Technical University of Crete (TUC)
Παράγοντες αποδοχής των πληροφοριακών συστημάτων από το ιατρικό προσωπικό: προοπτικές για την εφαρμογή της επί ενδείξεων βασιζόμενης ιατρικής (evidence based medicine)
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe diffusion of information and communication technology (ICT) has never been bigger than in this era, as far as the individual and the organization and enterprises use are concerned. It is a common sense that ICT benefits the operations of the organizations which accept it in many ways (i.e. access to information sources, directness of communication, better organization, decreasing costs, increasing production, control etc). However, comparing to other professional groups there is an important delay in the acceptance and use of ICT among the medical community. Although ICT contributes in medical practice by introducing new technology, which did not exist some years ago and it is now embedded in biomedical devices (i.e. in radiology) leading to a change it the medical practice itself, ICT has not been widely used by the medical staff. This is a global, common observation not dependant on the health system of the different countries, on the doctors training, on the technological progress of the different nations, or even on the information system in use. Questions posed and need to be explored are “what influences doctors attitude”, “does all the medical staff share the same perception towards ICT or not, and if yes, is it possible that medical staff be categorized in subgroups having common attributes in terms of attitude”, “is it possible to predict subgroup behaviour towards ICT”, “is it possible to use subgroup attributes in order to make interventions and guide groups” etc. Answers to such questions not only do help to understand the problem and the parameters that underlay in the creation of the resistance of the acceptance and use of ICT, but may also be used so that policies for interventions and change are developed. This dissertation explores the factors which influence medical doctors and nursing staff’s attitude towards the adoption and use of ICT and Clinical Information Systems (CIS). In order to avoid effects and cross-relations with technical characteristics that differentiate one CIS from another, the survey is not focused either on a concrete CIS or on specific technical characteristics. Instead, the research is focused on the attitude of the medical and nursing staff in terms of the organizational and operational characteristics of CIS, specifically in the light of a relatively new perception of medical practice, which is permanently grown, Evidence Based Medicine (EBM). This is not accidental. As it is extensively explained in the text, there is evidence that the positive attitude of the medical and nursing staff towards EBM is related to the positive attitude towards the CIS and this is beneficial for both EBM and CIS. By embodying EBM in the architectural structure which describes the operational and organizational characteristics of CIS, an appropriate and robust theoretical context is composed. The purpose of this research is the investigation of the latent relations among the organizational structures of the CIS, including EBM, as they are expected to subsist based on the theoretical concept. The main survey, which is crossectional type, was accomplished via self-reporting questioners, participated 1015 doctors and nurses from 13 main state hospitals of Greece. Finally 604 individuals answered the questioners and this is one of the biggest samples tested in the health sector. The measurement instrument consists of 214 items (questions) which describe well based structures found in the literature. Specifically, the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), the Technology Readiness Index (TRI) and the Evidence Based Practice Attitude Scale (EBPAS) were used in the same concept. Originally, the TAM was used in order to explore the relations between its structures (Perceived Easy of Use, Perceived usefulness, Attitude towards computer use and Behavioral Intention). Thereafter, the basic TAM model was expanded, using two external variables, namely ICT knowledge and future demands, in order to investigate the effect of there variables in the TAM structures. Moreover, the medical spatiality was used as moderator in order to separate the sample into two groups (surgeons and pathologists) and test for possible different attitude of the two groups. For the purposes of the statistical analysis modern quantitative methods were used, such as Confirmatory Factor Analysis, Structural Equation Modeling and Multi-group Analysis of Structural Invariance. Generally, the results are in line with other results found in the literature while the effects of the external parameters are being estimated. In order to investigate the tendency of the medical and nursing personnel to accept technology, the Technology Readiness Index (TRI) was used. The assumption that the five dimensions of technology readiness hold for the specific population was examined first, according the dimensions of technology readiness of the general population (explorers, pioneers, skeptics, paranoids and laggards). In addition, the characteristics and differences of the latent groups of the sample were investigated, towards the demographic data, the computer use, and the computer knowledge and feature demands. Explanatory Factor Analysis aw well as Latent Profile Analysis were conducted to analyze data, using Mplus software. The results support the existence of the five discrete medical groups of Technology Readiness. However, different group characteristics were found, comparing to the characteristics of the general population, the skeptics group being the predominant among them. Additionally, differences were found among the groups according to the demographic data (gender, age, tenure, average computer use per week, etc). In order to investigate the attitude of the medical personnel towards the Evidence Based Medicine, the Evidence Based Practice Attitude Scale was used, which was originally created to measure innovation acceptance in relation of Evidence Based Practices in mental health. The Scale was chosen, because the Evidence Based Medicine signifies an innovative perception on medical practice. In addition, the theoretical background on which the Evidence Based Practice Attitude Scale has been developed is based on the theory of diffusion and implementation of innovation, which obviously applies in other populations, besides those it was initially formed. The scale consists of 15 items, organized in 4 dimensions (subscales or factors), namely Appeal, Requirements, Openness and Divergence. The entire scale of the 15 items is concerned as a separate, fifth dimension, it is estimated independently, and represents the general attitude of an individual. By applying the Evidence Based Practice Attitude Scale in the sample, the structure of its factors, its reliability and validity were tested, providing empirical evidence the extension of the scale in the health sector. For the tests, Confirmatory Factorial Analysis with maximum likelihood algorithms was used, while for the best fit of the model a variety of indexes were used, such as, the RMSEA, the CFI, the AIC and the SRMR. In summary, it was found that both the medical and the nursing personnel have a low attitude towards the Evidence Based Medicine comparing to the mental health service providers. Having investigated the acceptance factors of the ICT, the technology readiness as well as the attitude of the personnel towards the Evidence Based Medicine, the next issue was to find the appropriate theoretical background to relate the attitude towards the Evidence Based Medicine with the attitude towards Information and Communication Technology. Intuitively, it would be expected a population with strong attitude towards the Evidence Based Medicine to develop the tendency to use the Evidence Based Medicine more frequently comparing to a population who does not have such a strong attitude towards the Evidence Based Medicine, thus to develop a positive attitude towards the Information and Communication Technology. Thus, the issue concludes to the investigation of the attitude and the consequent behavior of a population. In the literature, various research support generally that there is a poor relation between attitude and behavior. In other words, there is a limited power of the possibility to foresee people’s behavior based on their believes. However, Campbell (1963) argued that an individual’s declarations and actions reflect the same acquired disposition of behavior. Duncan, extended Campbell’s theory, claiming that the key to correlate the attitude and behavior is not how strong the relation is, but if a specific structural relationship among them. In other words, according to Duncan, the contradiction of attitude and behavior is due to the probabilistic correlation of the reactions or actions (which are not directly observable, i.e. latent) and the disposition on which they depend on. In their research, they used unfolding models (or Ideal Point Models) to show that the self-reporting attitude and self- reporting behavior belong to the same latent continuum, so they express the same concept, while behavior statements are located systematically in different positions in the behavior-attitude continuum. The unidimensional Graded Unfolding Model GUM7 was used in the final part of this research, as it is applied in the GGUM2004 software, to empirically demonstrate that the attitude towards the Evidence Based Medicine and the behavior towards the Information and Communication Technology share the same common cause, which is the behavior intention towards the Evidence Based Medicine, and that by placing the statements assessing attitude towards Evidence Based Medicine and Information and Communication Technology self-reported use on a single attitude-behavior continuum, attitude statements systematically prelude the behavior statements on the single attitude-behavior continuum. As unfolding models provide a probabilistic connection between the general attitude and its indicators, the reserved possibilities and the behavior for a population may be simultaneously foreseen. Based on the engagement possibilities and Rogers (1995) theory of innovation, a model is proposed for the diffusion of Information and Communication Technology in the health sector. In conclusion, the establishment of the relation of the Evidence Based Medicine to the Communication and Information Technology is confirmed. Evidence Based Medicine may well be the vehicle via which the adoption and use of Clinical Information Systems among health care providers may be achieved, thus creating new prospects and horizons for both Evidence Based Medicine and Clinical Information Systems.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Technical University of Crete (TUC)
- Year dc:date
- 2011
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Melas, Christos
- Μελάς, Χρήστος
Subjects
dc:subject × 24- Τεχνολογία πληροφορικής και επικοινωνιών
- Μοντέλο αποδοχής τεχνολογίας
- Πληροφοριακά συστήματα υγειονομικής περίθαλψης
- Τεχνολογική ετοιμότητα
- Ιατρική επί ενδείξεων
- Αναδιπλούμενα μοντέλα
- Μοντελοποίηση δομικών εξισώσεων
- Ανάλυση λανθάνοντος προφίλ
- Χρήση υπολογιστών
- Ελληνικά νοσοκομεία
- Information and communication technology
- Technology acceptance models
- Health care information systems
- Technology readiness
- Evidence based medicine
- Unfolding models
- Structural equation modeling
- Latent profile analysis
- Computer use
- Greek hospitals
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Health Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/26284