National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η επίδραση της διόρθωσης της μυωπίας με τη μέθοδο της Laser in situ κερατοσμίλευσης στην ποιότητα της ζωής των χειρουργηθέντων
Abstract
dc:descriptionAim: To estimate the quality of life (QOL) outcomes of LASIK using the Quality of LifeImpact of Refractive Correction (QIRC) questionnaire.Material and methods: The Greek version of the pre-validated QIRC questionnaire,specific for refractive error was used. Translation of the QIRC questionnaire from Englishto Greek followed standard international protocols. The questionnaire was completed by190 subjects, aged 18 to 39 years with myopia (range: -0.75 to -8.5 diopters) andcorrected distance visual acuity (CDVA) of logMAR 0.2 or better (Snellen equivalent20/32) in the worse eye. Half of this sample underwent LASIK with femtosecond laserflap creation and ablation with the Visx Star S4 IR excimer Laser. The questionnaire wasself administered. The determination of entry into the control or surgery group was onthe basis of patient election for refractive surgery. The control group was drawn fromoptometric practice and consisted of people interested to be operated later than thesurgery group. It was purposively recruited to match the surgery group in theproportions of spectacle and contact lens wearers. The QIRC questionnaire consists of20 questions with 5-category response options plus 'not applicable’. QIRC questionnairecovers items like: visual function, symptoms, convenience ,concerns and 'well-being'.Patient’s category responses are converted into known Rasch-scaled values generated inthe QIRC development study.These Rasch values are fit to a 0-100 scale and areaveraged to produce an individual’s QIRC score. In all questions, higher scores representbetter QOL. The content of questions 1-13 represent visual function, symptoms,convenience and concerns whilst the remaining questions from 14-20 represent ‘wellbeing’.The original questionnaire was validated by using traditional methods and Raschanalysis in patients with refractive correction by spectacles, contact lenses, andrefractive surgery in a pre-presbyopic age group. The study followed the tenets of theDeclaration of Helsinki and was approved by the University’s ethics committee.Quantitative variables are expressed as mean values ±SD. Qualitative variables areexpressed as absolute and relative frequencies. Chi square and Fisher’s exact tests wereused for the comparison of proportions. All variables were tested for compliance with aGaussian distribution by inspection and the Kolmogoroff-Smirnoff test. Student’s t-testswere used for the comparison of normally distributed variables whereas the non319parametric Mann-Whitney test was used for non-Gaussian distributed variables.Comparisons before and after the surgery were made using Wilcoxon signed rank tests.All reported p values are two-tailed. Statistical significance was set at p<0.05 andanalyses were conducted using SPSS statistical software (version 17.0).The psychometric properties of the QIRC questionnaire were evaluated. Internalconsistency reliability was determined by the calculation of Cronbach's α coefficient.Reliability equal to or greater than 0.70 was considered acceptable. The extent of anyfloor (minimum answer given for all questions) and ceiling effects (maximum answergiven for all questions) was tested based on the percentages of scores at extremes ofthe scaling range. Repeatability was assessed by Intra-class correlation coefficients(ICCs) and Bland-Altman 95% confidence intervals (CI) for limits of agreement (LOA).ICCs between 0.41-0.60 indicate moderate agreement, 0.61-0.80 good agreement andover 0.80 excellent agreement. Spearman's correlation coefficients (r) were computedbetween the items in order to evaluate convergent validity. Correlation coefficientbetween 0.1 and 0.3 are considered low, between 0.31 and 0.5 moderate and over 0.5high. Construct validity testing was designed to identify differences in item scores andtotal scores between groups which were expected to be different. These groups werethe control and surgery group, and spectacle and contact lens wearers. Theseexpectations were based on previous studies which have suggested that people whoelected not to undergo refractive surgery may have better QOL than those who elect toundergo surgery. Similarly, previous studies have shown that contact lens wearers havebetter refractive error-related QOL than spectacle wearers. Responsiveness to changewas evaluated by using the effect size(ES). Multiple regression analysis was used todetermine factors predictive of change in scores for the 20 questions. Factors includedwere gender, age, preoperative refractive error, visual acuity before surgery, overallhealth level and preoperative QIRC score. Rasch analysis indicators of psychometricperformance are not reported because Rasch scores were derived by assignment ofRasch measures to response categories as described above. The QIRC questionnaire haspreviously been shown to perform well on all Rasch analysis derived indicators ofpsychometric performance.320Results: The questionnaire was completed by 190 subjects. Half of this sampleunderwent LASIK with femtosecond laser flap creation and ablation with the Visx Star S4IR excimer Laser. The two groups were similar in most characteristics but the proportionof men was significantly greater in the surgery group. No ceiling effects were seen onthe QIRC score as all the groups had 0% scoring at the maximum. A small floor effect(1.1%) was found for spectacle wearers in the surgery group, which represents oneperson giving the minimum score for all questions. The results of this study are asfollow:1. Total score of QIRC questionnaire was increased from a mean of 38.9±5.7 to53.7±5.1 (p<0.001).2. There was a great improvement in QOL for all QIRC items (p<0.001) indicatingimprovement in QOL. The most significant change (more than 25 units) was onitem related to "difficulties in swimming", and "seeing on waking".3. Before surgery, women reported worse total QIRC score (mean 37.2±5.6) thanmen (40.1±5.4), p<0.001. For individual questions women reportedworse QIRC score on items related to driving in glare conditions (p<0.01) and 3of 7 items in the well-being domain (p<0.05).4. In both control patients and surgery patients, total QIRC score was greater forthose wearing contact lenses compared to those wearing spectacles (p<0.01).5. Comparing the pre-surgery group and control group, the pre-surgery groupreported worse QOL on 3 convenience items (p<0.05), 1 health concern item(p<0.05), and 2 of 7. well-being items (p<0.05). There were no differences on14 items or the overall score. This small difference between the groups is notsurprising since both groups were presenting for refractive surgery, the onlydifference being the choice to proceed.6. Women in control group reported higher score than women before surgery onitems: “How much trouble is having to think about your spectacles or contactlenses or your eyes after refractive surgery before doing things; e.g. travelling,sport, going swimming?”, “How concerned are you about having to increasinglyrely on your spectacles?”, “During the past month, how much of the time haveyou felt that you thing others see you the way you would like them to?”7. Men in control group reported higher score than men before surgery onitems: “How much trouble is having to think about your spectacles or contact321lenses or your eyes after refractive surgery before doing things; e.g. travelling,sport, going swimming?”, “How concerned are you about your vision not beingas good as it could be?”, “During the past month, how much of the time haveyou felt confident?”8. The Greek version of QIRC had good internal consistency reliability. Inter-itemcorrelations were all significant (p<0.001), ranging from 0.32 to 0.79. Repeatabilitywas high (Bland-Altman limits of agreement were -6.72 to +5.41 and ICCfor the total score was 0.98. The effect size was 2.8 units for men and 2.9 forwomen. All items showed statistical significant changes in scores after surgery(p<0.001) and responsiveness to change of all items was large. Effect size formen was 2,8 and for women 2,7.9. Patients with corrected distance visual acuity of logMAR 0.0 had biggerimprovement in quality of life (3.43 units more) than those with logMAR (0.1-0.2). The better the preoperative total QIRC score the bigger the improvementin quality of life after surgery. The better the preoperative overall health levelthe less the improvement in quality of life after surgery.Discussion - Conclusion1. Femtosecond-assisted LASIK led to a great improvement in quality of life for allQIRC items (p<0.001), and the total score. Similar results we had in otherstudies of QOL by using microkeratome-assisted LASIK. In the study ofGaramendi et al overall QIRC score was improved after microkeratome-assistedLASIK from a mean ±SD of 40.07±4.30 to 53.09±5.25 (p<0.001). These twostudies show a similar mean improvement of the total score: Garamendi et al13.02±6.78 whilst in this study 14.8±7.64 (statistical significance of thedifferences, p=0.132). This suggests that femtosecond-assisted LASIK causes anequivalent improvement of QOL compared with microkeratome-assisted LASIK(using the Techolas 217 (v2 9997; Bausch & Lomb), the Hansatomemicrokeratome (Bausch & Lomb Surgical), and non-customized ablation).Recentmeta-analysis also suggests an equivalence between technologies.2. The results of the studies differ in the number of individual questions thatimproved with surgery: all 20 in our study, but only 15 in the Garamendi et al322study with notably no change for visual function or symptoms. This suggeststhere may be a gain in QOL within these domains for the new technology.3. There were noted gender-related differences. This is consistent with the study ofGaramendi et al, where women before surgery reported also significantly worseoverall QoL (mean 39.06±4.54) than men (mean 41.68±3.51), p<0.05.However, after surgery Garamendi et al, found women had better QoL scorethan men (mean 53.83±5.46 compared with 49.39±5.94, p<0.005) but in ourstudy men and women were equivalent. In both studies the individual questionsthat were different between men and women were similar, being predominantlywell-being questions.4. In both control patients and surgery patients, total QIRC score was greater forthose wearing contact lenses compared to those wearing spectacles.5. The psychometric properties of the Greek QIRC largely mirror those of theEnglish language version. The Greek QIRC is free of ceiling and floor effects andhas excellent internal consistency reliability.6. Preoperative refractive error, visual acuity before surgery and the level ofgeneral health are predictive factors of the magnitude to change. QIRC isresponsive with large statistically changes in all scales after surgery.We propose that the use of femtosecond laser and wave front-guided ablation in thisstudy may be responsible for better results in visual function and symptoms questionsgiven this method carries less induced astigmatism and higher order aberrations (HOA)s.Certainly, customized wavefront ablation is effective in limiting the HOAs induced withsurgery and the femtosecond laser induces less HOAs than microkeratomes.The higher cost of the femtosecond laser used in our study, with a corresponding highercost of surgery could explain the higher male-to-female ratio in the surgery group (maleshaving higher incomes on average in Greece and more likely to be employed thanwomen). The higher rate of males may influence the overall QOL outcome results giventhat female patients report larger gains in refractive-error-related QOL with LASIK. Thisimplies that the gains in QOL for femtosecond-assisted LASIK seen in this study may beunderestimated.323The convenience sample used does not guarantee representativeness of the populationthat wears spectacles, contact lenses or is seeking refractive surgery, since there are norelevant epidemiological studies in Greece to estimate the generalizability of thedemographic characteristics of these groups of patients.Another limitation of this study is that QIRC questionnaire was developed for the prepresbyopiaage group and cannot be used in older population
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2012
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Meidani, Alexandra
- Μεϊδάνη, Αλεξάνδρα
Subjects
dc:subject × 19- Υποβοηθούμενη από laser φεμτοδευτερόλεπτου lasik
- Μυωπία
- Qirc ερωτηματολόγιο ( ελληνική εκδοχή)
- Ποιότητα ζωής
- Αξιοπιστία
- Εγκυρότητα
- Βαθμολογία ερωτηματολογίων με rasch ανάλυση
- LASIK
- Femtosecond laser - assisted LASIK
- Myopia
- Qirc questionnaire ( greek version)
- Quality of life ( QOL)
- Reliability
- Validity
- Rasch analysis scored questionnaire
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Health Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/29489