National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Μέτρηση αποδοτικότητας των ελληνικών κέντρων υγείας - περιφερειακών ιατρείων: η περίπτωση της περιφέρειας Πελοποννήσου, Δυτικής Ελλάδας, Ηπείρου και Ιονίων Νήσων
Abstract
dc:descriptionBackground:The measurement of technical efficiency in healthcare delivery has become common practice internationally and is gaining ground in Primary Health Care (PHC). The most well-founded version of this approach is a linear programming tool referred to as Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). Perhaps the most significant of the proposed extensions to DEA is the concept of better specification of the model of inputs-outputs and their relative weights, so as to incorporate the dimensions of severity and quality. Objectives of the study:.1.To create a model that identifies the key inputs and outputs of the Greek rural and semi-urban HCs and estimates their relative importance (weights) on their production function..2.The application of this model on the measurement of the total technical efficiency (TE), pure technical efficiency (PTE) and scale efficiency (SE) efficiency of the public HCs of the 6th Health Prefecture of Greece, which covers the southern and western parts of the country..3.The running of a second stage analysis to explore the effects of a serious of internal and external factors on the efficiency scores of the HCs.Methods:.1.The production of the model of inputs-outputs was fulfilled through two multi-discipline panels of experts in Primary Health Care..2.The measurement of the 3 forms of efficiency was based on data from the 50 HCs-RPs of the Prefecture of Southern and Western Greece, gathered through a questionnaire. The weight-restricted technique ‘Assurance Region’ of Data Envelopment Analysis was applied in an output-oriented model, under constant (CRS) and variable (VRS) returns to scale..3.The study of the factors determining efficiency of Greek primary care units was based on the running of a second-stage DEA, using the DEA-produced efficiency scores of the HCs, and data for some other characteristics of the HCs gathered by the same questionnaire. A series of statistic correlation tests and regression analysis techniques were applied.Results:According to the results of the Delphi study, key inputs into the production function of the Greek HCs is the size of their staff (physicians, registered nurses / allied health professionals) and their technological infrastructure (medical equipment and laboratories), whereas key outputs are the ‘Greek Ambulatory Patient Groups (APGs)’. The Task Force Meeting attributed appropriate weights to the selected inputs and outputs.From the 42 HCs which provided complete and trustworthy data, the study identified nine (9) as technical efficient (PTE), five (5) as scale efficient (SE) and two (2) as total efficient (TE). The mean total efficiency, pure efficiency and scale efficiency scores of the HCs of the 6th Health Prefecture were 0.57, 0.67 and 0.87, respectively. The majority of the Health Centres function under decreasing returns to scale (DRS). Most of the technical efficiency units are situated in Western Greece.In the second stage analysis, distance to the nearest hospital (expressed in time) and population density were found to independently predict technical inefficiency of the HCs. More specifically:.¬The highest the distance of a HC of the 6th Health Prefecture to a hospital, the lower its technical efficiency score..¬The biggest the size of its catchment population, the larger its technical efficiency score.DiscussionConcerning methodology, to my knowledge this is the first study in the international literature of primary healthcare that utilizes consensus methods to specify the input-output model, as well as the weights of the relevant variables. This study aims to extend the research on frontier efficiency measurement in Greek healthcare on two more grounds:It is the first Greek effort to incorporate data from the decentralized, provincial Rural Posts (RP), thus using the integrated structure of HC-RP as unit of analysis.It is the first study in Greek PHC that did not use –the often partial and unreliable- data routinely collected by the Greek health authorities, but data collected through a new questionnaire, constructed according to the results of panel analysis.As far as results are concerned, more of ¾ of total inefficiency of the HCs of the 6th Health Prefecture is attributed to pure technical inefficiency (PTE). A noteworthy number of facilities are under-performing to some extent. There is considerable variation in production levels between different primary care providers. On the contrary, most public PHC units are close to the optimal size, with scale inefficiency calculated to only 13%.The two most important parameters found to significantly influence technical efficiency are the size of the population (number of residents charged to the HC) and the distance to the nearest hospital (time to reach by car or boat). These factors account for health care need, accessibility to urban health care structures, and other demographic, socio-economic and cultural characteristics (like educational level and health consciousness). Interestingly, proximity to hospital seems to increase and not decrease demand for primary care services from HCs, possibly because secondary care provides specialist services (like surgeries and laboratory tests), which then require more frequent monitoring in primary care level.Conclusions:This study identified nine units as benchmarks concerning technical efficiency. These HCs could be used as a reference set for comparison and their production characteristics as efficiency targets for the less efficient ones. Further research on the less efficient units could reveal the sources of clinical and administrative inefficiencies.The study revealed two environmental factors as shaping the potential of HCs to produce outputs in a considerable extent. This knowledge can be used for major decisions concerning resource allocation and optimal service provision within Greek primary care system. This PhD thesis finally intends to build on the more general effort to evaluate healthcare services in Greece, by creating an objective, well-documented and useful tool for efficiency measurement.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2012
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Economou, Nikolaos
- Οικονόμου, Νικόλαος
Subjects
dc:subject × 17- Περιβάλλουσα ανάλυση δεδομένων
- Κέντρα υγείας
- Περιφερειακά ιατρεία
- Πρωτοβάθμια φροντίδα υγείας
- Αποδοτικότητα
- Αξιολόγηση
- Αγροτικές περιοχές
- Primary health care
- Data envelopment analysis
- Efficiency measurement
- Health centres
- Rural Greece
- Evaluation
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Health Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/29476