Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Μεταβολές της "εικόνας του σώματος" σε ασθενείς που υποβλήθηκαν σε μεταμόσχευση οργάνου
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of this study was to investigate body image changes in transplant patients. The general part of the study introduces a comprehensive literature review of the concept of body image, its evolution and evaluation from several different disciplines, with a particular emphasis on the internal body image. Our discussion draws on Lipowski’s (1977) definition of body image as perceptions of, attitudes towards, and beliefs about one's body and its functions. The next chapter presents the multiple realities of transplantation and the dilemmas associated with this form of treatment, as well as an overview of organ transplant psychiatry literature, and a critical review of the psychosocial dimensions of the quality of life research in organ recipients. In the third chapter, our study turns into an extensive review and an evaluation of published findings in the effects of transplantation on the body image. The specific part presents the aims of the study and the main hypothesis. Two hundred and twenty patients (heart-, lung-, liver-, renal- candidates and recipients) from the Organ Transplant Units and a Dialysis Unit in Northern Greece were enrolled. These patients were assessed within the framework of liaison-psychiatry to the Organ Transplant Units. The patients completed the Draw a Person test, and Inside-of-the-Body test. The tests were performed at the end of a 30 to 90 minutes-long interview, which included a semi-structured psychiatric clinical assessment, specialized psychosocial evaluation regarding the transplantation (Psychosocial Assessment of Candidates for Transplantation, Olbrisch 1989) and a discussion of ‘transplant and donor’. Only the drawings that were acquired in the first interview of each patient entered the data set. Several groups (employees, medical students, obese individuals with body- image concerns, cardiac surgery patients, and family members of transplant patients) served as controls. Both quantitative and qualitative analyses of the drawings were performed. Results from Draw a Person testing showed that drawings by the transplant patients were significantly different from those of normal controls, although not from the drawings of the obese group. Of note, examiner and situational variables had a significant impact on the results. There were not significant differences between drawings from candidates and recipients, renal- liver- and heart- patients, hospitalized or not patients. Qualitative analyses showed that patients’ drawings were poorly formed and rather disorganized. In the Inside-of-the-Body testing, patient groups drew the diseased organ more often than the control groups. The renal recipients drew two kidneys more often than the control groups; interestingly enough, the graft was rarely depicted on the drawings. Certain drawings among renal patients depicted kidneys in a unique and peculiar way, i.e. reverse circumference of the kidneys, kidneys drawn in the out-of-the-body space... In renal patients a significant association was found between the depiction of the kidneys in the Inside-of-the-Body test and better performance in Draw a Person test. The above findings suggest that ‘the new organ is not psychologically inert’ (Castelnuovo-Tedesco, 1981). In addition, they are not consistent with the more traditional interpretation of a gradual incorporation of the transplanted organ; rather, they seem to suggest that the graft is placed in an intermediate space, and the patients treat it as a transitional object. The defense mechanism of denial is activated for the psychological ‘acceptance’ of the new organ. Based on our findings, we believe that renal transplantation research could be a fruitful field for the study of body image in transplantation. In addition, the finding of denial as a basic defense suggests that clinical research should re-evaluate patients' narratives, including data gathered from self-administered questionnaires and be less willing to accept them at face value. From a clinical management point of view, our work would support recommendations for Human Figure Drawings to be included in formal clinical examination settings. They are easy to use and could reveal important information about the patients. As the graft tends to be psychologically active, practical measures that facilitate the psychological graft compatibility (/acceptance) -such as non-disclosure of any donor- or graft-related information- should be seriously considered. This work documents the variable, and often times latent meanings of transplantation for each patient. In addition, it should alert clinicians to overlooked or hidden body image disturbances and their implications. In our view, although there is no doubt that transplant patients need a ‘time for silence’ (Mai, 1985) and physicians should respect it, it is equally true that, when patients express the desire to talk about ‘the strange things that are crossing their minds’, they should be encouraged to do so by physicians who are able to tune into this kind of discussion.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2002
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Syngelakis, Markos
- Συγγελλάκης, Μάρκος
Subjects
dc:subject × 14Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/14000