deformation is examined on both curved and tangent paths. Furthermore, the tire adhesion forces are examined in both directions (longitudinal and lateral), and the relative friction factors are being introduced. Finally, formulas are derived that distribute the vehicle weight to the four wheels during its motion on a curved surface. Thus, the analysis enables the consideration of a four-wheel dynamic model, since the forces acting on the vehicle wheels are segregated to those acting on the driving - rolling axis and on inner - outer wheel of a curve respectively. In the third chapter the state of the art approach of vehicle dynamics is presented and the existing determination of critical design elements is described. The variation in the dynamics of heavy vehicles is reported and their influence on the road traffic capacity is underlined, especially while moving on high grade values. In the fourth chapter the relations describing the accelerating and decelerating motion of a two-axle vehicle are formulated, the assumptions are quoted and the influence of various technical variables is analyzed. Specifically, the vehicle acceleration is expressed through mathematical formulas, introducing the vehicle horsepower, parameters rising from vehicle technical characteristics, road geometry and tire-road adhesion values. The developed dynamic model is compared to other known theoretical and empirical approaches and the methodologies are given in order to determine: • the variation of the vehicle speed due the combination of the horizontal and vertical alignments, • the minimum horizontal radius during the acceleration of a vehicle, • the minimum horizontal radius during the motion of a vehicle with the maximum attainable constant speed (safe speed). In the fifth chapter an analysis regarding the safety of a passenger car is carried out for six different types of passenger cars that includes: • the determination of the minimum horizontal radius during acceleration. • the determination of the maximum attainable constant speed (safe speed) on a wide range of horizontal and vertical alignments as well as its influencing parameters, • the evaluation of OMOE-X design values (Greek road design guidelines) in terms of their capacity to provide minimum values of horizontal radii satisfactory to the motion of the various vehicle types. • the calibration of the statistical model developed herein to calculate the safe speed using field measurements of operating speed. The model is used to determine representative values of road geometry and vehicle technical parameters. In the sixth chapter the same analysis is carried out regarding two-axle trucks. Four types of two-axle trucks are examined under two extreme loading conditions (fully loaded, and unloaded). The analysis also examines the truck roll-over case concluding that the fully loaded case is the critical. In the seventh chapter the influence of the high-grade values to the vehicle operating speed is investigated. The performance of passenger cars and two- axle trucks is examined while statistical models are developed to determine the critical parameters that affect speed variation. Based on the developed models, a methodology is set up of how to apply evaluations of the 3-D road design, especially when high grade is involved. In the eighth chapter the Greek, the German, and the American design guidelines are compared in terms of degree of safety that provide and the differing concept that stand for. In the ninth chapter the validation of the present model is carried out based on field measurements revealing its high capacity of determining under-designed road segments. In the tenth chapter the conclusions and the suggestions for further research of the present thesis are outlined. Conclusions. The critical motion of the examined vehicles is only the motion governed by tractive force. An exception seems to be the case of loaded two-axle trucks when braking mode is combined with high negative grades. In this case, the OMOE-X design guidelines marginally satisfy the safe motion of 19t truck on grade of -8% or more. The four-wheel dynamic model (bicycle model + load transfer) simulating a vehicle, when it negotiates a curve, excels the plain bicycle model. Actually, it increases the determined minimum horizontal radius by 30% for passenger cars and doubles it for two-axle unloaded trucks. The introduction of the horse-power rate during the safety investigation of a vehicle concerns a factor of major importance that is necessary to determine the maximum attainable constant speed (safe speed) among a great number of horizontal and vertical alignment combinations. The research regarding the determination of Rmin during the motion of a vehicle under acceleration and maximum utilization of the available horsepower rate reveals that the Rmin values depend on whether the vehicle utilizes a portion or the total of the available horse power rate. Regarding the passenger cars, the present research confirmed an empirical study that claims that longitudinal grades up to 5% do not affect substantially the vehicle speed. Additionally, it is also noticed that increasing safe speed values are required for increasing mass values and/or decreasing buoyancy force coefficient values. The parameters that affect Vsafe are the horizontal and vertical road profile, tire-road adhesion values and the buoyancy force coefficient. In the case of unloaded trucks, the longitudinal center of gravity location and the horizontal design affect substantially the Vsafe values especially on mild grades. In the case of loaded trucks, it was found that the Vsafe values are not depended on the horizontal radius when is superimposed by high positive grades. Contrary, they depend on the radius value when such value is small and superimposed by low grades. The roll-over only of the 19t loaded truck is expected to occur on favorable friction pavement, when mild grade values are combined with low radii. Finally, it is found that “small” passenger cars may experience unsafe conditions moving on wet pavement and grades of 8% or more by a speed of 90km/h and over. Suggestions. The dynamic analysis of unloaded two-axle trucks reveals that OMOE-X has a confined capacity to provide safe design values especially when high positive grade values are involved. Therefore, the adoption of a speed limit exclusively for trucks is proposed. The correlation between the field measured operating speed and the Vsafe values of passenger cars reveals that several combinations of high grade values and low radii accepted nowadays are unsatisfactory for the safe motion of several mostly “small” vehicles. This finding concerning wet pavements must be checked whether holds and up to what level for dry pavements as well, which requires corresponding measurements to be carried out. Contrary to the passenger-car case, it is found that the truck motion may be unsafe even on dry pavements. The fact that the pavement friction and in greater extend the location of the gravity center have been proved critical parameters, complicates the drawing of certain conclusions regarding the safety degree of this particular type of vehicles. To carry out a sensitivity analysis and determine the entire set of unsafe cases, new measurements ought to be performed distinguishing the cases of the loaded and unloaded trucks. The suggested model is able to predict with satisfactory accuracy the instant speed value of any design vehicle moving on any combination of horizontal and vertical alignments. Thus, it could be a useful tool for contributing to the determination of the expected level of service of the road segments. This research is confined to the investigation of the critical scheme horizontal - vertical alignment (constant radii and grade values respectively). The extension of the model towards the entire set of combination alignments as well as their enrichment with all common vehicle types are prerequisites for completing the investigation of the problem examined in this study.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2002

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Mavromatis, Stergios
  • Μαυρομάτης, Στέργιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/13568

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Mavromatis, Stergios; Μαυρομάτης, Στέργιος. Διερεύνηση ασφάλειας και λειτουργικότητας οδού δυό λωρίδων κυκλοφορίας ως προς την κίνηση διαξονικών οχημάτων σε αυξημένες κατά μήκος κλίσεις. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2002. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/13568