Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Ρητορική και πρόκληση: τα συναισθήματα, οι αξίες και οι στάσεις των καταναλωτών έναντι ρητορικών προκλητικών διαφημίσεων
Abstract
dc:descriptionConsumers get bombarded with myriads of advertising messages on a daily basis. In order to overcome this clutter phenomenon and attract attention and interest, practitioners gradually intensify their efforts by employing controversial topics as well as rhetorical maneuvers in advertising. Albeit such techniques are frequently applied in marketing communications, there are still a lot of issues that remain largely unknown. The goal of the present research is fourfold: a) to examine the dynamics of a visual-verbal rhetorical figure called resonance when employed in non-controversial advertising settings as well as verify its limits in terms of effectiveness, b) to further establish the provocation appeal ad genre by exploring its variety dependent upon the controversial topic in which it may be grounded, c) to shed light on the impact of rhetoric when utilized in provocative ad contexts and d) to explore viewers’ affective (i.e., emotions) and cognitive responses (i.e., personal values) as well as those responses’ influence on attitudinal outcomes (i.e., ad and brand attitude, purchase intention) within rhetorically and non-rhetorically structured provocative ad frames. Four research studies were conducted in order to fulfill the foregoing research goals. The first experimental study examined visual-verbal instances of resonance. According to findings, resonance in advertising results in favorable outcomes in terms of ad liking, elaboration and comprehension. Moreover, different instances of resonance (i.e., whether either one or both visual and verbal elements that comprise resonance are rhetorical figures by themselves) may result in even more favorable outcomes. The second study examined resonance’s limits of effectiveness from an incongruity standpoint. More specifically, based on the schema-incongruity theory, this study explored resonance’s performance depending on the demonstrated incongruity between its pictorial and verbal components. As per findings, moderately-incongruent resonance generates the most favorable results with concern to ad liking and lack of annoyance. In contrast, both low and highly-incongruent resonant ad stimuli produce negative outcomes. In fact, highly-incongruent resonance induces the strongest objection in terms of ad likability, annoyance and lack of comprehension. The third experimental study which comprised of two sub-studies examined the effects of rhetoric (i.e., resonance) in provocation appeal advertising settings grounded in a variety of taboo topics. More specifically, the first sub-study focused on violence as a taboo issue whereas the second sub-study concentrated on strong eroticism. According to findings, consumers generally oppose to the use of provocation in advertising. However, such an opposition largely depends on the taboo topic upon which the provocative ad stimulus may ground. More specifically, the audience appears to emotionally and attitudinally object to the employment of violent themes in advertising. In contrast, viewers do not reject the use of erotic themes in ads, at least through an emotional lens. In addition, the application of rhetoric seems to play a reinforcing role as far as both viewers’ emotional and attitudinal reactions. Nevertheless, results again depend on the taboo topic upon which controversy is based. More specifically, the heavier is the use of rhetoric in violent advertising the more unfavorable are the outcomes in terms of consumers’ feelings and predispositions. On the other hand, the heavier is the embodiment of rhetoric in an erotic ad context, the more favorable are the emotional and attitudinal responses. Next, the fourth experimental study examined the use of resonance in provocative advertising in more depth. First, we examined provocation based on the employment of violent symbolism. Second, apart from emotions and attitudes the role of consumers’ personal values was also explored. Results showed that rhetoric did not inhibit objections toward provocative ads from an emotional and attitudinal standpoint. In fact, like previously (e.g., study three) it played a reinforcing role as far as subjects’ negative responses. Also, consumers’ value orientation had an impact on attitudes. However, its role was not as important as that of emotions. In general, personal values such as those pertaining to personal gratification and security affect consumers’ attitudes toward rhetorically and non-rhetorically structured stimuli. Last, personal values and emotions do not interact significantly as to determine consumers’ final attitudes. The present thesis closes by discussing its limitations associated with the concepts employed, the procedures followed and with the measures utilized among others. Finally, a series of future research suggestions are advanced such as the necessity of a cross-cultural replication, the exploration of additional rhetorical figures within a controversial ad context grounded on further taboo topics and the necessity of conducting such examination within advertising frames promoting a social idea (e.g., safe-driving) rather than commodities (e.g., consumer products).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
- Year dc:date
- 2011
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Θεοδωράκης, Ιωάννης
- Theodorakis, Ioannis
Subjects
dc:subject × 28- Διαφήμιση
- Ρητορική
- Ρητορικά σχήματα
- Θεωρία ασυμβατότητας
- Σέξ
- Βία
- Συναισθήματα
- Προσωπικές αξίες
- Στάσεις
- Μέτρα διαφημιστικής αποτελεσματικότητας
- Advertising
- Rhetoric
- Rhetorical figures
- Incongruity theory
- Sex
- Violence
- Emotions
- Personal values
- Attitudes
- Advertising effectiveness measurement
- Social Sciences
- Economics and Business
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/26582