Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Μεταμοσχεύσεις ιστών και οργάνων: ηθικά, νομικά και δεοντολογικά προβλήματα

Abstract

dc:description

The purpose of this study was to examine and evaluate the most important legal and ethical problems concerning organ transplantation in Greece. The study was conducted during the period 12/98 - 3/99. The data were obtained from:a. An anonymous questionnaire that was answered by 106 doctors of 16 ICU's of hospitals in Attica (Athens included), Greece.b. An anonymous questionnaire that was answered by 501 relatives and visitors of patients in various hospitals in the greater Athens area.According to the results, although the majority of doctors consider the ethical (97.2%) and legal problems (95.3%) which may arise in the daily practice of Medicine significant, 51.9% consider themselves equipped to handle the ethical and deontological problems and only 12.3% the legal problems, which may arise. There is a relative ignorance of the deontological code (41.5%) while 50% of those questioned were unfamiliar with the legislation concerning organ transplants. Also the majority of physicians maintain that transplant issues were not stressed enough during their training, especially their legal and social aspects. Another important finding was that although only 70.8% of the doctors knew the definition of brain death, 95.3% stated that they accept it. It is also considered contradictory that although 84% declared in favor of transplants only 65.1% were willing to donate organs, a percentage which drops to 47.2% when it concerns organs of members of their inner circle of family and friends. 78.3% replied that other medical considerations besides tissue compatibility should be examined before deciding on the selection of the donor and 48% of them believing that this consideration should be medical.In reply to the question whether older people should be excluded from transplants, 76.6% answered negatively. 41.5% agree with the idea that there should be a law compelling hospitals to ask relatives of patients who are brain dead and whose organs are suitable, about becoming organ donors. 50.9% of ICU doctors who answered the questionnaire stated that they had participated in at least one organ transplant.In answer to whether they would proceed to remove organs from a card holding donor without consent from the donors’ relatives 62% replied“No".40.6% stated that they were unaware of the existence of laws concerning the transplant of fetal tissue.56% maintain that no moral dilemma arises when there is no relation between living donor and recipient of kidneys.The majority of doctors asked (89.6%) stated that there should not be (monetary) compensation for donors.In reply to whether or not it is policy in their particular division, to inform the relatives of the possibility of organ donation by brain dead patients, 62.3% replied negatively, a percentage that is considered extremely low.The following findings are considered contradictory:i) 36.8% of ICU doctors state ignorance of which matters are stressed during the information of organ recipients.ii) 43.4% state that recipients are informed on the side effects of medication, on the postoperative problems and on the restriction on their life styles.Table 23, shows that only 16% of those asked, both donor and recipient, answered that they received psychological support before and after the operation at the hospital or transplant center.The findings in table 24, are considered significant as they show that 68% of the doctors who took part in the study, state that they are not satisfied with the way human donor organs are handled in Greece.51% of doctors asked consider the following weaknesses of the system: the approaching of, informing and psychological support of the relatives of deceased donors, the lack of coordination between the medical teams taking part in transplant procedures, completeness of the forms to be filled out and the speed with which the tests for compatibility are carried out. 50% of ICI) doctors asked, stated that their units comply with the obligation to maintain the anonymity of both recipient and donor of transplant organs.The statistics in general show that 75.7% of the medical staff is willing to inform the relatives of a brain dead patient about the use of organs for transplants.Of the remaining (21.7%) who were unwilling to do so, 56.5% stated that this was due to lack of education in this particular field.54.8% of doctors asked believe that there should be no form of financial or ethical motivation to participate in transplantation.Tables 29a, 29b, 29c and 29d show the general statistical distribution of replies:a. relative to stress symptoms (lack of concentration, increased heart rate, increased rerspiration, insomnia etc),b. symptoms of depression (distress, sadness, pessimism),c. the fear of attack from donors relatives,d. the fear that they may be accused, by the relatives of prospective brain dead donors during the information of illegal transactions related to donor organs.The general corresponding percentages show that 54.7%, 48%, 64%, and 58.5% accordingly, have no such feelings.The majority of doctors (67.9%) believe that the information of the relatives of a brain dead patient about the possibility of donating organs should be handled by a team of specialists (doctors, psychologists etc.).Concerning the public's view, almost all (92%), support the institution of organ transplants. The majority (81.6%) answered that they had been informed by the media. 76.6% stated that they do not believe that extended discussions on the matter play a negative role. In answer to the question on who may become an organ or tissue donor, whether living or not, 30.3% answered that only those in a healthy condition and 38.7% answered all. In investigating of the publics’ knowledge on the necessity of the existence of donor cards in order to become a donor after death, the replies were:53.3% of the public believes that card holding donors should be free to change their decision. In investigating the public's knowledge as to under 50% of ICI) doctors asked, stated that their units comply with the obligation to maintain the anonymity of both recipient and donor of transplant organs.The statistics in general show that 75.7% of the medical staff is willing to inform the relatives of a brain dead patient about the use of organs for transplants.Of the remaining (21.7%) who were unwilling to do so, 56.5% stated that this was due to lack of education in this particular field.54.8% of doctors asked believe that there should be no form of financial or ethical motivation to participate in transplantation.Tables 29a, 29b, 29c and 29d show the general statistical distribution of replies:a. relative to stress symptoms (lack of concentration, increased heart rate, increased rerspiration, insomnia etc),b. symptoms of depression (distress, sadness, pessimism),c. the fear of attack from donors relatives,d. the fear that they may be accused, by the relatives of prospective brain dead donors during the information of illegal transactions related to donor organs.The general corresponding percentages show that 54.7%, 48%, 64%, and 58.5% accordingly, have no such feelings.The majority of doctors (67.9%) believe that the information of the relatives of a brain dead patient about the possibility of donating organs should be handled by a team of specialists (doctors, psychologists etc.).Concerning the public's view, almost all (92%), support the institution of organ transplants. The majority (81.6%) answered that they had been informed by the media. 76.6% stated that they do not believe that extended discussions on the matter play a negative role. In answer to the question on who may become an organ or tissue donor, whether living or not, 30.3% answered that only those in a healthy condition and 38.7% answered all. In investigating of the publics’ knowledge on the necessity of the existence of donor cards in order to become a donor after death, the replies were:53.3% of the public believes that card holding donors should be free to change their decision. In investigating the public's knowledge as to under50% of ICI) doctors asked, stated that their units comply with the obligation to maintain the anonymity of both recipient and donor of transplant organs.The statistics in general show that 75.7% of the medical staff is willing to inform the relatives of a brain dead patient about the use of organs for transplants.Of the remaining (21.7%) who were unwilling to do so, 56.5% stated that this was due to lack of education in this particular field.54.8% of doctors asked believe that there should be no form of financial or ethical motivation to participate in transplantation.Tables 29a, 29b, 29c and 29d show the general statistical distribution of replies:a. relative to stress symptoms (lack of concentration, increased heart rate, increased rerspiration, insomnia etc),b. symptoms of depression (distress, sadness, pessimism),c. the fear of attack from donors relatives,d. the fear that they may be accused, by the relatives of prospective brain dead donors during the information of illegal transactions related to donor organs.The general corresponding percentages show that 54.7%, 48%, 64%, and 58.5% accordingly, have no such feelings.The majority of doctors (67.9%) believe that the information of the relatives of a brain dead patient about the possibility of donating organs should be handled by a team of specialists (doctors, psychologists etc.).Concerning the public's view, almost all (92%), support the institution of organ transplants. The majority (81.6%) answered that they had been informed by the media. 76.6% stated that they do not believe that extended discussions on the matter play a negative role. In answer to the question on who may become an organ or tissue donor, whether living or not, 30.3% answered that only those in a healthy condition and 38.7% answered all. In investigating of the publics’ knowledge on the necessity of the existence of donor cards in order to become a donor after death, the replies were:53.3% of the public believes that card holding donors should be free to change their decision. In investigating the public's knowledge as to under

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2001

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Xristofeli, Anastasia
  • Χριστοφέλη, Αναστασία

Subjects

dc:subject × 19

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/22683

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Xristofeli, Anastasia; Χριστοφέλη, Αναστασία. Μεταμοσχεύσεις ιστών και οργάνων: ηθικά, νομικά και δεοντολογικά προβλήματα. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2001. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/22683