National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Συγκριτική μελέτη της υβριδικής εξωτερικής οστεοσύνθεσης και της συμβατικής εσωτερικής στη χειρουργική αντιμετώπιση των καταγμάτων των κνημιαίων κονδύλων
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe purpose of this study was the comparison, clinically and experimentally, of the adequacy of hybrid external fixation in relation to the internal in the surgical treatment of tibial condylar fractures. At first, was presentated a review of the anatomy and biomechanics of the knee joint, as well as informatons for the tibial condylar fractures, necessary for the comprehension of the surgical treatment details. Continuing, clinically, were evaluated the results of the treatment with open reduction and internal fixation (either using antiglide plate either cancellous screws) and were compared with the results of the application of hybrid external fixation combined with limited arthrotomy, in 60 tibial condylar fractures of all types, according to Schatzker’s classification. The following parameters were recorded: time of surgical procedure, time of postoperative hospitalization, time of starting the weight bearing on the affected extremity, complications, clinical and radiological evaluation of the knee. The clinical evaluation of the knee was accomplished with the Knee Society Score (KSS) and the postoperative radiological results were performed according to Rasmussen’s Radiological Score (RRS). The mean duration of postoperative follow-up was twelve months. Were recorded 60 cases: 39 males (65%) and 21 females (35%) with a mean age of 40,5 years (21 to 78 years). The motor vehicle accidents were the cause of 47 fractures (percentage 78,33%) of which 29 were due to pedestrian-vehicle drift, while the remaining of 13 (percentage 21,66%) was the result of falling from a height. All fractures were closed and none was associated with vascular or neurological injury of the knee. Among the 30 fractures that were treated with internal fixation, 5 fractures were of type I (16,66%), 7 of type II (23,33%), 4 of type III (13,33%), 6 of type IV (20%), 4 of type V (13,33%) and 4 of type VI (13,33%). Respectively, concerning the group of the 30 fractures treated with hybrid external fixation, 5 fractures were of type I (16,66%), 6 of type II (20%), 4 of type III (13,33%) 4 of type IV (13,33%) 6 of type V (20%) and 5 of type VI (16,66%). The average time of the surgical procedure was in the first case 101,9 minutes, while in the second 97,5 minutes. The average time of postoperative hospitalization was in the first case 4,2 days, while in the second 3,6 days. The average time of the starting of the weight bearing on the affected extremity was in the first case 9,8 weeks, while in the second 12,9 weeks. In the 30 cases treated with the method of internal fixation the postoperative radiological results were: 7 (23,33%) excellent, 13 (43,33%) good, 8 (26,66%) moderate and 2 (6,66%) poor, while the clinical results were: 18 (60%) excellent, 3 (10%) good, 3 (10%) moderate and 6 (20%) poor. In the 30 cases of hybrid external fixation application the equivalent radiological results were: 4 (13,33%) excellent, 12 (40%) good, 9 (30%) moderate and 5 (16,66%) poor, while the clinical results were: 12 (40%) excellent, 6 (20%) good, 1 (3,33%) moderate and 11 (36,66%) poor. In the 30 cases treated with the method of internal fixation the complications recorded were: in 1 patient (3,33%) superficial would infection, subsided with oral antibiotics and the meticulous care of the would without its debridement, in 2 (6,66%) patients pulmonary embolism, clinically and laboratory established, which was resolved with appropriate treatment, in 2 (6,66%) patients anteroposterior instability of the knee, which will require re-operation for the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament, in 7 (23,33%) patients knee stiffness, in 2 (6,66%) patients malunion of the fracture and it is expected that in eleven patients will occur posttraumatic arthritis over time. In the 30 cases treated with the method of hybrid external fixation the complications recorded were: in 5 patients (16,66%) pin tract infection, subsided with oral antibiotics without removal or replacement of any of the transfixion wires, in 1 (3,33%) patient pulmonary embolism, clinically and laboratory established, which was resolved with appropriate treatment, in 1 (3,33%) patient anteroposterior instability of the knee, which will require re-operation for the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament, in 4 (13,33%) patients knee stiffness, in 7 (23,33%) patients malunion of the fracture and it is expected that in sixteen patients will occur posttraumatic arthritis over time. The comparison of the results to the two types of methods of treatment was completed by statistical analysis. This demostrated that there was statistically no significant difference between the average times of surgical procedure, the average times of postoperative hospitalization, the complications, the radiological and clinical results. But the comparison of the average time of starting of weight bearing on the affected extremity of both fixation methods verified that significant statistical difference was present and showed that this time by the internal fixation method occurred at an earlier time than the hybrid external method by almost three weeks. Experimentally, in order to study the mechanical behavior of the two fixation systems (hybrid external and internal) under equal loading conditions, were used the finite element method (FEM). An anatomically accurate 3-D finite-element model of the knee was generated in a SOLIDWORKS (version 2010) software system after assembing and meshing procedures. The geometric information for this model was based on data from computed tomography (CT) scans. Thus, were used 38 of a total of 144 CT images obtained of an 40-years old male’s knee. The slice thickness of the scan was 2 mm. The boundaries of the discrete areas were noted through points which are used as the basis for creating splines at the level of each section. It should be noted that the 38 sections resulted to a total of 1520 points. The multiline strings were deployed in space and by using the loft command were converted to a three-dimensional model. Consequently, by recomposing the 3D images, the model of the knee was created. Then, the six different types of fractures were designed on the model, according to Schatzker’s classification, and the osteosynthesis materials were designed in a linear 3D aximetric representation, as well as in photorealistic form. Through the proper use of the SOLIDWORKS commands, the osteosynthesis materials were placed on the knee – tibia model. The next step was the creation of the mesh. From the library of the software, the type of finite element was selected for the discretisation of the model; this must allow the realistic representation of objects, and, as a result, it must have enough nodes in order to follow the curvature of the lines while approaching their geometry. The finite element selected is tetrahedral, tetranodular with three degrees of freedom per node. Consequently, six solid meshes were developed with internal fixation and six with hybrid external, with a different number of elements and nodes in them. In the present study, both the bone and the osteosynthesis materials were considered isotropic, with linear elastic behavior. In regards to the cortical bone, the Young modulus defined was Ε=17.4 GPa while the Poisson’s ratio was ν=0.3 and the respective values for the trabecular bone were Ε=0.96 GPa and ν=0.2. The osteosynthesis materials were titanium alloys, with Ε=105 GPa and ν=0.3. In regards to the analysis, which was static, conditions of non-traction and non-impregnation between the cooperating elements were assumed, i.e. every node connecting the osteosynthesis materials between them and with the bone was constrained, while also were completely constrained the degrees of freedom of the nodes at the distal end of the meshes. In the elements of the upper extremity of the model, a resultant axial compressive load equal to 1000 N was applied. The results coming from the resolution procedure refer to the field of values of Von Mises equivalent stresses and strains, as well as to the displacement values on a resultant of axis. It was observed that the values of the maximum equivalent Von Mises stresses developed in models with type I, IV and VI fracture, with internal fixation, were less than the stress values of the respective models using hybrid external. On the other hand, the values of the maximum equivalent Von Mises strains were lower in the models with type I, II and VI fractures with internal fixation. Comparing the values of maximum displacements, it was found that they were reduced in the models with internal fixation, in regards to every fracture type, save from type III, which means a decrease stiffness and therefore less stability of the complex hybrid external-bone, in these types of fractures. The internal fixation confers postoperative stability, which is one of the most decisive factors affecting the quality of the result, but requires an extensive approach, necessary to apply the plate, and, in consequence, may increase the severity of the soft tissue injury. For this reason, the hybrid external fixation is an acceptable alternative method for the treatment of tibial condylar fractures.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2012
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Malakasi, Apostolia
- Μαλακάση, Αποστόλω
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- ΚΑΤΑΓΜΑΤΑ ΚΝΗΜΙΑΙΩΝ ΚΟΝΔΥΛΩΝ
- Υβριδική εξωτερική οστεοσύνθεση
- Ανοικτή ανάταξη και εσωτερική οστεοσύνθεση
- Φόρτιση του σκέλους
- Μέθοδος πεπερασμένων στοιχείων
- TIBIAL CONDYLAR FRACTURES
- Hybrid external fixation
- Open reduction and internal fixation
- Weight bearing
- Finite element method
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Clinical Medicine
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/29576