Abstract
dc:descriptionThe research hypothesis of the dissertation pertains to the general issue of the relationship between literature and ethical thinking. It focuses on the possible contribution of literature to the expansion and cultivation of moral or ethical knowledge. Exploring this dimension of the ancient quarrel regarding the relations between philosophy and poetry, first thematized by Plato, in contemporary terms, the dissertation aims to highlight the cognitive background of the relationship in question, to exemplify the peculiar features of the contribution of literature to ethical knowledge and to examine the role of empathy in this process. The dissertation deals with the main arguments of contemporary philosophers in the Anglo-American analytic tradition who adopt a certain stance towards the two areas of moral reflection and literary expression. These philosophers dwell on the most crucial parameters of the modern debate, displaying a positive attitude towards the contribution of literature to both ethical knowledge, broadly interpreted, and to the theoretical discussions of moral philosophy. The analysis proposed, involves the comparative study of their central positions in the light of the recent critical reception of their work. The first part of the dissertation provides a thorough presentation of their theories and an attempt at an assessment of the arguments for and against their basic claims, in the context of the debate concerning the relations between literature and moral thought. It leads to certain conclusions which are further evaluated and elaborated in order to refine the articulation of the philosophical premises of the dissertation. With respect to the methodological approach to be adopted special attention is given to the writings of Martha Nussbaum who has largely contributed to the revival of the ancient quarrel in modern terms, through the development of her thesis recognizing a cognitive content in emotions considered as evaluative judgments, and, more generally, through her extensive studies of Aristotelian moral philosophy and of its possible applications to the ethical construal and criticism of modern literature. The dissertation examines also the theories defended by Colin McGinn, Alison Denham, Noël Carroll and Alice Crary, who acknowledge a cognitive content in literature, defending either strong (McGinn) or moderate (Denham, Crary) versions of moral realism and cognitivism. Moreover, the positive appraisal of these theories is accompanied by the critical examination and rejection of non-cognitivist accounts of literature, such as the "no-knowledge theory" put forth by Peter Olsen and Stein Haughom Olsen, as well as Richard Posner's relativist assaults against the prospect of drawing any ethical conclusions from the study of literature. All the above considerations contribute to the elucidation of the philosophical tools making possible the formulation of the basic positions of the participants in the modern debate and the orientation of the research pursued in the dissertation within the framework of contemporary philosophical discussions. The ethical reading of particular realistic novels of the 19th and the 20th centuries, by Charlotte Brontë, Alexander Papadiamantis, Ian McEwan and Nick Themelis, drawing on the conclusions reached in the first part of the dissertation, constitutes the second part. It reveals the way literature may contribute to the testing of philosophical projects. More particularly it helps disclose the salient role of empathy in the expansion and refinement of ethical knowledge. The results of the critical discussions summarized above are the following: A) Ethics and literature are able to communicate against the background of extended notions of objectivity and rationality which include emotions construed as rational modes of thinking while also expressing feeling. Thus, one can ascertain the cognitive contribution of literature to ethical thinking by means of the appropriate study of the emotions conveyed to the readers who are able to experience and "re-enact" them. B) The ethical research in realistic novels in the second part of the dissertation makes possible the confirmation and explication of the contribution of empathy not only as an expected reader's response to the plot of the story but also through a study of the results of exercising or failing to exercise empathy by the heroes of novels in their fictional lives. C) Ethical knowledge becomes enriched by literature, thanks to the double function of empathy in it, explored and defended in the dissertation. Empathy on the one hand extends the phenomenological repertoire of ethical stances and reveals the beliefs and values which inspire them, and on the other confirms the presence of a shared human nature which can function as a basis for the coexistence and eventually the convergence and the synthesis of a variety of ethical beliefs in a liberal and pluralistic spirit.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2012
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Μελαχροινού, Χριστίνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Παλαιά διαμάχη
- Ενσυναίσθηση - φαντασιακή ενσυναίσθηση
- Ηθική γλωσσολογία - Ηθικός ρεαλισμός
- Συναισθήματα ως αξιολογικές κρίσεις
- Πέπλο ετερότητας
- Μινιμαλιστική αλήθεια
- Ρεαλιστικό μυθιστόρημα
- Θεματοποίηση της ενσυναίσθησης στο ρεαλιστικό μυθιστόρημα
- Ancient quarrel
- Empathy - imaginary einfuhlung
- Ethical cognitivism - Ethical realism
- Emotions as moral judgments
- Veil of ignorance
- Minimalistic truth
- Realistic novel
- Empathy as a subject in realistic novel
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/28571