Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Αξιολόγηση της αποτελεσματικότητας των χειρουργικών επεμβάσεων για το ροχαλητό και την αποφρακτική υπνική άπνοια βάσει της μελέτης ύπνου
Abstract
dc:descriptionSince antiquity, the subject of interrupted sleep accompanied by loud snoring and daily somnolence has been an object of study by physicians attempting to correct what they perceived as an anomalous sleeping condition. The publication in 1837 of “The Posthumous Papers of the Pickwick Club” authored by Charles Dickens, presented and accurately described most facets of advanced obstructive sleep apnea syndrome to the medical community for the first time, creating public interest in a condition so prevalent as to affect all strata of modern society. A century and a half later, the entity now known as OSAS (obstructive sleep apnea-hypopnea syndrome) is a well-known syndrome characterized by loud rhonchopathy, recurring obstruction of the upper airway leading to interrupted sleep and daytime fatigue and sleepiness, associated with a multitude of pathologic conditions such as systemic hypertension, diabetes, cardiovascular/coronary disease with impairment of the cardiac function, pulmonary hypertension, cardiac arrhythmia, gastro-oesophageal regurgitation, reproductive dysfunction, endocrine dysfunction, ultimately leading to obesityhypoventilation-hypoxemia syndrome and increased mortality. This extremely diverse array of medical conditions, whether precursors, concurrences, or consequences of obstructive sleep apnea, has emerged as a challenge to the entire medical body due to its ramifications and to the dire outcome to patients if left untreated, for sleep apnea syndrome will in fact increase morbidity and ultimately mortality to the estimated 2-4% of all adults diagnosed with the condition. The social, professional, financial, and psychological consequences are also an aspect of sleep apnea and sleep deprivation that burden society as a whole, due in no small part to the dramatic increase in vehicle accidents inadvertently caused by undiagnosed or untreated apneic patients, the costs of which are estimated in the billions. The gravity of the disease and the enormous financial stress that derives from its many complications has led health authorities worldwide to evaluate management strategies in the treatment of OSAS, and in the last few years to attempt to arrive at an optimal, evidencebased therapeutical scheme which would offer cost-effectiveness and maximum benefit to the patients. Although the use of nasal continuous positive airway pressure devices (nCPAP) has proven effective in the past, making it the treatment of choice, the intrusive nature of the device and the unsatisfactory compliance rates have led to a search for other less invasive and more highly compliant methods with similar effectiveness. Surgery has long held an important role in treating snoring and obstructive sleep apnea syndrome, ever since Ikematsu developed uvulopalatoplasty in the 50’s and 60’s, and Fujita modified and laid the guidelines for its modern development and evolution into more complex forms of obstruction relief which in recent years include single-level and multi-level surgery of the upper airway. Also, since the early 90’s, Coleman and Kamami’s experience with laser uvulopalatoplasty has been well documented, and their results diversely criticized as to their effectiveness in relieving upper airway obstruction and/or rhonchopathy. Along with selective palate ablation surgery using radiofrequency probes, the above surgical techniques have constituted the majority of single-level surgery of the upper airway for the past two decades. The fact that no prospective, long-term trials with objective pre- and post-operative follow-up evaluation in the context of pre-determined assessment strategies have ever been conducted in Greece, was a major incentive to instigate the present research. Current management of the disease is usually based on the clinician or surgeon’s intrinsic experience, modified by research publications of such diverse conclusions that a cohesive strategy of treatment cannot easily be extracted. This random approach is incompatible with evidence-based medicine as decreed by current ‘best-practice’ guidelines. The aims of this research, as ordained by the University Otorhinolaryngology Department of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece in the form of a doctoral thesis were therefore to: -evaluate and objectively assess the effectiveness of oropharyngeal surgery in the treatment of sleep apnea syndrome, -determine the individual prognostic factors that would influence the outcome of surgical operations in the treatment of sleep apnea syndrome, -extract conclusions which would assist in the general management of the disease, based on the results of the present thesis and extrapolated from a comprehensive review of international literature on the subject. Ever since the beginning of quantitative evaluation of sleep apnea, sleep studies have proven their worth in accurately recording the patients’ sleep parameters, assessing the gravity of the condition, and providing insight as to possible management of the disease. This ‘golden standard’ of assessment of OSAS was therefore chosen as the common denominator in evaluating the possible beneficial outcomes of the surgical techniques selected to represent non-conservative treatment, and which at present encompass the majority of surgical interventions practiced in Greece for the relief of upper airway obstruction and sleep apnea/hypopnea syndrome. The present study followed the management of a patient group that consisted of 82 subjects; 62 patients who underwent surgical operations for snoring and obstructive sleep apnea between 2001 and 2006 in the ENT/Head & Neck Department of AHEPA University Hospital of Thessaloniki, and a control group of 20 patients who were conservatively treated with a diet regime, appropriate sleeping habits, and the use of nasal CPAP. Initially, these patients were examined in the ENT outpatients department of AHEPA Hospital, and their evaluation included full clinical, endoscopical examination along with personal questionnaires using the Epworth Sleepiness Scale for daytime sleepiness in the context of the apneic syndrome, and Visual Analog Scale scoring for snoring. Polysomnography for all patients was conducted at the Sleep Disorders Department of “St. Paul” Hospital of Thessaloniki, where specialized personnel assured objective sleep study evaluation and reliable results. The 62 surgical patients underwent either uvulopalatopharyngoplasty (UPPP) based on a modified Fujita technique (27 patients) or laser-uvulopalatoplasty (LAUP) using an adapted Kamami technique (35 patients). Initial post-operative evaluation was conducted after a three-six month interval including polysomnography for immediate post-operative results, and repeated after a period of 20-40 months, again with full polysomnographic study and clinical evaluation including self-assessment questionnaires. The 20 subjects that underwent conservative treatment were re-examined at regular intervals and were fully assessed after a similar two-year period. Success or failure criteria were predetermined according to the standard methodology established by Sher (1996) (apnea/hypopnea index (AHI) 25% but less than 50%), lack of significant improvement (final AHI between –25% and +25% of the initial AHI), and failure to improve (final index increased by >25%). Comparative analysis of the objective (clinical and polysomnographical) and subjective (Epworth and snoring questionnaires) results after an initial three-to-six month period concluded that LAUP patients showed similar success rates as UPPP patients as far as the apnea/hypopnea index was concerned (40.0% for LAUP and 33.3% for UPPP), with statistically insignificant variability for lesser degrees of improvement (11.4% minor improvement, 40.0% unimproved, and 8.6% aggravation for LAUP patients, compared with 33.3% minor improvement, 14.8% unimproved, and 18.5% aggravation for UPPP) (p>0.05). The same applied to other polysomnographic parameters such as mean SaO2%, and sleep duration with SaO₂% less than 90%, where both surgical groups presented similar degrees of post-surgical findings. Snoring assessment during the first post-operative period showed overall improvement in 91,9% of patients and significant improvement (by >3 points in the 10-point visual analog scale) in 69.4% of the patients, slightly less for LAUP patients (decrease in snoring intensity by avg. 44.5%) than for UPPP patients (decrease in snoring intensity by avg. 53,5%). Epworth questionnaire results were inconclusive in determining the patients’ subjective postoperative improvement or aggravation of daytime sleepiness, both in LAUP and UPPP subjects. However, during the second post-operative follow-up >2-3 years after the surgical operations, statistical significance (p<0.05) was determined in the difference between the treatment of UPPP patients (44.4% success, 14.8% improvement, 33.3% unchanged, and 7.4% aggravation) and that of LAUP patients (14.3% success, 11.4% improvement, 51.4% unchanged and 22.9% aggravated). Statistical significance was also established in the improvement in mean SaO₂% and in the duration of sleep with SaO₂% less than 90%, where UPPP patients performed better with 25.9% and 55.5% improvement rates respectively, compared to 14.3% and 28.6% for LAUP patients. Snoring assessment during the second post-operative period showed overall improvement in 90.3% of patients and significant, lasting improvement in 56.5% (by >3 points in the VAS), slightly less for LAUP patients (decrease in snoring intensity by avg. 39.1%) than for UPPP patients (decrease in snoring intensity by avg. 43.5%). The 20 conservatively treated patients showed an expected significant improvement of their symptomatology at the two-to-three year follow-up, presenting only minor complications such as iatrogenic rhinitis. The therapeutic interval proved beneficial, as persistent weight therapy in this group managed to improve their mean body-mass index by an average of 2.8 BMI units over the 2-year time period, thus enhancing the beneficial effects of therapy. The epidemiological, clinical and polysomnographic data for the patients were analyzed in order to establish a potential diagnostic factor that would assist in predicting a favorable surgical outcome. The variables examined included sex, age, BMI, smoking, diabetes, gastrooesophageal reflux, Epworth sleepiness scale score, Mueller endoscopy classification of the upper airway obstruction, initial diagnostic polysomnography results such as the apneahypopnea index AHI, O₂ saturation %, and duration of sleep with SaO₂%<90%. The first post-operative review revealed a statistically significant difference (p<0.05) in surgical improvement linked to age, pre-operative AHI, SaO₂%, SaO₂%<90, and a less significant but statistically present (p<0.1) difference linked to pre-operative BMI. The second post-operative (long-term) review revealed a statistically significant differences (p<0.05) in surgical improvement linked to the initial BMI value and BMI category, and to the initial AHI. A less significant (p<0.1) statistical difference in surgical results was found linked to initial SaO2%, SaO2%<90 patient age at the time of the post-operative review (p=0.1), and presence of arterial hypertension, and diabetes. Additionally, the pre-operative Mueller airway classification was found to predispose to better long-term post-operative results (30.2% successful treatment and 9.3% improvement) in cases where single-level obstruction was established, as opposed to poorer results in cases where multi-level obstruction was diagnosed (7.7% success and 30.8% improvement) (relative statistical significance, p<0.1). The only factors that maintained a predictive significance throughout the entire post-operative period were initial apnea-hypopnea index AHI (p<0.05), where essentially AHI<40 predisposed to better surgical results while AHI>40 predisposed to poorer surgical results, and to a lesser extent initial body-mass index BMI (p<0.1), where BMI<30kg/m² predisposed to a better surgical outcome rather than BMI>30kg/m² which predisposed to a poorer surgical result, to a less exact significance however. The other factors including age, sex, smoking, hypertension, diabetes, Epworth score and Mueller classification, although linked to a loosely significant extent with a degree of post-operative improvement or lack thereof, were not found to have highly reliable prognostic value. The results, their significance, and their relevance to the international literature are discussed at length in the present diatribe. The intrinsic multi-systemic nature of the sleep apnea syndrome is highlighted in the context of a multi-disciplinary approach in which surgical management maintains specific indications, and mention is made of the increasing value that is currently being attached to multi-level surgery. Indeed, single-level surgery adressing the oropharynx in the form of pharyngo-palatoplasty has been the mainstay of surgical management for the last decades of the twentieth century, however concerns over its longterm effectiveness have led to the recent development of techniques that address several levels of the upper airway and that seem to present better alternatives. It seems that recent data validate the multi-level approach, and favorably compare its efficacy to the simpler, single-level surgery, although no optimal combination of techniques has been favored with universal consensus. A realistic approach to a complex pathology, involving all the relevant specialties is seen as essential to a long-term improvement, as opposed to transient upper airway relief, targeting not only the upper airway resistance but also the underlying etiologies contributing to the apneic syndrome.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2008
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Petridis, Dimitrios
- Πετρίδης, Δημήτριος
Subjects
dc:subject × 14Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/19586