National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Pandemonium management: a perspective on managerial decision making
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn this thesis, a perspective is proposed linking managerial decision making with Selfridge's Pandemonium model of perception. The methodology followed consists of (a) extensive review of the relevant international literature on which the theoretical construct of the thesis was based, (b) field research to test hypotheses related to significant parts of the theoretical construct, and (c) a case study composed to illustrate the proposed model of managerial decision making. It is argued that, in modern organizations, managerial decision making takes place mostly in teams which transform individual beliefs and opinions into team decisions. The way they do this is debated, as is their overall advantage-or lack of it-vs. individuals deciding in solitude. A managerial team's main function is to make sense of a multitude of inputs and fuse a variety of opinions (including, notably, dissent) into a decision possessing the characteristics of effectiveness (good-enough), efficiency (fast-enough), and consensus of an appropriate level (acceptable-enough). In performing its function, a managerial decision making team resembles to Selfridge's pandemonium whereby hosts of agents (demons) try to decipher incoming stimuli and persuade one-another of their interpretation of such stimuli. By comparison, members of managerial decision making teams weigh information received from sources, both external and internal (i.e. other team members), based on their perception of the expertise and bias of such sources. Political bias gets in the way of expressing one's true beliefs and opinions in management pandemoniums. A management pandemonium can be seen as a 'lens' that helps scattered pieces of information and divergent viewpoints converge into a (partial) consensus decision, through dialogue and the interplay of informational and normative influence between team members. Appropriate team size, cognitively rich team composition, and free communication are positive factors to management pandemoniums. Empirical evidence is presented indicating, counter-intuitively, that the elaboration on team members' expertise and bias during team deliberations affects managerial decision efficiency very negatively, lowers consensus, and adds nothing to decision effectiveness. Then, a realistic business case is narrated to illustrate the many facets of management pandemoniums. Finally a normative pandemonium management model is proposed, drawing from the entirety of the preceding discussion.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2010
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kokkalakis, Nikolaos
- Κοκκαλάκης, Νικόλαος
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Πανδαιμόνιο
- Διευθυντικές αποφάσεις
- Αποτελεσματικότητα αποφάσεων
- Αποδοτικότητα αποφάσεων
- Συναίνεση αποφάσεων
- Εξειδίκευση
- Γνωστική μεροληψία
- Πολιτική μεροληψία
- Pandemonium
- Managerial decisions
- Decision effectiveness
- Decision efficiency
- Decision consensus
- Expertise
- Cognitive bias
- Political bias
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Μηχανολόγου Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Mechanical Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/28716