Abstract
dc:descriptionDuring the last decades the science of ecology is the centre of discourse, both as a study of the physical environment as well as a research on the relation between nature and the human. Respectively, the promotion of ecology to a social demand and the familiarization with environmental issues turn envi-ronmental study into an indispensible component in the teaching of sciences. However, despite the introduction of ecological issues in the educational pro-grammes of all grades, the results of several, although fragmented, studies regarding the understanding of fundamental ecological concepts, but also the misconceptions and alternative views on broader environmental questions, are quite contradictive. Based on the concerns caused by the above results and understanding the inherent complexity of environmental issues, this study focuses on the picto-rial content of the school textbooks for Environmental Studies, as a lesson that basically introduces pupils to the relation between scientific and social issues. These textbooks are the only official teaching books that contain material for the environmental education of primary school pupils; in these textbooks we find the majority of environmental references, since the Greek Educational system does not include specific lessons on ecology and environmental educa-tion. We examined the series of previous textbooks, taught from 1982 to 2006, and the series of new textbooks which replaced them in 2006, 2007, which are currently taught in Greek primary schools. Focusing on the study of accompanying concepts in the textbooks of the Greek primary school, in the first part of our research we attempted to exam-ine their pictorial content (representations). Our approach is based on the fact that pictures can significantly assist pupils to have access to knowledge. This is especially true for the primary school textbooks, which show a strong tendency towards visual communication of their scientific data. Taking into consideration that pictures are not a direct, but rather a distorted mirror of reality, that they are formulated representations of the world de-pending on the interests of the social structures that these pictures are born out of and also communicated into, our intention is to research which view of nature and also which view of the human- nature relationship is presented in the Greek textbooks of natural sciences. In this sense, it is generally acceptable that the cognitive data given by natu-ral sciences certainly contain social influences and therefore that school text-books promote specific ideological loadings (Potter and Rosser, 1992). Adopt-ing this approach, Östman (1998) suggests the idea of “cognitive” and “ac-companying” concepts, where the latter refer to the social and/or ideological content of the teaching of natural sciences. The pictorial analysis shows that the dominant view presented is the “ba-roque” view on nature and on human-nature relationship; according to this world view nature is in constant movement, therefore accidental and unfore-seen natural changes are the rule. Natural environments are described in ma-terial terms, as they are constantly changing form under the influence of hu-man beings and they are being utilized as resources. In the second part of our research we studied the optical syntax of the mate-rial included in the school textbooks, starting from the point of view that vis-ualization is important for pupils to have access to their object of study (Spil-iotopoulou – Papantoniou, 2009) because it presents real models of the outer world which contain both scientific and ideological loadings(Gilbert 2005). This means that visual material is not merely a representation of reality. On the contrary, although it draws inspiration from reality, it constitutes inde-pendent, specific and unrelated representations of a formulated interpretation of the reality (Kress & van Leeuwen, 1996). Therefore, the interpretation of the visual material is a kind of post-visualization and post-knowledge proc-ess, for example, the ability for someone to think about their way of thinking (Gilbert 2005), which eventually familiarizes pupils with the skill of thinking in pictures (Tversky 2005). Furthermore, according to Mathewson (2005), children are able to begin to explore visual material in order to develop observation capabilities already from their first school years. When we compare the ideology presented by the previous series of textbooks that were introduced in the ‘80’s with the one presented in the current series of textbooks, using two different exmination methods, our analysis shows that both series of textbooks present worldviews that differ from each other. The most recent textbooks are influenced by the so-called “baroque” views on nature, while the previous textbooks promote the so-called “romantic” and “classic” worldviews. Approaching from the point of view of critical realism, our findings show that the “romantic and classical” views of nature in the previous series of text-books express a vitality, optimism and innocence which feature in industrial societies (or societies that move towards industrialism), where interventions in the environment are concerned. This coincides with the general enthusi-asm that was enjoyed by the Greek society during the ‘80’s. On the other hand the “baroque” approach, that appears in the new series of tetxbooks, shows the scepticism of post-industrial societies where natural phenomena are concerned. This coincides with the scepticism and uncertainty that char-acterizes all modern societies – such as the Greek society – on their way to-wards globalization.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Ioannina
- Year dc:date
- 2011
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Λεμονή, Πανωραία
- Lemoni, Rea
Subjects
dc:subject × 22- Συνοδευτικές έννοιες, ρομαντικά κοσμοείδωλα
- Ανάλυση περιεχομένου
- Εικονική ανάλυση
- Ανάλυση σύνταξης εικονικού περιεχομένου
- Ελληνικά σχολικά βιβλία
- Εικονικές αναπαραστάσεις του φυσικού περιβάλλοντος
- Μπαρόκ κοσμοείδωλα
- Companion meaning
- Content analysis
- Pictorial analysis
- School textbooks
- Views of nature
- Baroque worldview
- Romantic worldview
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Γεωεπιστήμες και Επιστήμες Περιβάλλοντος
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση
- Natural Sciences
- Earth and Related Environmental Sciences
- Social Sciences
- Education
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/26256