Back to search

Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)

Ηθική θεώρηση των τεχνικών παρεμβάσεων στο ανθρώπινο γονιδίωμα

Abstract

dc:description

The revelation that the cell is the fundamental building block of life sparked off a scientific effort to discover therein the secrets of life. A landmark in biological and genetic research was reached when Watson and Crick showed that the answer to the secret of cellular reproduction and inheritance lay in a molecular chain in the nucleus, DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid). This breakthrough paved the way not only for further discoveries, such as mapping the genome of various species, but also for previously inconceivable interventions in the various stages of these organisms’ development. Such interventions or manipulations are called genetic because they aim to modify the genome, the organism’s genetic makeup. Similarly, the technology used in these manipulations is known as gene technology. Genetic manipulation usually aims to give organisms desirable characteristics (e.g. increased crop and livestock yields) or eliminate undesirable ones (e.g. diseases). The technique used is that of recombinant DNA, which allows the addition or removal of genes, and is called genetic engineering. Genetic intervention in man can be divided into three groups: a) Diagnostic, which includes prenatal and preimplantation diagnosis and genetic screening in adults, b) Therapeutic and non-therapeutic, which includes the four types of gene therapy or intervention: somatic cell gene therapy, germ line gene therapy, gene enhancement and genetic eugenics, c) Reproductive, including cloning. Gene technology is also used to manufacture human biological products, in forensic science and in geographical anthropology. These recent medical and biological discoveries, together with their applications, do not promise only benefits for mankind; it is widely accepted that they also conceal grave dangers and ethical dilemmas. This realisation has created an urgent need for an ethical framework to deal with the new moral dilemmas attendant on new medical and especially genetic techniques. This need led to the creation of a new, interdisciplinary, field of study, that of Bioethics. Bioethics, a product of western society, aims to identify and examine the ethical problems associated with the application of modern medical science. On the philosophical level it has been chiefly influenced by the schools of empiricism, utilitarianism, liberalism and individualism. In dealing with bioethical issues it has established four principles: a) autonomy, b) nonmaleficence, c) beneficence, and d) justice. However, despite considerable effort, bioethics has failed to reach a consensus on bioethical issues. This is chiefly due to the different ideologies and beliefs held by bioethicists, which produce a differing moral outlook and criteria. For this reason, when reference is made to bioethicists’ views on a particular bioethical issue, it is standard practice to mention the views of the principle bioethical schools of thought, even if they are mutually contradictory. With regard to the genetic manipulation of crops and livestock, bioethics is mainly concerned with the dangers involved in consuming genetically modified (GM) animal and vegetable products. Other issues are also addressed, however, such as the possible threat of ecological catastrophe arising from the release of such organisms into the environment. Another concern has to do with the ethics of using animals in genetic engineering experiments, an issue of particular importance in western society. The application of genetic engineering to man is an issue of paramount importance in bioethics and is constantly in the news. For the present these techniques are only used in routine medical practice for diagnosis; other applications are still mostly in the experimental stage. The position taken by bioethicists on prenatal and preimplantation diagnosis largely depends on the value they attach to embryonic life. Since there is as yet no way of curing diseases at the prenatal or preimplantation stages, the abortion of fetuses carrying a genetic disorder is seen as the only feasible solution. Those bioethicists who accept abortion base their position on a woman’s right to choose whether or not to have a child. Those opposed take their stand not so much against abortion as such as against a eugenic mentality, which permits the rejection of fetuses with genetic diseases. Genetic screening of adults raises moral questions of a social nature, the most serious being the uncontrolled dissemination of genetic information to employers, insurance companies and elsewhere, with its attendant risks of social exclusion. The principles of nonmaleficence and beneficence underpin the bioethical approach to genetically engineered biological products. Within this framework the vast majority of bioethicists oppose the manufacture of biological weapons. The use of genetics in crime solving is similarly evaluated by bioethics, in this case according to the principles of autonomy. Almost the entire bioethical community approves, provided such techniques do not encroach upon personal liberty. The bioethics of gene therapy and gene manipulation, the applications of genetic engineering to man, form the focus of this study. Somatic cell gene therapy has very few critics, as it does not raise serious ethical questions. It is however important that during its experimental application on humans the patients are made fully aware of the possible risks. Additionally, the high cost of treatment and the limited number of hospital places brings to the fore the principle of justice, without of course ignoring the other three principles. Germ line gene therapy is more promising, but presents greater ethical problems. Every such intervention is permanent and irreversible, hence the majority of bioethicists approve its use only for the prevention and cure of serious diseases. The experiments at the early stages of fetal development that are essential to the success of the research create additional ethical problems. The determination of an individual’s genetic makeup by others, without his consent, contravenes the principle of autonomy. Despite this, germ line gene therapy has many supporters from every branch of bioethics. Genetic modification and enhancement have sparked more bioethical debate than all the other applications of genetic engineering in man. The ability to alter human characteristics at will sets mankind on a completely untrodden path. The changing or improvement not only of physical, but also psychological and moral characteristics naturally raises grave doubts. Although most bioethicists view this application with serious misgivings, there are some who support its use under certain conditions. There is more support for those interventions of a more medical nature, e.g. strengthening the immune system. This has led to considerable debate among bioethicists, medical researchers, political and religious leaders and other concerned parties as to what constitutes ‘disease’ and ‘cure’. It is essential that these terms be defined as clearly as possible in order to prevent eugenic practices from masquerading as gene therapy. The modification and enhancement of the germ line is utterly opposed by almost all bioethicists. All bioethicists also reject eugenic gene manipulation, on the grounds that it falls outside the bounds of the medical profession, affronts human dignity by indirectly infringing on the right to be different and leads to serious social problems. Cloning is now a major bioethics issue that is very much in the news. Most bioethicists are in favour of therapeutic cloning using totipotent stem cells. Those opposed rate the value of embryonic life higher than that of any potential medical benefit. Reproductive cloning is viewed very skeptically by most bioethicists, although quite a few, especially from the field of medicine, are enthusiastic supporters. The arguments for and against cloning are based chiefly on different interpretations of the principle of autonomy and the principle of individual dignity that follows on from the first. Those who see cloning as a legitimate and beneficial reproductive method believe that the only problem lies in its riskiness due to the early stage of scientific research. Orthodox moral theology cannot remain indifferent to such a burning issue as bioethics. However, its participation in the bioethical debate presents certain distinctive features, perhaps even difficulties. The study of bioethics arose in western society, where the way of life, philosophical ideas and morals are far from the spirit of Orthodox morality. In secular bioethics the true nature of morality has essentially been sacrificed by deliberately avoiding any approach to the human condition based on metaphysical considerations. The moral nature of bioethics was thus truncated in order to achieve the greatest possible agreement between bioethicists with different views. As a result bioethics has fallen to the level of professional ethics and has become the handmaiden of politics. Even worse, by indiscriminately adopting the principles of liberalism it has been promoted as the morality of globalisation. Orthodox moral theology must have two aims if it is to provide answers to the contemporary bioethical challenge and especially to the moral questions raised by the applications of gene technology. The first is to study the technical issues and the manner in which bioethical questions are identified, and here it has much to gain by participating in the bioethical debate. The second is to preserve unadulterated its moral character, which springs from the Orthodox Christian view of man. Within this framework one can speak of Orthodox bioethics, which will not be a self-contained branch of study but a special field incorporated into the body of Orthodox moral doctrine. […]

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Year dc:date
2002

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Koios, Nikolaos
  • Κοϊός, Νικόλαος

Subjects

dc:subject × 12

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/20515

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Koios, Nikolaos; Κοϊός, Νικόλαος. Ηθική θεώρηση των τεχνικών παρεμβάσεων στο ανθρώπινο γονιδίωμα. Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH), 2002. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/20515