Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Η πολλαπλότητα των τρόπων επίλυσης των διαφορών μεταξύ κρατών και ξένων επενδυτών
Abstract
dc:descriptionAs late as two decades ago, the international law rules dedicated exclusively on foreign investment were rare. Until the beginning of the nineties foreign investment transactions were regulated by general public international law and by several bilateral investment treaties, which, nevertheless, had not been interpreted by any investment arbitral tribunal. The legal instruments dealing solely with foreign investments and foreign investment disputes increased significantly during the nineties, when more than 2000 bilateral investment treaties were signed, providing for international arbitration of any dispute arising between the host State and the foreign investor. At that time, the conclusion of the NAFTA and the ECT further contributed in favour of this dynamic evolution. The increased number of legal instruments for the protection and mutual promotion of foreign investment resulted in a corresponding increase of arbitration claims. The lack of hierarchy for the purpose of the application of the foresaid instruments combined with the fact that the foreign investor had recourse to differentiated forums (international arbitral tribunals and national courts) under different identities and qualifications, allowed for the simultaneous or consequent submission of claims before multiple dispute resolution forums. Therefore the issue of multiplicity, in the sense of an existing competitive interaction among the jurisdiction of mechanisms available for the resolution of investment disputes, was dealt first by the jurisprudence of arbitral tribunals. The latter were often called upon to decide on a dispute that was still pending before or was previously submitted and decided upon by the national courts of the host State. In the framework of a single national legal order this problem would be easily resolved by traditional procedural rules that preclude the filling of multiple claims or the existence of parallel judicial proceedings (mostly the principles of lis pendens and res judicata). Nevertheless, in the framework of investment arbitration such rules were impossible to apply since the test of the triple identity of parties, causes of action and the petitum were never met due to the different qualification of the investor and the State under the multiple applicable legal instruments. Multiple proceedings and contradictory decisions on the same or similar disputes among the same or connected parties were labeled as signs of a legitimacy crisis suffered by the legal system of investment dispute resolution. The present thesis enumerates and describes all possible forms of multiple proceedings that may arise due to the interaction and the competitive application of multiple legal instruments regulating the investment dispute. It encodes the arbitral jurisprudence with the purpose of searching the relevant rules that could hierarchise multiple proceedings. It ressembles therefore each symptom of the so called legitimacy crisis in the settlement of disputes between States and foreign investors, focusing on its fundamental causes and explaining in each particular case how the multiplicity of legal sources leads to multiple proceedings, as well as how this issue should be dealt with globally.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2009
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Κουτογλίδου, Αλεξάνδρα
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/19945