National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Γεωγραφικά συστήματα πληροφοριών: διερεύνηση σφαλμάτων στις διαδικασίες ψηφιακής καταγραφής υψομετρικών καμπυλών και δημιουργίας ψηφιακών μοντέλων υψομέτρων
Abstract
dc:descriptionDigital Elevation Models (D.E.Ms.) can be generated through digitizing of analogue topographic paper maps or sources such as stereo - photogrammetry, stereo satellite imaging, radar sources and topographic field measurements. While the latter sources are currently more widespread in mass production processes of digital elevation information (D.E.Ms.), the former is still used by single users because of simplicity, low cost for small projects and its ease of application in local areas. The procedure of D.E.M. generation from analogue topographic paper maps, comprises three main steps, namely digitizing the contours of the map, transformation of coordinates of contours and interpolation. However, the issue of the accuracy of the final D.E.M. is affected by the error associated in each of the three steps. Although there has been described in the literature studies on the errors on individual steps, there is lack of thorough examination of all parameters affecting the final product of D.E.M. This thesis deals with the issue of elevation information of D.E.Ms., which have been generated from analogue maps and studies the error generation in the procedures of manual digitizing contours of analogue maps and their propagation into the DEM construction. The thesis has aimed to develop quality control procedures for the production of a Digital Elevation Error Model (D.E.E.M.), which will effectively produce height error information for each point comprising the contours of the D.E.M. The thesis deals with each step of the D.E.M. generation procedure separately, and studies the errors associated with each one. In this way, each step is treated autonomously and suitable quality control can be applied in such a way that the accuracy of the final product, which is the D.E.M., is controlled. This thesis hopes to help on the definition of rules and prescriptions for the quality of the generated elevation information of D.E.M.s. Other issues that have been studied in this thesis are: • The examination of the digitizing step and the produced errors, is based on the use of a "simulated" specially designed and with a representation of a realistic topographic map, which includes the geometric characteristics of interest. • The relationship of the geometry of the digitized contour lines with the associated horizontal errors is described through correlations and simple linear functions. Also, linear models have been developed, for the estimation and simulation of the digitizing errors. • The study of the horizontal errors generated in the digitizing step and how these are influenced by the geometric characteristics of the contour lines and the personal characteristics of the digitizing personnel. • A proven procedure is suggested for estimating the elevation errors of D.E.M.s, taking into account all the steps required for their generation (from the analogue paper map through to the interpolation of elevations). This thesis comprises eleven chapters and is divided into three parts. The first part reviews all the relevant literature. The second part includes the design, application and analysis of the digitizing step and the coordinate geometrical transformation step in the procedure. Finally the third part covers the design, application and analysis of the interpolation step, followed by the presentation of the results and conclusions of this research. Specifically, the objectives of the thesis were: • The development of models associating the geometry of the contours with the errors generated during the digitizing step. • Algorithm development for the study of total errors which are affected by a number of parameters in each step of transformation and interpolation. • Derivation of realistic quality indicators for heights, estimated from the D.E.M. • Investigate the use of "simulated" topographic maps to the validation of the developed models for the error estimation of the D.E.M. The main conclusions of this research are: • The digitizing error is dependent on the curvature, the complexity and the direction of the contour line being digitized. It is also dependent on the density of the contour lines at the nearby area, where digitizing takes place. • The horizontal errors, resulting from the digitizing step are noteworthily (99.7% of them are within the range of 0mm - 0.54mm), and can even exceed the scale resolution of the specific map being digitized.• Considering the horizontal errors, resulting from the digitizing step, as an ordered series of data, it can be noticed that there is a correlation of 75% between two adjacent errors. • The horizontal errors resulting from the digitizing step, present a 20% increment on the north - south direction of digitizing in comparison with the east - west direction. • The models of the digitizing step error estimation are statistically accepted (confidence level 95%) and can be used in digitizing simulation procedures. • The coordinate transformation creates horizontal errors of magnitude 20% to 60% of the horizontal errors generated by the digitizing step, which have to be taken into account, but smaller in comparison to the errors created in the digitizing step. • The use of a large number for control points in the coordinate transformation step, does not improve substantially the accuracy of the final product (D.E.M.). • The use of the error due to the analogue map’s scale and the digitizer's mechanical error, as an initial error of the digitizing step, contributes 33-50% to the accuracy of the final D.E.M. • A comparison between the estimated D.E.M. errors and the respective errors derived empirically by Imhof [Imhof 1982] for analogue maps, has shown that these latter errors deviate from the former errors, by 50% to 90%. • The contribution of the digitizing step is greater than the contribution of the interpolation step (15% to 40% greater), as it concerns the final D.E.M. error. • Decreasing the resolution of the generated D.E.M. (pixel increment), the contribution of the digitizing step to the final D.E.M. error decreases, comparatively with the contribution of the interpolation step.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2002
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Achilleos, Georgios
- Αχιλλέως, Γεώργιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Σφάλμα
- Ακρίβεια
- Ψηφιακά μοντέλα υψομέτρων
- Ψηφιοποίηση
- Μετασχηματισμός συντεταγμένων
- Παρεμβολή
- Ισοϋψείς καμπύλες
- Errors
- Accuracy
- Digital elevation models
- Digitization
- Coordinates transformation
- Interpolation
- Contour lines
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Πολιτικού Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Civil Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/16787