National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Legal aspects of electronic bill of landing on maritime transportation: a comparative analysis based on international practice
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn recent years, the commercial world has experienced an increasing number of transactions both in respect to international sale contracts and to the contract for carriage of goods by sea. In maritime transportation, it is important to track all good moving from one place to another. By definition, the bill of lading is one of the most important legal documents in shipping. The international trade including transport of good by sea could not have been present without the transport of documents. Also the shipper and the carrier use this bill as a receipt for the merchandises. This is a written evidence of contract of carriage and a negotiable document of title to the goods. Knowing that the new generic technology came to play a huge role in commercial activities and almost every part of our everyday life, we see many industrial sectors as transportations having electronically upgraded. The technology leads to a remarkable improvement of information transfer process in the maritime industry. For example, the development of Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) has essentially enabled transport documents to be transferrable electronically everywhere and anytime. Despite this emergence, the success of bill of lading remains ambiguous in practice. It is found out that electronic bill of lading is not yet widely accepted to be used in the maritime business and, many would likely maintain paper bill. The present thesis discusses the Electronic Bill of Lading, explains how this soft bill of lading may replicate traditional ones, essentially by comparison with the laws and the international rules by summarizing how fundamental traditional properties can be obtained on the basis of electronic bill of lading, it also assesses the situation and potential success in legal practice of one major invention in the maritime industry, namely, the electronic bill of lading by taking into consideration developments of the relevant regulatory frameworks through time by some few important institutions involved including CMI (Committee Maritime International), Bolero (Bills of Lading Electronic Registry Organization) and UNCITRAL (United Nations Commission on International Trade Law). In first Chapter named the essence of the classic bill of lading, explain the definition and the historical background for the bill of lading which beginning as a bailment receipt for goods, then it has developed into a receipt containing the contract for carriage and acquired a third characteristic, a negotiable document of title. After that, described the types of the bill of lading because there are more than one type according to the way of issued. And finally described the data and the most common conditions which written on the bill of lading. In second chapter named the functions of the classic bill of lading, explains the three functions of it. The first function as a receipt which signed by or behalf of the carrier and issued to the shipper acknowledging that the goods, as described in it, have been shipped in a particular vessel to a specified destination or have been received in the carrier’s custody for shipment, the second function is a memorandum of the terms and conditions of the contract of carriage, it can not be said that, the bill of lading is the contract of carriage. The bill of lading is considered to be only an evidence of the contract for carriage of goods by sea. The third function is a document of title to the goods which enables the consignee to take delivery of the goods at their destination or to dispose of them by endorsement and delivery of the bill of lading. In third chapter named the functions of the electronic bill of lading. Explains the definition of the EDI system which is usually consists of communications between the shipper’s computer and the carrier’s, identifies problems or disadvantages of paper bill of lading, which has been widely used for many centuries, and discusses the rationales for their electronic substitutes, i.e., to facilitate commercial transactions in the maritime industry such as to reduce costs and conform to delivery speed of goods in the modern time which are typical and crucial problems when paper bill is used. And the chapter focuses and analyzing the effectiveness of the legal attempts to support the electronic bill to be accepted as fully legally enforceable as in the paper-based case. In doing so, emphasis is placed on the question of how fundamental legal requirements of the traditional bill can also be met by this paperless replacement. The thesis argues that the trendy bill concerned shall be regarded as the electronic equivalent of the paper bill since based on some of the recent guidelines and provisions offered, it certainly satisfies such traditional requirements. That is, the electronic bill of lading is, too, a legal document that can be signed and capable of performing all basic traditional functions which include being a receipt for the goods, being evidence of terms in a contract of carriage and, more sophisticatedly, being a negotiable document of title. In fourth chapter named the attempts to use electronic bill of lading, an examination of the attempts by focusing on how the issues have been handled by many frameworks, models or rules proposed by the international institutions involved was carried out. Generally, those attempts are associated with some of the problems which include the lack of security in the CMI model, and the lack of publicity of the BOLERO system, and the inadequate provisions dealing with legal liabilities of parties under the UNCITRAL Model Laws. In conclusion, it should be determined how those problems have been solved recently by UNCITRAL in order to evaluate the current situation of achievability of electronic bill of lading. As conclusion, the electronic bill of lading is not yet widely accepted to be used in the maritime business and, many would maintain, far from being reliable replacements for paper bill. The functions of the bill of lading can be classified into two broad groups which are the general requirements including writing/document and signature requirements, and specific requirements including three essential functions: (i) as a receipt for the goods; (ii) as evidence of terms and conditions in a contract of carriage; and (iii) as a negotiable document of title to the goods. The thesis points out that achieving the (iii) seems most difficult and much space herein is therefore devoted to discussing the attempts of the relevant institutions at handling this issue so as to facilitate the use of electronic bill of lading.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2010
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Khasawneh, Saleem
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Εμπορικό δίκαιο
- Διεθνείς συμβάσεις πώλησης
- Ηλεκτρονική ανταλλαγή δεδομένων
- Ηλεκτρονική φορτωτική
- Οργανισμός ηλεκτρονικού μητρώου φορτωτικών
- Διεθνές εμπορικό δίκαιο
- Bill of landing
- Electronic bill landing
- Electronic data interchange
- Certification authority
- Bolero bill of landing
- Commercial law
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Social Sciences
- Law
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/20670