National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Οι σύγχρονες τάσεις των θεσμών της παραγραφής και της χρησικτησίας: συγκριτική μελέτη
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis thesis focuses on the trends of legal schools in the world around the topic of Extinctive Prescription and Acquisitive Prescription. It mainly includes the thought of the Islamic school, the Latin school, the German school and the Anglo-Saxon school. Thus, I have succeeded to study various legal trends around the topic of the thesis. The thesis deals with the Extinctive Prescription and the Acquisitive Prescription, as well as it includes aspects of the differences and the similaritiesbetween them. The Islamic doctrine has organized all aspects of life ofsociety by laying downrulesfor stabilizing, safeguarding and setting society at rest. Among the efforts were those of Maliki and Hanafi schools offaith which laid down provisions for defining the rights of creditors and debtors and for organizing the creditor’s claiming for his/her rights as they specified a time limit for claiming so fthe credit or fails to claim to his/her rights from the debtor during the specified time, the judiciary will not respond to the claim after that, for the safeguarding of stable dealings in society and for the realizing of public interest. The consequential effect of not discussing to the creditor’s legal case against the defaulting debtor is the retention of the creditor’s right pursuant to the saying of the honored Messenger: “ A Moslem ’s right cannot be invalidated by prescription”. The two schools of faith laid down, as well, rules for organizing the possession of other’s rights (realties or chattels) for a certain duration after which passage the judiciary shall not discuss the plaintiff’s action in case of unavailability oflegitimate excuse that canjustify satisfaction with other ’s possession of right throughout the specified period. The consequential effect of not discussing the proprietor’s legal case against the possessor is the retention of the proprietor’s right pursuant towards the saying of the honored Messenger: “Whoever possesses some thing for 10 years, he will be the proprietor”. The jurisprudents of each of the Maliki and Hanafi schools of faith judged that in case of termination of time without a claim by the creditor against the debtor or the proprietor’s objection to the possessor of his right, the denying debtor or the denying possessor owns the right to requestjudiciary not to discuss the plaintiff’s action. Some legislation’s have been affected by the thought both Maliki and Hanafi school ’s of faith as they legalized refraining from discussing the lawsuit and laid down provisions that allow defendant to hold to that before judiciary in case of bringing an action against his by the plaintiff after the passage of the specified period. Where as other legislation’s were affected by what was provided in the Latin legal thought which believe in the idea of prescription and the eventual termination of obligation if the creditorfails to claim for debts within a specified duration, and the idea of acquisition of title of the possessive right if the possession lasted for the legally specified period. Finally, there are legislation’s which were affected by what was provided in the German and Anglo-Saxon legal thought which believe in the idea of prescription without the eventual termination of obligation if the creditorfails to claim for debts within a specified duration, and the idea of acquisition of title of the possessive right if the possession lasted for the legally specified period. The importance of research is shown in the study of three systems of positive legislation ’s concerned with the laps of time; a) The first system determines a right for defendant in requesting the court not to discuss the plaintiff’s action, without difference between the Real right and the Personal right, b) The second system determines a rightfor defendant in requesting the dropping (Extinctive Prescription) or gaining (Acquisitive Prescription) of right, without difference between the real right and the personal right, c) The third system (mixed system) determines a right for debtor in requesting the court not to discuss the creditor’s action. Contrarily, this system determines a right for possessor in requesting the gaining of the real right by Acquisitive Prescription. The first system was taken from jurisprudence of Islamic school, and the law provided the condition of denial for the right of the plaintiff from the defendant. The second system was taken from the legal thought of the Latin school. The third system was taken from the legal thought of the German school and the Anglo-Saxon school. We have presumed that the Islamic school agrees with the system of Acquisitive Prescription, however, disagrees with the system of Extinctive Prescriptionfor the reasons which we have explained in the thesis. We have examined the condition of the defendant’s disclaim where we have seen the specific meaning of disclaim, its importance and the terms of its validity. We have explained the effects of Possession differentiating between the Greek law and the Arabian laws. Moving on, we have examined the position of the Kuwait lawmaker in illegality of the system of short Acquisitive Prescription. Also, we have examined the position of the Greek lawmaker around the True Reason. In addition, we have clarified the rule of the Goodwill Possession for the movables. Finally, we have explained the effects of Prescription differentiating between the Extinctive Prescription and the Acquisitive Prescription, the Islamic system, the German and the Anglo-Saxon systems. In the conclusion and the recommendations we infer that there are differences between the provisions of the system of Islamic doctrine and the other systems of prescription (Extinctive andAcquisitive), not with standing of similarities them in some provisions.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2005
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Jadalhaq, Iyad
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/20681