Back to search

University of the Aegean

Factors increasing the productivity of information and communication technologies investments of the Greek firms: The effect of external environment, strategy and strategic alignment, soft ict investment and new forms of workplace organization

Abstract

dc:description

One of the most important research topics in the area of information systems (IS) has been for many years the business value they generate. Initially, from the mid 1980s until the mid 1990s (Roach 1987, Strassman 1990, Brynjolfsson 1993, Strassman 1997), very little empirical evidence had been found of a positive statistically significant association between information and communication technology (ICT) investment and business performance, giving rise to the extensive debate on the ‘ICT Productivity Paradox’ (Brynjolfsson 1993). However, from the mid 1990s until today, there has been considerable empirical evidence of a positive statistically significant contribution of ICT investment to several measures of business performance (Brynjolfsson and Hitt 1996, Stolarick 1999, OECD 2003, OECD 2004, Loukis and Sapounas 2005), even though there are still studies with mixed or inconclusive results (e.g. Stir oh 1998, Carr 2003). After 2000 the main emphasis of the research in this area has been put on the identification of factors and conditions that can increase the business value generated by ICT. This research shows that the business value generated by the ICT ‘hard’ investment of organizations (i.e. in computer hardware, software, etc.) can significantly increase, if it is combined with appropriate ‘soft investment’ in new work practices, redesign of business processes, new human skills, innovations, etc. (e.g. Brynjolfsson et al 2002, Ramirez 2003, Loukis and Sapounas 2005, Arvanitis 2005, Hempell 2005). This dissertation presents the results of the first empirical investigation of i) the impact of information and communication technologies (ICT) investment of firms on their business performance in Greece, and ii) the effect of a number of internal factors (associated with the interior of a firm) and external factors (associated with the external environment of a firm), which had not been previously empirically investigated, on this impact of ICT investment on business performance. Our study consists of four parts. In the first part we investigate the effect of both ‘hard’ ICT investment (in ICT hardware, software and networks) and ‘soft’ ICT investment (in ICT structures, human resources and skills) on firm output. It is based on data from big Greek industrial firms, which have been collected via a questionnaire-based survey conducted in cooperation with the Federation of 8 Greek Industries (FGI). Using these data, econometric models of output have been constructed based on the microeconomic production theory. Our analysis shows that the Cobb-Dougl as production function can adequately describe the relation between output and inputs in the Greek context, in comparison to the more general transcendental production function. Using the Cobb-Douglas production function, it has been found that ‘hard’ ICT investment in Greece makes a positive and statistically significant contribution to firm output; however its output elasticity is lower than the one of the non-computer capital and much lower than that of the labour. Also, from the measures of the ‘soft’ ICT investment we examined, it has been found that the existence of a separate ICT department has a positive and statistically significant effect on firm output, which is of considerable magnitude of about two thirds of the effect of the hard ICT investment. This finding underlines the importance of this dimension of the soft ICT investment, as it can increase by two thirds on average the business value generated by the hard ICT investment. Finally, the possibility of an effect of firm size on the structural stability of the econometric models we employed was also investigated; it was found that for firms with total sales above about € 20 million the structure of the models is reasonably stable, and therefore the conclusions drawn from them are valid at least for the whole range of firm sizes that our data cover. In the second part of our study we investigate the effect of two factors associated with the external environment of a firm: i) the ‘generalized’ competition it faces, which, according to M. Porter’s ‘Five Forces Model’ of competition includes the bargaining power of its suppliers, the bargaining power of its buyers, the competitive rivalry from its competitors, the threat of new entrants and the threat of substitute products or services, and ii) the strategy the organization follows for responding to pressures of its external environment, on the business value generated by ICT investment. The study is based on firm-level data from Greek companies, which have been collected through a questionnaire-based survey in cooperation with ICAP, one of the largest business information and consulting companies of Greece. Using these data are constructed econometric models of output based on the Cobb-Douglas production function. From these models, it is concluded that higher level of bargaining power of suppliers causes a significant increase (41%) of the business value generated by ICT. Also, concerning strategy, it is concluded that following a strategy of frequent introduction of new innovative products and services causes a significant increase (31%) of the business value generated by ICT. These findings mean that there are environment conditions and strategies resulting in higher ICT business value. In the third part of our study, we examined the impact of four ICT strategic alignment mechanisms, which are associated with different hierarchical levels, and also both strategy formulation and implementation, on the business value generated by ICT. The study is based on the above mentioned firm-level data from Greek companies. From the econometric models we estimated, based on the Cobb-Douglas production function, it is concluded that the ICT strategic alignment causes a statistically significant and large increase (of a level of 47%) of the business value generated by ICT. Furthermore, all the four ICT strategic alignment mechanisms we examined cause statistically significant increase of the business value generated by ICT. The bilateral relationship between the ICT Plan and the business/strategy plan and involvement of the organisational units of the firm (e.g. directorates, departments) in the IS and applications development projects are the mechanisms with the most increasing impact on the ICT business value (42% and 44% respectively). Finally in the fourth part of our study, we conducted a comparative empirical study of the effect of ICT capital, human capital, organizational capital (adoption of new organizational practices) and knowledge capital, on labour productivity in Greece and Switzerland. It has been based on firm level data from both countries collected through a common questionnaire, from samples of similar composition, from which econometric models of similar specification have been estimated for both countries. We found statistically significant positive effects for ICT capital, human capital and “employee voice” oriented organizational practices on labour productivity for both countries; on the contrary no effect (in the Greek case) or even a negative effect (in the Swiss case) has been found for “work design” oriented organizational changes. There are also considerable differences between the two countries. First, it has been concluded that Swiss firms are more efficient and mature in forming and using knowledge capital, than the Greek ones. Second, the effect of “employee voice” on labour productivity, which is significantly positive for both countries, is based on different types of practices. In Greece, positive and statistically significant effect on business performance has the decentralization of competences referring to the working conditions (work pace, work way, work sequence), while in Switzerland the decentralization of competences having to do with the work content (contact to customers, solving of problems related to customers). The results of this comparative study provide evidence that the national context influences the effect of these ‘new’ production factors on labor productivity.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of the Aegean
Year dc:date
2009

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Sapounas, Ioakim
  • Σαπουνάς, Ιωακείμ

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/25065

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Sapounas, Ioakim; Σαπουνάς, Ιωακείμ. Factors increasing the productivity of information and communication technologies investments of the Greek firms: The effect of external environment, strategy and strategic alignment, soft ict investment and new forms of workplace organization. University of the Aegean, 2009. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/25065