Back to search

University of Ioannina

Η γνώση στην τραγωδία και ειδικότερα στο έργο του Σοφοκλή

Abstract

dc:description

The purpose of this research is to examine and shed light upon a particular dimension of the role which knowledge plays in Tragedy. A dimension which has not been enough and systematically brought out, and which is of great dramatic and essential weight. Our first point, which has been confirmed by the detailed study of the dramatic texts, is the firm belief that between the notions of knowledge and constraint exists an indissoluble, close, multiform and determinative relation. This very relation is what we attempt to enlighten by approaching it from different aspects. It is also necessary to make clear that in our work we do not use the term knowledge as a philosophical or as an epistemological term, but in the broadest sense of the word in order to denote the revelation, the realization or the acquisition of certain gnostic elements and information on behalf of the heroes. On the other hand by the term constraint we refer to the external and internal pressure which is exerted on the heroes and forces them to reveal things they know or to demand to know - at any cost - what they realize that they ignore. The focal point of our interest is the work of Sophocles. However we also enlarge upon the tragedies of the two other poets - Aeschylus’ and Euripides’ - so that we can reach more spherical conclusions as far as the function of the relation between knowledge and constraint is concerned in the whole dramatic work. Besides this approach allows us to see the tragedies of Sophocles in another light and thus to come to more specific findings with reference to his own dramatic texts. Before we proceed to the analytical examination of our subject, in the introductory chapter of our study, we consider it necessary to go ahead with an also analytical presentation of the so far results of the philological research into the role of knowledge in Tragedy. This presentation we regard it as an integral and important part of our work not only because it demonstrates that the aspect of the theme which we examine has not been systematically approached before - a fact that makes interesting our attempt - but mainly because it allows us to obtain a general and wide image of the meaning and the importance which the element of knowledge and its role has in Tragedy. A role that we should not consider it fragmental and partial but on the contrary total and comprehensive. The multiform character of it is what the presentation of the relevant bibliography brings out. Namely we find out that the role of knowledge in Tragedy has been studied in connection with the language and the vocabulary of the poets, with the notion of happiness and misery, with the possible philosophical influence exercised on the dramatists, with the metaphorical function of the light, the darkness, the sight and the blindness, and with the notion of madness. In addition it has been examined the element of self-knowledge, the contrast between the human and the divine knowledge, the relativity of the former, and the ways to gain it, the ignorance and the limited apprehension of the heroes, and the motif of late knowledge. Special emphasis has also been laid on the idea of learning by suffering. Having in mind the framework in which the philological research has already moved and the conclusions that has reached, in the first chapter of our study we examine all those cases in which the revelation and the acquisition of knowledge seems to be the result of an external force. Our aim is to discover and highlight the factors which work as a vehicle for this employment of coercion, while at the same time in the light of this approach we try to interpret the heroes’ behavior and their reactions. These cases we group them in virtue of the factor which seems to play the most determinative role. Nevertheless it is true that such a grouping cannot be absolutely strict since the interaction of the elements which exercise pressure on the heroes is obvious. However we arrive at the conclusion that the element which practically influences the heroes’ attitude is especially the pressure, the insistence and the arguments of their interlocutors, the difficult position in which they stand, the supplication and the plea for mercy, the treat, the fear of punishment, and the use of force. In the second chapter we examine the cases in which the revelation and the acquisition of knowledge is the result of an internal pressure which has to do with the feeling of a personal command, and refers to the notion of an internal constraint. We find out that the factors which mostly exercise pressure on the heroes have to do with the influence which has on the hero his personal contact with the man from whom he hides the truth, with the hero’s nature itself, and with the obligations arising from it, with the demand regarding the restoration of the truth, with the fear of the consequences of a concealment, and with that resulting from the ignorance and from the administrative inability of a person, and also with one’s attachment to somebody else. A determinative factor proves to be also the feeling of a moral obligation and of a practical duty, the need to carry out a certain plan, the pursuit of the profit, and the emotional load of the hero. But they exist also some other factors like the heroes’ need to survive , to support the common benefits, and to know as better as possible everything that concerns them and the persons of their environment. Furthermore we observe that quite often the curiosity of the heroes takes the form of an irresistible and strong desire the satisfaction of which causes a high sentimental delight. We examine these cases as well as the case in which the realization of the natural laws can influence the hero’s reactions as far as our subject is concerned. Of equal interest is also the topic with which we occupy ourselves in the third chapter. In its first part we try to shed light upon the cases in which the revelation and the acquisition of knowledge is the result of the coexistence and the combination of certain external and internal pressures. Here we examine the case of Oedipus Tyrannus which we consider not only as the most characteristic but also as especial. Its peculiarity lies in the fact that the hero not only feels compelled to reveal those he knows and those he himself ignores, but also he constrains the others to talk. Besides his case is special also because in his person we recognize the simultaneous exertion of many different pressures of external and internal character. In the second part of the same chapter our aim is to examine the cases in which the gain of knowledge is achieved through an imperative spectacle. On the other hand, in the fourth chapter, we study a different aspect of the relation between knowledge and constraint. Specifically we examine the cases in which the gain of knowledge is not the result of the heroes’ demand, who now seem to be passive receivers. This time knowledge is imposed on them because of the initiative of another person who decides unilaterally to make them participants of it. We start with the cases where the revelation of this type appears as the result of a human initiative and we proceed with those which bear upon the divine decision. Both times we lay stress on the factors which seem to make these revelations necessary and inevitable, and on the heroes’ reactions to the revealed knowledge which they are made to face. In the deductive chapter of our work we present the specific and the general conclusions of our research regarding each group of cases. In addition we bring out our observations with reference to the similarities and the differences which we locate in the work of the three dramatists, and to the way in which the three poets reflect in their tragedies the relation between knowledge and constraint, its forms, its dimensions and its consequences. A relation which seems to prove important not only as an element of dramatic power and as a vehicle for the emergence of various speculations and ideas, but also as a medium through which we can penetrate into the heroes’ psychology, interpret certain dramatic passages and scenes in a different light, and understand the whole tragedy from another viewpoint.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Ioannina
Year dc:date
2007

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Tsalta, Sevasti
  • Τσάλτα, Σεβαστή

Subjects

dc:subject × 12

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/21910

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Tsalta, Sevasti; Τσάλτα, Σεβαστή. Η γνώση στην τραγωδία και ειδικότερα στο έργο του Σοφοκλή. University of Ioannina, 2007. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/21910