Back to search

University of the Aegean

Επιστήμες της αγωγής και δημιουργική επίλυση προβλήματος: στάσεις στελεχών δημόσιας διοίκησης σχετικά με τη διαχείριση κρίσεων: συγκριτική μελέτη

Abstract

dc:description

The hypothesis of the current thesis focuses on the role of creative and critical thinking within the process of crisis management from public sector executives. Interviews with public sector executives have been conducted in order to test this hypothesis. These executives have been sampled in a way that represents insular and mainland Greece. The interviews were semi structured, which means that they were based in a pre-decided questions frame. The questions were set orally to the research participants, allowing a more free and flexible approach. Also, the questions were structured aiming to investigate the way with which the public sector executives in Greece manage crises, and specially the crisis of a forestall fire. Furthermore, it was aimed to identify: the role and function of the relatively new institution which is called “civil protection office”, the role of the research university community in the battle for rescuing Greek forests, the role of the penetration of forest protection/fire extinction technologies within Greek reality, the structure of the volunteers institution, the evaluation of the equipment and of the ability of involved parties to use that equipment, the quality of communication among state services during the crisis, the degree of creative and critical thinking exploited by the public sector executives, the degree of alignment with the European standards regarding forest management, the role of environmental education for the sustainable managing of Greek forests. For supporting the above research frame, literature review was conducted, and a theoretical frame was conceived from which the semi-structure interview potential questions were resulted. The first chapter examines the phenomenon of creativity and critical thinking. This approach serves an innovative study approach for the multifaceted phenomenon of crisis management, since it inserts the creativity factor inside a field that is traditionally approached by different methodological tools. The analysis of these two concepts (creativity and critical thinking) attempts to clarify their impact on crisis management. More analytically, a definition of creativity and critical thinking is attempted within the first chapter, aiming to form the theoretical framing of the concepts that constitute the hypothesis. Through a historical overview of the concept of creativity, as seen from researchers, the evolution and maturation of the research field is presented, as well as the relevant controversies among researchers. As for critical thinking, the relevant criteria which are accepted by researchers are presented, attempting its placement among other cognitive activities. Furthermore, the correlation of critical thinking with pedagogical science is pursued, or, in other words, the identification of the way with which education is called to perform a significant role for the formulation of critical thinking of the trainees. Finally, the first chapter approaches the conceptual correlation and the comparative study among the critical thinking and creativity, locating overlapping characteristics, hallmark differentiations and convergences.The second chapter studies the phenomenon of leadership, emphasizing on the creative leader’s qualities and functions. Furthermore, we attempt the correlation of the content of the first chapter with the field of leadership. The concept “leadership” is defined and the current, valid definitions are presented. After the clarification of the terms “leader” and “leadership”, the second chapter focuses on a specific leadership model, this of the creative leader, analyzing systematically the research models that describe and define the phenomenon of creative leadership. The second chapter aims to the juxtaposition between the conventional and the creative leader, to the localization of their differentiations, to the reasoning around the benefits of creative leadership and the underlining of the increasing demand for creative leaders for the management of modern, complex crisis. Emphasis is attributed to the correlation between the effective and the creative leader, or, in other words, to the core idea that successful leadership is based on creativity. Special reference is attributed to the “achievement cycle”, its conceptual definition and its position within the research field of leadership, and of ideal organizational planning. The aspect of the second chapter which focuses on crisis management is essential. Crisis management is of quintessential significance especially for studying leadership, since it influences the correctness of decisions towards an immerging problem.The third chapter analyzes the concepts of environment and sustainability, preparing the fourth chapter, which includes the case study: the management of forest fires from public sector executives. Therefore, the third chapter develops the concepts of environmental management, sustainable development and environmental education. The environmental management is sub-structured in an economical, ecological and moral aspect. The privileges of an integrated environmental management system are discussed. The main environmental indicators are presented, along with the international environmental standards, according to which the ecologically sustainable organizations function. The third chapter aims to present the characteristics of an ecologically acceptable organization, and the pre-requisites it should meet in order not to be ecologically harmful, the pre-suppositions that refer to its existence. Furthermore, the third chapter analyzes the concept of sustainable management of organizations and the characteristics of their orientation towards sustainable development. This chapter constitutes the natural continuum of the previous chapter on leadership, since it attempts to highlight those characteristics in the vision of a leader and in the working frame of an organization that make it sustainable. The third chapter, finally, expands to environmental education, comprehending the role of education in the dissemination and consolidation of ecological mentality. The concepts of environmental education and of education for sustainable development are presented, identifying similarities and differentiations. The next chapter deals with the case study of forest fires within the frame of crisis management, attempting a holistic approach and providing a wide theoretical frame. The multidimensional nature of the phenomenon (of forest fires) is studied, starting with the demarcation of the concept “forest fire”. The chapter is structured based on the stages before, during and after the fires, suggesting a global study of the phenomenon in all its phases. The reasons for forest fires are categorized into human-caused and non human-caused, and are further ramified into complex sub-categories. The reasons are correlated with human-caused intentional actions, and also with accidental ones. Also, the chapter examines the social-economical parameters that lead to forest fires, the role of relevant Greek legislation, the structure of function in public organizations that involve with forest management and forest protection. Special reference is made for the methodology and the tools of preventing forest fires. The reference on the current technology for forest protection and fire extinction occupies an extensive position, since this technology forms an excellent auxiliary resource.Further, the concept of voluntarism is extensively presented, along with its available infrastructure in Greece, the frame of function, and its role for fire extinction. For the stage of fire extinction different, prevailing models are presented, emphasizing on the differences between the preventive and the interventional model. Special reference is made about the local communities that dwell in a proximity with forests and their role in forest protection. The consequences of forest fires extend from purely environmental to others that relate with economy, human psychology and social impact. The chapter is concluded with an extensive conclusion that attempts to resume the theoretical frame of forest fires, to focus on the essential parts and to provide a critical evaluation of the existing frame. The fifth chapter describes the methodological tools of the current thesis and theoretically supports why these tools were preferred over other alternatives. The aims of the research are described, as well as the criteria of choosing the sample (public sector executives), the criteria of data collection methodology (semi structured interview), the conditions of conducting the interviews, the geographic/political criteria of prefectures selection, the questions that served as a basis for the semi-structured interviews, the statistical software with which data was analyzed.The sixth chapter presents the results of the statistical editing of data, as they were processed after the transcription of the recorded interviews. The results are depicted with statistical tables and comparative graphs, as well as with commenting of the depicted findings. The point of comparison is the juxtaposition of the public sector executives (mayors) and their assistants (vice mayors).The seventh chapter follows the same structure with the sixth chapter, but the point of comparison is the juxtaposition among executives of insular and continental Greece.The last chapter presents the results as they accrue from the content analysis on the semi-structured interviews. From the statements and beliefs of the total sum of participants (executives and assistants from insular and continental Greece) many conclusions can be extracted mapping the general conceptions of public sector executives on the issue of forest fire management. In an attempt to present an abbreviated version of the research results in this abstract, it is worthwhile to highlight the following points: from the semi structured interviews, we proceeded into mapping the public sector executives’ attitudes and beliefs towards the phenomenon of forest fires. We attempted to locate the belief system executives hold regarding the institution of civil protection, the efficiency of its personnel, its adequacy in dealing with disasters, its level of ability to cooperate with other public services. The majority of the sample evaluates positively the institution of civil protection, expresses satisfaction regarding the efficiency of its personnel, state that they maintain a constructive cooperation with external, scientific partners. But, they claim that the institution remains immature and a great number of corrective interventions should occur, in order to secure the future unhindered function of the institution of civil protection. Also, the participants insist on the increasing of budget absorption for the institution of civil protection and they express their intense worrying, due to the current intense fiscal crisis. The participants also discussed the reasons of forest fire within their area. Specifically, they connected fires both with human-factored and non human factored forest fires. They separated between accidental and deliberate human actions. They enumerated among deliberate human actions, the one that aim to the illegal transformation of forestall land into buildable plot, or into pasture land. Also among the reasons for forest fires, they discussed the function of illegal waste lands and the illegal logging, which is expected to increase with the current fuel prices, unless the state actively prevents this. Last, among the reasons for forest fires, the participant mentioned the lack of national forest registry and the legal frame which does not prevent arbitrary actions. Focusing on the causes of forest fires, the participants were asked to comment the destructive fires in Attica prefecture (2009), during which the fire department didn’t know how to arrive on the burning field. During this conversation we underlined the specific causes for forest fires, such as the problematic protocol of communication among services, the vague frame of responsibilities, the delays due to the absence of a functional protocol of inter-service communication. It is interesting the fact that the participants covered in depth and width the causes behind forest fires, developing a complete theoretical prism. Since the present research is focused on the leadership theories aiming to approach crisis management, the participants were asked to comment how prepared they personally feel handling a crisis of a forest fire. They were asked to comment on the positive and negative parts of their role as managers of crisis. Specifically, the participants located the beneficial impact of modern technology, the role of voluntarism and of local community, the role of finely trained fire department personnel, and the role of their personal previous experience as executives. Among the negative parts they referred to the complex nature of the forest fire phenomenon, the aggravating climate conditions (dryness and intense winds), the insufficient funding, the shortages in equipment and staffing, and the weak role of the current legislation. Since the present thesis attributes focused role to creative and critical thinking during the practicing of leadership, the participants were asked to refer to which degree they trust their intuition and their experience respectively. The majority of the participants stated thay they trust their experience and they are hesitant regarding intuition. This contributes to the estimation that creative and critical thinking is exploited in a limited degree, with all the consequence for forest fire management. The public sector executives and their assistants were asked to discuss the preventive actions they organize in order to avoid forest fires. Within this frame we recorded measures of patrolling, water tanks, clearance of paths for facilitating vehicles pass-through, cleaning of dry grass, control towers, meteorological reports that warn on fire risk. Participants declared they fell worried with the insufficient preventive measures. They also stated that in Greece the emphasis is attributed to fire extinction, not to prevention, with tragic environmental and fiscal aftermaths. We note that the participants proved to be equally informed on both causes and preventive strategies for forest fires, without this meaning that this knowledge is implemented. The semi structured interview attempts to locate the suggestions of both executives and assistant executives regarding the improvement on forest fire management. Also, the interview examines their suggestions on changing currently applied practices. We observed an often overlapping of suggestions for the initiation of new practices and of suggestions for the abolishment of applied practices. This part of suggestions for initiation of new practices and for abolition of old practices is potentially the most interesting part of the research, at least concerning forest management issues. The participants suggested, among other things, the establishment of a national forest registry, the restructuring of the legal frame that refers to forest management and to the penalties for actions against the forest, the reform of the services that are in charge of forest management and fire extinction, the improvement of the protocol of communication and cooperation among services, the elimination of planning errors. Harmonization with the European aquis is suggested, including common exercises of Greek and other European forestall services. Also, what is further emphatically suggested is lifelong learning for the forestall personnel, and the adoption of modern technologies regarding fire prevention and fire extinction. We discussed methods for increasing the involvement of the private sector in forest management, through the provision of opportunities for sustainable exploitation. Within this frame, the correlation between profit and motives for forestall protection has been discussed. Participants coherently mentioned the necessity for mentality turnaround regarding attitude towards the forest, via primarily education, but also via media. The sample also mentioned the need to increase the cooperation with the scientific institutions, so that forestall management planning is the object not of political, but of scientific leadership. Also, the sample located the need for absorption of bigger budget for fire prevention, and not exclusively for fire extinction. During the conduction of the semi-structured interview, we attempted the identification and evaluation of the fire-detection equipment and forest protection, as well as its quantitative representation for the sample. Also, we discussed thoroughly the role of voluntarism and the strategies of its reinforcement and optimal exploitation.Also, we studied the followed practices for the protection of fire affected citizens, the detection of the fixed measures the state undertakes to assist them, and the presentation of the suggestions for improving these measures. We analyzed the methods of burnt forest restoration and the nature and goal of anti-erosive and anti-flood measures; we discussed the optimal scenaria, the necessity of adopting scientific planning and the necessity of legislatively imposed protection of burnt lands, so that possible arbitrary actions will be prevented. Finally, an epilogue was attempted for each semi-structured interview, based on a question about the global planning of forest fires management, for all three phases: the phase of prevention, the phase of fire extinction and the phase of recovery. In this last question the participants were given an opportunity to locate the key concepts for planning. After the apposition of references that were studied for the completion of the present study, an annex follows with the legislation on forest protection, as well as a glossary of terms that correlate to forest fires. We note that the chapter of forest fires includes a critical evaluation of the legislation on forest protection and management.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of the Aegean
Year dc:date
2013

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Παπαδομαρκάκης, Ιωάννης

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/28528

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Παπαδομαρκάκης, Ιωάννης. Επιστήμες της αγωγής και δημιουργική επίλυση προβλήματος: στάσεις στελεχών δημόσιας διοίκησης σχετικά με τη διαχείριση κρίσεων: συγκριτική μελέτη. University of the Aegean, 2013. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/28528