University of Patras
Φυσικοχημική διερεύνηση της αποσάθρωσης δομικών υλικών ιστορικών μνημείων και μέθοδοι προστασίας
Abstract
dc:descriptionA significant number of historic monuments and artworks have been made of stone mainly of marble lime and silicate materials. The work in the present thesis is focused on the investigation of the kinetics of marble dissolution under various conditions. These studies contribute to the understanding of the mechanism of dissolution for of calcific and dolomitic marbles. Understanding the mechanism of the problem is essential for the selection and the implementation of methods for the protection of monuments. More specifically in the present work it was attempted to achieve the following tasks: a) Determination of dissolution mechanism through measurements of the kinetics of marble dissolution in solutions undersaturated with respect to the main component (calcite dolomite) under various undersaturation conditions at controlled conditions, b) Dissolution inhibition by addition of water soluble compounds and investigation of the mechanism of their interaction with the calcific surfaces, c) Formation of potentially protective coatings on marble surface consisting of sparingly soluble inorganic salts, d) Comparison of marble dissolution rates (in the presence and in the absence of different water soluble substances) with the respective values reported in the literature and with results from marble specimens exposed outdoors or under accelerated weathering conditions in a salt spray chamber (with or without other agents including colonization with microorganisms treatment with biocides). The aim of this comparison was the selection of the best model for the reliable testing of novel methods and materials for the protection of marble. Three marble types were selected in the present investigation. These types have been frequently used as building materials in monuments and sculptures in Europe: Carrara (>98% calcite), Pentelic (>98% calcite) and Ekeberg (>93% dolomite). A number of compounds were selected for the investigation of their effectiveness of protection against marble weathering due to wet precipitation VPA3-7 (surfactant) and HEDP (organophosphorus compounds). Hydrophase superfici® (hydrophobic substance) and Algophase ® (biocide). To study the effect of microorganisms on the weathering of marble specimens exposed outdoors they were inocculated with a bacteria culture consisting of (Geodermatophilus sp BC 508 isolated from limestone rock (Noto, Syracuse, Italy), Micromonospora sp, BC 562 isolated from Pentelic marble), fungi (Coniosporium apolliniis MC518 isolated from marble from Tarragona Cathedral (Spain) and Coniosporium uncinatum MC557 isolated from Carrara marble statue (Messina Italy).) The aim of the measurements of the rates of marble dissolution in solutions undersaturated with respect to calcite as a function of the relative undersaturation was the attainment of a better understanding for the mechanism underlying marble dissolution. Undersaturated working solutions were prepeared by dilution of proper stock solutions of CaC1₂, MgC1₂, NaHCO₃ NaC1 and pH was initially adjusted to 8.25 with 0.01N NaOH. After equilibration of undersaturated solutions in the reactor known amount of marble was introduced, either in powder form (suspension) or in rod form (fixed on special scaffold). Depending on the control of the parameters possible the following types of experiments were done and the dissolution rates were measured free drift (all variables change with the exception of temperature), constant pH (pH only is kept constant), constant undersaturation (the activities of all species in the undersaturated solutions are kept constant). The dissolution rates of calcitic marble (both in powders and slabs) and calcite powder showed linear dependence on the relative undersatutation. In all cases, the rates of dissolution were of the same order of magnitude with the rates corresponding to (synthetic) calcite powder. Thermal pretreatment of pentelic marble powder resulted to higher dissolution rates. In this case the dependence of the rates measured with respect to the relative undersatutation was found to be non-linear (R=Kdσn, n>1). In the case of Ekeberg marble the dependence of the rates of dissolution on the relative undersatutation was found to be non-linear as well with n = 2. It may therefore be concluded that the dissolution is surface diffusion controlled. In the present work, solubilities for different types of marbles investigated in aqueous solutions were calculated from measurements of specimens equilibrated with electrolyte solutions over a time period exceeding the 2 years. For Pentelic and Crystallina Thassou marbles, values of solubility products were close to the value of pure calcite, while those for the rest of the calcite marbles (Carrara, Spilia, Dionysoy) were higher. For the dolomite marbles Ekeberg and Thassos White, the values obtained were almost identical and close to the values reported for stoichiometric dolomite. In all cases the rate of dissolution was found to be controlled by surface diffusion. The adsorption of a substance on marble surface could possibly affect the dissolution process. The adsorption of substances possessing ionisable phosphate and phosphonate groups on marble powders (Pentelic, Carrara, Ekeberg) was investigated through the respective adsorption isotherms. HEDP was mainly studied in this section because its presence in undersaturated solutions inhibited dissolution to a large extent and also because it could be considered as a model substance for the investigation of the effect of substances with similar functional groups on crystalline solids with metal cations on their surface. The presence of HEDP in the undersaturated solutions resulted in the reduction of the marble dissolution rates proportionally to the extent of HEDP adsorption on the substrate. The dissolution rates obtained were lower than those obtained in experiments were HEDP was pre-adsorbed on the substrate (both in marble powder and in marble rod tests). HEDP showed strong inhibition effect (even by 80-90%) but also showed negative effect on the morphology marble crystallites. The aim of the next series of experiments was the formation of coatings on pentelic marble slabs. The coatings tested in the present investigation consisted of inorganic salts less soluble than calcite. Treatment solutions (HC1, EDTA, lactic acid, H₃P0₄, HEDP, NTMP, N(phosphomethyl-) imino diacetic acid) were applied by: a) brush, b) impregnated patch and c) immersion. The most effective way was impregnation. XRD, FT-IR and SEM were used for the characterization of the surfaces and of the composition of the coatings. The “new” composite (marble + coating) materials were then subjected to dissolution experiments in solutions undersaturated with respect to calcite. Treatment of marble with phosphoric acid resulted in formation of a thick layer of CaHP0₄·2H₂0, DCPD. Following a second treatment with sodium hydrogen phosphate solution the iniatially formed DCPD crystals were hydrolyzed to pseudomorfic OCP crystals, resulting to a layer of 100 um thickness with complete coverage of the surface and good adhesion on the substrate. Dissolution experiments showed that only the coating was dissolved. Outdoors exposure. The inhibiting effect of HEDP on dissolution was verified in the case of the exposed marble specimens. The surfactant substances tested seemed to protect the specimens more than the hydrophobic compounds which emphasizes the importance of substance-substrate interaction and is in good agreement with batch experiment results. Salt spray chamber. The inhibiting effect of HEDP on dissolution was again verified in the case of the marble specimen exposed under accelerated weathering conditions. Results of the measurements of the kinetics of marble dissolution obtained from outdoors exposure tests of marble slabs, were comparable to those obtained from batch reactor experiments. Measurement of dissolution kinetics in working solutions under constant undersaturation conditions is a method capable of providing satisfactory information on the behaviour of marble specimen under weathering conditions and a useful tool on testing and evaluating the efficiency of candidate protective methods and products in a short time (suitable as preliminary screening tool).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2012
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kanellopoulou, Dimitra
- Κανελλοπούλου, Δήμητρα
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Διάλυση μαρμάρου
- Ρυθμοί διάλυσης
- Αναστολή
- Διαλυτότητα
- Επικαλύψεις
- Πεντελικό μάρμαρο
- Ασβεστίτης
- Δολομίτες
- Marble dissolution
- Dissolution rates
- Inhibition
- Solubility
- Coatings
- Pentelic marble
- Calcite
- Dolomites
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Χημικού Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Chemical Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/27030