Back to search

University of Ioannina

Μελέτη της περιγραφικής χημείας και των προβλημάτων οργανικής σύνθεσης σε σχέση με τρεις ψυχομετρικές παραμέτρους

Abstract

dc:description

According to studies, the Johnstone-EI-Banna problem solving theory seems to exist, however it has low power. The main cause is the difficulty to define the required steps in order to solve a problem. However, if we apply this to organic chemical synthesis problems, each reaction can be defined as a distinguish step for the solution of the problem. This was the idea for this research. At the design of the research another matter was added to the initial query; to investigate if the teaching of chemistry using hierarchical approach and explanations can lead to better understanding of the chemistry curriculum.The working-memory capacity X of the students was measured and assessed in order to investigate the power of the Johnstone-El-Banna problem solving model. The working-memory capacity X is a psychometric variable. To make the study more sophisticated two other psychometric variables of the students were measured, their mental level according to Piaget’s model, and the dependence on the field. As a result the study investigated the effect of those three psychometric variables on the solution of organic chemical synthesis problems, hierarchical approach of chemistry teaching and the explanations.The sample included students from public schools and private tutoring schools of rural areas. The students were asked to solve organic chemical synthesis problems. The problems were of gradual difficulty Z. The initial problem difficulty level was Z=2, which was increasing one difficulty level at a time up to difficulty Z=8.The difficulty level was calculated based on the number of reactions necessary to fabricate the second organic compound given only the first organic compound.The requirement of each problem was calculated according to the number of reactions required in order to fabricate the second organic compound using the first one alone.Each equation of reactions required to transform a chemical compound to another one is a step. The results of pupils’ working-memory capacity Χ were combined with the problem requirements that each pupil solved correctly and were statistically analyzed using four different ways. To study the hierarchical approach of teaching we rank each piece of aliphatic compounds. We modify the organic chemistry manual of the senior class of high school in a way where chemicals compound and chemical phenomena are presented without the need of previous knowledge.Pupils of the experimental group used the modified book whereas the control group used the original one. Both groups had the same teacher. The two teaching methods were compared based on the pupils’ grades on problems of οργανικής χημείας at the final exams as well as at the National exams with a modification due to the exam differences between each year.Comparisons between groups have been performed through t-tests, Mann-Whitney and UNANOVA of general linear model (GLM). The pupils’ grades in Physics and the total high school graduation grade were used as covariates.For the explanations a questionnaire was formed with examples of chemical reactions and physical properties. Each example included an explanation and pupils were asked to answer if the explanation was helpful or not using a three scale options.Questionnaires were completed by senior high school pupils of the urban area of Attica and the first year Chemistry students of the University of Ioannina.The results confirmed the Johnstone-EI-Banna problem solving theory under specific circumstances. Statistical analysis showed a significant decrease on pupils’ performance when the requirement Z of the problems exceed the pupils’ working-memory capacity Χ. This was clearly seen at the pupils of private tutoring schools and public schools without previous experience in contrast with the pupils of public schools with previous experience. This finding proves that similar problems make the pupils to use chunking which has as a result to reduce the demands of the problem. The lack of experience seems to be the more important requirement for the confirmation of the Johnstone-EI-Banna theory.Concerning the hierarchical approach of teaching the hierarchical series was found to be more helpful at the National Exams.Moreover, 55% of the pupils of the experimental group found better the modified curriculum and only 12% found it worse. The less mental development the pupils had the more in favor of this modification they were. However, this is in contrast to the performance at the National Exams. In addition 64% of the pupils declare that followed the hierarchical series in combination with the book.Concerning the explanations the majority of the pupils believed that it helps in their education. Their Concerning the psychometric parameters it seems that only the dependence or not from the field plays an important role at the pupils choice. The more the pupils are depended on the field the less they think that the explanations can help their learning.Concerning the “desmi” that the pupils choose, the pupils who are interested on medical schools were more in favor of the explanationsFinally, concerning sex differences girls clearly prefer explanations more than boys

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Ioannina
Year dc:date
2011

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Angelopoulos, Vasilios
  • Αγγελόπουλος, Βασίλειος

Subjects

dc:subject × 24

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/26974

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Angelopoulos, Vasilios; Αγγελόπουλος, Βασίλειος. Μελέτη της περιγραφικής χημείας και των προβλημάτων οργανικής σύνθεσης σε σχέση με τρεις ψυχομετρικές παραμέτρους. University of Ioannina, 2011. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/26974