Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Συγκριτική μελέτη βιολογικών και συνθετικών υλικών στην γυναικολογική ουρολογία
Abstract
dc:descriptionIntroduction: The new minimal access surgical methods repair more effectively the pelvic floor prolapse in woman than the classical methods. The purpose of this study is to compare the best synthetic material (polypropylene + polygalactic acid) to the best biological material (special processing porcine dermis) when they are used in these techniques. Materials and methods. The study applies at 128 women who suffered from symptomatic prolapse of the vaginal wall, uterine prolapse, stress incontinence and combinations of the above diseases. We excluded patients who did not complete their family, women who had more than three recurrences or women who were suffered from autoimmune disease. All the patients have been informed about the study and the possible complications and they gave writing consent. A question form regarding the mains symptoms and their effectiveness on the quality of life was completed at 6 and 12 months after the surgery. The patients were categorized in 4 groups depending on the type of the procedure: repair of cystocele, repair of rectocele, posterior IVS for uterine prolapse, enterocele or vault prolapse and TOT for stress incontinence. The majority of women belongs to more than one group because it is ethical appropriated to treat the patient and no the disease. The repair of cystocele (n=64) started with dissection of the bladder to the arcus tenodium following by the fixation of the appropriate size mesh – synthetic, vyproII (n=32) or biological, permacol (n=32) - at the arcus tenodium. The rectocele repair (n=66) was done by the method of site specific repair of Denonvillier’s fascia followed by the fixation of the appropriate size mesh – synthetic, vyproII (n=33) or biological, permacol (n=33) - at the arcus tenodium of rectovaginal fascia. At the cases of stress incontinence (n=52) I introduced a transoburator tension free tape under the urethra – synthetic, uretex (n=27) or biological, permacol (n=25) - (out in method) in a distance of 1,5 cm from the urethral meatus. The women suffered from enterocele, uterine or vault prolapse (n=48) underwent posterior slingoplasty. We introduced a tension free tape – synthetic, tyco IVS (n=24) or biological, permacol (n=24) – 3 cm lower and lateral from the anus through the ischiorectal fossa. At the level of the ischiac spine (very close to the sacrospinal ligament) the tape was turned to the other side over the rectum where it was fixed on the cardinal ligaments or to the isthmus of the uterus. The tape was coming out symmetrically to the opposite gluteal area. We studied the anatomical and functional results to a three year period. Results. Cystocele repair with mesh augmentation. The anatomical result of the repair was excellent with both types of mesh (96,8% at synthetic’s group and 93,76% at the biological’s group). The type of mesh did not affect the improvement of the detrusor instability (10% at synthetic’s group and 11,11% at the biological’s group). Postoperative dyspareunia appeared statistically significant at synthetic’s group p = 0,05 only when the patient had hystererectomy at the same time. There was no statistical significance in the frequency of the postoperative urinary infection, erosion, granuloma, recurrence of cystocele or enterocele independent of the performance of simultaneous hysterectomy. Nevertheless there is a tendency of more frequent appearance of postoperative erosion (12,5% versus 0%) and granuloma formation (9,35% versus 3,12%) at the synthetic’s group. Rectocele repair with mesh augmentation. We have observed perfect anatomical repair at 93,93% independently of the mesh type whereas healing of constipation at the 12,12% of the synthetic’s group and at 18% of the biological group. Pelvicol produce statistical less total complications than vyproII (p=0,020). De novo dyspareunia (12,12% versus 3,03%), granuloma (12,12% versus 3,03%) and vaginal erosion (9,09% versus 0%) appeared more frequent after the application of the vyproII without reaching statistical significance. The simultaneous performance of hysterectomy appears not to effect the frequency of complications except of the granuloma formation (p=0,034%). Transobturator tension free tape (ΤΟΤ) for stress incontinence. None the less the tape type the success of the method was very high (96%) even in cases of mixed incontinence (80%). The complication rate is very low and no serious (interoperative vaginal perforation, pain at the thigh and haematoma formation) independently of the simultaneous performance of hysterectomy. The rate of postoperative urinary infection is higher at the biological’s tape group (16% versus 3,7% of the synthetic’s tape group) without reaching statistical significance. Posterior IVS or slingoplasty for enterocele, vault or uterine prolapse. The above method is very effective (95,84%) in both tape types. The treatment of constipation as well is around 12,5% with both types of the tape. There is no correlation of the tape type and the rate of postoperative haematoma formation, enterocele and rectocele. Despite of the rate of postoperative urinary infection, de novo dyspareunia, and granuloma formation are more frequent in the synthetic’s tape group there are not statistical significant. The usage of synthetic tape is accompanied with 41,67% rate of postoperative vaginal erosion versus 0% rate of erosion in the biological’s tape group that is statistical significant 0,01(<p=0,05). Conclusion. The biological meshes that are produced by porcine special processing dermis are equal effective with polypropylene meshes for the anatomical repair of pelvic prolapse but associated with less complications and better functional results. Their effectiveness and complication rate for TOT operations are similar with polypropylene tapes but their use is prohibited because of higher cost. Multifilament polypropylene is not suitable for posterior ΙVS.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2008
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Papachatzopoulos, Stergios
- Παπαχατζόπουλος, Στέργιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/19592