National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Συμβολή στην αξιολόγηση οδοστρωμάτων αεροδρομίων
Abstract
dc:descriptionContemporary airport management is under pressure to maximize profits by the most efficient use of the transportation infrastructure, whilst facing an ever increasing demand for air transport. The adoption of a simple and reliable procedure for rating the aircraft load and checking the adequacy of the pavement bearing capacity would form a significant tool in support of effective airport management. In addition, the use of a classification and reporting system may facilitate the information exchange among the different parts involved in air transport matters (airport managers, airline operators, aircraft manufacturers). Considering this fact, the ICAO (International Civil Aviation Organisation) has introduced the ACN-PCN (Aircraft Classification Number-Pavement Classification Number) method which currently is the only universally accepted system for rating the aircraft load and reporting the bearing capacity of pavements. However, despite the wide use of the ACN-PCN there are several questions about the suitability and accuracy of the method regarding the comparison of the effect of the different aircraft and the examination the adequacy of the pavement bearing capacity. More specifically, as shown also in this research, there are several cases when aircrafts with lower ACNs proved to be more damaging for pavements compared to aircrafts with higher ACNs. In addition, the estimation of a pavement PCN using several internationally accepted methods provides very different and incomparable results, leading to the conclusion that the PCN of a pavement does not express its bearing capacity in a unique matter. As consequence, it seems not possible to have a reliable indication for the pavement bearing capacity by its PCN reporting. It should be noted here that according to the ACN-PCN method assumptions, for the asphalt pavements the critical load effect of an aircraft is estimated only for the possibility of the subgrade failure. This is very important since the ACNs do not take into account the potential critical effect for other layers and materials, including the possibility of producing significant damage or failure of the asphalt concrete or hydraulically bound materials. In addition, the adoption of the CBR (California Bearing Ratio) method for the definition of the ACN limits its capabilities, especially in relation with pavement analyses using computational tools. Taking all these into account, in this research an alternative classification system is introduced, based on a new index named ALI (Aircraft Loading Index) for expressing the relative aircraft load effect. In contrast to older indexes such as the LCN and the ACN which use equivalent single wheel with constant pressure, the ALI utilizes an equivalent single wheel load with constant radius (R) and variable pressure (P) which is a function of the actual air craft load. For each pavement type and category, a suggested R value has been estimated and for each aircraft a pressure value P can be estimated after suitable calculations so as to produce a critical effect for the pavement similar to that the actual load. Following the international practice the critical effect for flexible pavements was assumed to take place at the bottom of the asphalt concrete layer (fatigue) and the top of the subgrade (permanent deformation). For semi-rigid pavements, the critical effect is assumed to be at the bottom of the hydraulically bound base layer (fatigue). As shown, in all cases the deviations between the ALI equivalent single wheel estimations and the actual load are acceptable. The necessary calculations was made using analytical tools and more specifically the APSA (Airport Pavement Structural Analysis) software, which uses the multi-layer elastic theory and has been developed in the NTUA Laboratory of Highway Engineering and the well known ABAQUS 3D finite element software. Further investigations towards the verification of ALI capability to express the critical effect of aircraft load at a pavement were undertaken using Large Scale Facility (LFC) test data. Data used in the models derives from airport pavement testing undertaken at the National Airport Pavement Facility (NAPTF) by FAA in cooperation with Boeing. The investigation of ALI included comparison of (a) the critical effect of the actual load and the ALI as it is estimated using analytical methods and (b) the ALI estimation and the measured critical stress or strain. The research showed that the ALI estimations for the critical stress and strain values do not differ from the respective of the actual load. After successfully completing the ALI investigation, it is possible to further utilize it for the classification and checking of the bearing capacity of airport pavements. For this purpose, the Airport Pavement Capacity Index (APCI) is introduced, which expresses the bearing capacity of a pavement in terms of the maximum ALI that can be serviced for a selected number of operations. Through a simple procedure which relates the pavement APCI and the ALI values of the aircrafts that use the pavement it is possible to examine whether the bearing capacity is adequate to serve the requested traffic, as well as to estimate the expected damage or remaining life of the pavement. Preliminary applications of the proposed method seem to be very promising for the practical use and extension of the ALI and APCI indexes. The major findings from the investigations undertaken are the following: • The ACN estimation for the aircraft relative effect on a pavement may not be adequately reliable. In several cases aircrafts with lower ACNs proved to have a more severe effect compared to others with higher ACN. The PCN estimation provides results which are difficult to use in practice since the different methods provide incompatible, not comparable results. • At least for the asphalt pavements, the ACN-PCN method provides only rough indications about the relative effect of the aircraft load and the pavement bearing capacity. For this reason in practice it is rarely used as a contribution for the management of airport pavements. • The proposed, new ALI index is suitable for the estimation and rating of the aircraft load effect for different types of asphalt pavements. Based on investigations using real-time data, the ALI estimation for the critical stresses and strains are similar to those of the actual gear. • Compared to ACN, the ALI estimation of the critical effect of an aircraft is closer to that of the actual gear. • By using ALI and APCI it is possible to examine the adequacy of pavement bearing capacity using results from both traditional pavement analyses and modern computational tools. • The proposed ALI-APCI method can provide useful information for managing airport pavements by investigating the effect of different scenarios for traffic changes. • The ALI-APCI method can provide information and estimations about the pavement adequacy and the potential effect of serving the new large aircraft types such as the A380.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2008
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Charonitis, G.
- Χαρωνίτης, Γεώργιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 15Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/17053