University of Patras
Αποτίμηση τεχνολογίας κατ' οίκον αιμοκάθαρσης, μελέτη των παραγόντων που επιδρούν στην υιοθέτησή της και αξιολόγηση ποιότητας ζωής των αιμοκαθαιρομένων στην Ελλάδα
Abstract
dc:descriptionEnd stage renal failure is the irreversible loss of kidney function. When loss of kidney function reaches the point at which die kidneys fail to support life, then renal replacement therapy (RRT) is required, that is hemodialysis (HD), peritoneal dialysis or renal transplantation. Hospital hemodialysis is conducted 3 times per week and lasts 3-5 hours. Home hemodialysis takes places at patient’s home, offering flexibility in choosing the frequency (3-7 times Week) and the length of the hemodialysis session (4-10 hours). Daily nocturnal home hemodialysis in particular, which is conducted while the patient is asleep, offers significant clinical benefits, the opportunity of social and professional rehabilitation, reduction of drugs, freedom in diet and drinking intake, as well as improvement in patients' quality of life. According to recent records, more than 10.000 Greek patients suffer from end stage renal disease (ESRD) and 74% of them use hemodialysis as replacement therapy, while at die same time there is increasing pressure on hemodialysis units because of the growing number of patients who are receding hemodialysis. In 2004, Greece appeared to have the highest incidence per million population in hemodialysis, in comparison with 24 European countries and the 31 place in die world in the incidence per million population in RRT, after USA and Japan. The rating of Greece in the 8th place of global comparison in prevalence in RRT, although more propitious, remains very high suggesting die extent of the increasing number of ESRD m Greece. Among the factors that contribute to the existence of this phenomenon are the very low numbers of renal transplantation in Greece, which holds the 20th place among 24 European countries m 2004 and the increase of survival of patients on RRT. This doctoral thesis focuses on technology assessment of home HD, the study of the factors that affect its adoption and finally die evaluation of Greek hemodialysis patients' quality of life. The specific objectives are: i) To evaluate the quality of life of Greek hemodialysis patients, as well as their willingness to participate in a home HD program and ii) To conduct a review of the literature in order to assess whether home hemodialysis is more effective and with better cost-utility than hospital hemodialysis and to gather and analyze data taken from the inquiring visit in experienced home hemodialysis units of foreign countries. Data concerning die health related quality of life of 146 Greek hemodialysis patients were gathered from 10 HD units in Greece and the response rate was 84%. The renal disease specific instrument KDQOL-SF was used (which incorporates the general health instrument SF-36), accompanied with an additional questionnaire and an informative leaflet on nocturnal home hemodialysis, in order to gather demographic data and to evaluate the willingness of participation m a home hemodialysis program. Questionnaires were completed with onsite interview. This study included 99 men and 47 women, with mean age 57 +/- 15,7 years. Although 61% of the participants were in productive age, only 23% were employed and the rest were either unemployed, on sick leave or receiving a disability pension, while 62% of the patients reported annual income less than 10.000 Euros. Diabetes mellitus was the most common primary kidney disease (20%) and the majority of patients were on hemodialysis for less than five years. Three patients were obliged to change place of residence so as to be closer to the hemodialysis unit, while almost 45% of the patients had to navel more than 40km, 3 times per week, for every HD session. The lowest scores in KDQOL-SF scales were found in work status, in sexual functioning and m the burden of kidney disease. The comparison of the SF-36 scales of die study sample with the Greek general population identified statistically significant differences (p<0.01) in all scales, except of the bodily pain scale. Moreover, the Mental Component Summary was slightly worse compared with the general population's, while the Physical Component Summary was quite lower. The results of the present study sample (N=146) were compared with an equivalent sample of Spanish ESRD patients (N=194) who completed the same questionnaire. The fact that m this comparison no statistically significant difference was found in the scale of bodily pain, strengthens the validity of the measurement and suggests that ESRD patients did not experience severe suffering from pain due to their disease that could worsen their perception of health related quality of life. Inclination to participate in nocturnal home HD was expressed by 84% of the patients and by 75% of the patients for home hemodialysis. Strong willingness was reported in 53% of the patients for nocturnal home HD and in the 38% for home HD respectively, while the 38% of the patients were also willing to contribute financially in order to participate. The inquiring visit in two experienced home hemodialysis units in Lund and Helsinki, provided valuable information concerning their organization, their waging, their experience and their know-how, which are related with the structure of the program, economical evaluations, medical data, statistical outcomes, methods of training and potential risks or problems that might emerge, together with advices on how to avoid or solve them. The demographical data in combination with the high cost renders hospital hemodialysis one of the most expensive medical interventions and certainly the most expensive among the other RRT methods. Hemodialysis cost in Greece absorbs more than 2% of total health expenditure. The review of the global literature and the study on the Scandinavian home HD units verified that both home and satellite hemodialysis are less costly and more cost-effective than hospital hemodialysis, while at the same time they present increased survival and better quality of life. Hence, the development of these alternative modalities of dialysis in Greece could mitigate the anticipated net cost increases of RRT to the health system. This could contribute to the alleviation of the increasing pressure on hospital HD units and the nursing shortage, with the simultaneous improvement of hemodialysis patients' quality of life. With the appropriate organization and staff, home hemodialysis could be feasible also in Greece, since big part of the patients are reporting willingness to participate and this fulfils the basic requirement for such a program to succeed. In addition, considering that Greece reports very high incidence, efforts must be intensified in order to restrain and reduce this phenomenon, through informing and prevention programs, which next to renal transplantation are the most effective ways to confront the problem.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2007
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Stavrianou, Kalliroi
- Σταυριανού, Καλλιρόη
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Κατ' οίκον αιμοκάθαρση
- Ποιότητα ζωής
- Αποτίμηση τεχνολογίας υγείας
- Home hemodialysis
- Quality of life ( QOL)
- Health techonology assessment
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Βιοϊατρική Μηχανική
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Engineering and Technology
- Medical Engineering
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Health Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/16899